Case Dismissed In Cleveland In Mysterious Death Of Marsha Brantley

Monday, February 5, 2018
The state on Monday in Cleveland decided not to go forward with murder charges against Donnie Ray Brantley whose wife's body has never been found. He is shown with his daughter and attorneys Janie Varnell and Lee Davis.
The state on Monday in Cleveland decided not to go forward with murder charges against Donnie Ray Brantley whose wife's body has never been found. He is shown with his daughter and attorneys Janie Varnell and Lee Davis.

On the eve of a cold case murder trial in Cleveland, District Attorney General Steve Crump on Monday morning announced that charges were being dismissed against Donnie Ray Brantley in the mysterious death of his wife, Marsha Brantley.

Ms. Brantley disappeared in 2009 and her body has never been found. She was 52 and worked at Lee College (now University).

DA Crump said Chattanooga attorney Lee Davis had raised issues of territorial jurisdiction and he indicated that Judge Andrew Freiberg appeared to be swayed by the defense argument.

DA Crump said on Saturday he concluded "that this case might never get to a jury." He also cited a recent ruling on a similar issue in McMinn County that went against the state. 

He said he took the action "with a very heavy heart."

Judge Freiberg told Brantley, "You are free to go." He had been free on bond.

DA Crump said the case may not be over and that it has been assigned to the Cold Case Unit.

He said, "We are not finished with this case."

Attorney Davis said he believes his client is innocent, and he said he welcomes the probe by the Cold Case Unit. He said he believes it will come to the same conclusion.

He said, "In this unusual case the state has no proof of a crime. The state charged Donnie Brantley with first-degree murder. And yet the state has failed to produce any physical evidence that Ms. Brantley is dead, much less murdered: there is no body, no crime scene, and no forensic evidence of any kind. There are no witnesses to a crime. No confessions. In short, there has been no evidence presented to me that an crime alleged has in fact been committed at all, much less that it was committed with premeditation by Mr. Brantley in Bradley County, Tennessee." 

Brantley stood outside the Bradley County Justice Center briefly with his defense team and his daughter, Elise, who said she was elated by the decision.  

Brantley was first arrested in 2013. He said at the time that his wife had left him and he was planning on getting a divorce.

It was later decided to drop the case in order to gather more evidence.

Brantley was arrested again on the murder charge in December 2016, though authorities did not say what new evidence had emerged.

At the time of the re-arrest, DA Crump said, “The Bradley County grand jury, in its October term, returned an indictment against Donnie Ray Brantley for first-degree murder in the premeditated murder of Marsha Brantley.

“It is our belief, and the grand jury found, that between the first day of May 2009, and the 31st of May 2009, that he committed the act that led to her death, and that that act was done in a premeditated and deliberate fashion.”

 

He also said, “I believe I have satisfied my professional responsibilities and that the case that was presented to the grand jury will be persuasive, but again that is the jury’s province, and I will leave it to them.” 

 

Brantley was living in Cartersville, Ga., when he was re-arrested.

 

A crew from the CBS News program 48 Hours is in town filming the trial.

 

A number of other media outlets were at the courts building.

 

Jury selection had been set to start on Monday morning and jurors were present. They were dismissed prior to the district attorney announcing his decision.

 

Attorney Davis said he had been prepared to try the case after spending months rounding up witnesses from Ohio, Kentucky, Tennessee, North Carolina and Georgia.

 

 

 


Marsha Brantley
Marsha Brantley

Chattanooga Man Indicted On 4 Counts Of Rape Of A Child

Trenton Man, 29, Charged With Having Sex With 16-Year-Old Chattanooga Girl

Investigation Finds There Was No Threat To Soddy Daisy Middle School Student


A Chattanooga man has been indicted on four counts of rape of a child. The charges were brought against Maurice Ladell Davis, 29. It says the alleged incidents involved a child between ... (click for more)

A 29-year-old Trenton, Ga., man has been charged with having sex with a 16-year-old Chattanooga girl. Bobby James Walter Black, of 2780 Highway 136, was charged with aggravated statutory rape. ... (click for more)

An investigation found there was no threat to a Soddy Daisy Middle School student as was rumored, authorities said. On Monday a Soddy Daisy Middle School administrator was made aware of an ... (click for more)


Breaking News

Chattanooga Man Indicted On 4 Counts Of Rape Of A Child

A Chattanooga man has been indicted on four counts of rape of a child. The charges were brought against Maurice Ladell Davis, 29. It says the alleged incidents involved a child between the ages of four and 12 and it occurred in the defendant's bedroom. Davis has an extensive criminal record, including a charge of attempted first-degree murder in 2008. He received a suspended ... (click for more)

Trenton Man, 29, Charged With Having Sex With 16-Year-Old Chattanooga Girl

A 29-year-old Trenton, Ga., man has been charged with having sex with a 16-year-old Chattanooga girl. Bobby James Walter Black, of 2780 Highway 136, was charged with aggravated statutory rape. Authorities said they began investigating a report by a school counselor where the girl attends. A Child Protective Services worker filed for emergency temporary custody of the girl, ... (click for more)

Opinion

Thanks To First Volunteer Bank

Thank you to the Highway 58 branch of First Volunteer Bank. On behalf of the Ernie Pyle Chapter of the Military Order of the Purple Heart, I would like to express our appreciation to the manager and staff of the HIghway 58 Branch of First Volunteer Bank for putting on a Veterans Day lunch in the lobby of your bank on Friday, Nov. 9. It was a cold and rainy day and Army, Marines ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: ‘Easy Eddie’ & Butch

Not an hour’s drive from where I now sit is one of the best restaurants in all of Tennessee. Its been some years since I last ate supper at High Point, a legendary mansion restored to elegance by the current owners but, back in the ‘60s, I got a wide-eyed teenager’s peek at the place one Sunday afternoon. What’s this? 14-inch walls filled with sand to stop a G-man’s bullet? Escape ... (click for more)

Sports

Lady Vols' Davis, Westbrook On Women's Naismith Trophy Watch List

The Atlanta Tipoff Club has released the 50 names on the 2019 Women's Citizen Naismith Trophy Watch List, and UT sophomores Rennia Davis and Evina Westbrook are among the candidates. The midseason 30 team will be announced on Feb. 11, 2019, and then the competition will be narrowed down to 10 national semifinalists on March 4, 2019. The four finalists will be named on March ... (click for more)

Pruitt Looks For Vols To Maintain Momentum

The Tennessee football team returned to the practice at Haslam Field Monday, coming off of its second win over a ranked opponent this season. Head coach Jeremy Pruitt, who became the first Tennessee head coach to defeat two ranked teams in his first season since Phillip Fulmer in 1993, reflected on the win over Kentucky and looked ahead to Saturday's home finale against Missouri ... (click for more)