Lawsuit Claims Construction Crew Came Onto Historic Farm Of Joe Engel, Knocked Down Baseball Artwork

Sunday, December 1, 2019

Two Hamilton County property owners who said they have worked to preserve the historical significance of the former Joe Engel estate have filed a lawsuit against Pratt Land & Development Company and James Wright Construction. The suit charges"illegally trespassing onto their property, damaging real property, destroying large growth trees, damaging their driveway, and taking historical pieces of artwork which included decorative baseballs formerly owned by Joe Engel, the long-time owner of the Chattanooga Lookouts and the visionary of the Historic Engel Stadium."

Plaintiffs, Phillip and Emily Goldberg, purchased the Historic Engel Property in 2017.  They said the eight-acre property located at 660 Julian Road "has been a historical piece of the East Brainerd community since the 1930’s and included Engel concrete baseballs which Joe Engel had commissioned as decorative artwork to show the significance of the property and reflect his love of baseball."

Attorney Bryan Hoss said, "On the morning of July 30, 2019, the plaintiffs claim that Pratt and Wright employees illegally trespassed onto their property driving heavy excavation equipment across the property, damaging landmark architecture, structure, and agriculture.  During the trespass, Pratt and Wright employees knocked down a no trespassing sign, demolished a trove of old growth trees, and dumped construction materials using the trespassed property as a dumping ground and parking lot.

Imagine coming to your property where you were going to build your dream house and finding your large shade trees, not just knocked down, but totally gone.  Stolen.  Imagine finding your driveway in bits and pieces. And your beloved Engel concrete baseballs stolen?

The lawsuit alleges that Pratt Development was told in the months prior of the importance of the property’s integrity. “My clients spent months telling Pratt and his employees about their property, their love for it, and the historical significance of the property including the landmark baseballs.  And in one fail swoop, the developers destroyed it,” said attorney Hoss.

The lawsuit alleges during the evening of July 30, 2019, James Pratt of Pratt Development was alerted of the damage. Attorney Hoss said, "This did not stop the developers from continuing their destruction. The next day, one of the parked excavation machines was moved over the plaintiff’s property which caused additional damage. The Plaintiffs found that the developers had flipped over and broken a historical stone fountain as well as the Plaintiff’s historical decorative baseballs were now missing.

"The defendant(s) had to offer their employees a cash reward for the return of the Engel baseballs.”

“A silt fence separated the two properties in question”, stated attorney Hoss, “Any reasonable developer would have seen the silt fence sitting about 100 yards away, and would have told their employees where the property line was located. The developers in this case only missed it by the length of a football field.” 

Bryan Hoss is a partner in the Chattanooga-based law firm Davis and Hoss.

The suit was filed in Circuit Court.


Police Blotter: Doller General Shoplifter Returns; Landlord Visits Tenants At 2 A.M.

2 Fugitives Arrested Friday Afternoon On Shallowford Road

Latest Hamilton County Arrest Report


A shoplifting was reported at the Dollar General, 2303 E. 23rd St. Police spoke with the store manager, who said an unknown black female had run out of the store with a trash bag full of items ... (click for more)

Detectives with the Hamilton County Sheriff’s Office Fugitive Division went to 6220 Shallowford Road on Friday at 2:45 p.m. to attempt to locate and arrest fugitives Shawn Cranfield, 42, and ... (click for more)

Here is the latest Hamilton County arrest report: ARNOLD, TAMI MARIE 1526 DALLAS LAKE ROAD HIXSON, 37343 Age at Arrest: 53 years old Arresting Agency: Hamilton County Booked for Previous ... (click for more)



Breaking News

Police Blotter: Doller General Shoplifter Returns; Landlord Visits Tenants At 2 A.M.

A shoplifting was reported at the Dollar General, 2303 E. 23rd St. Police spoke with the store manager, who said an unknown black female had run out of the store with a trash bag full of items without paying. The woman then fled in a white four-door sedan with a drive out tag. The manager estimated the value of items taken around $200. While working on the report at a separate location, ... (click for more)

2 Fugitives Arrested Friday Afternoon On Shallowford Road

Detectives with the Hamilton County Sheriff’s Office Fugitive Division went to 6220 Shallowford Road on Friday at 2:45 p.m. to attempt to locate and arrest fugitives Shawn Cranfield, 42, and Erika Bell, 29. Cranfield had outstanding Hamilton County warrants on the following charges: possessing a firearm with intent to go armed; possession of drug paraphernalia (x2), possession ... (click for more)

Opinion

Why Is All The New Building Not Saving Us From A 40-Cent City Property Tax Increase? - And Response

With the number of homes, apartments and condos built downtown, why is a 40 percent property tax increase necessary? Are these new structures on the paying property tax role? I need to know what’s going on downtown and why isn’t that money benefiting the city? Georgia Vaughn * * * The answer is that tax exemptions for these projects have been given out freely and ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: The Degradation Of Nurses

Debbie Moore-Black, is a registered nurse whose blogs regularly appear on the medical news website, KevinMD.com. With the unearthly demands of COVID and historic lack of concern for the nursing populace, she wrote this week on the degradation and the devaluation of the nation’s nursing force. Perhaps we should all listen: * * * TIME WILL TELL IF LESSONS WILL BE LEARNED ... (click for more)

Sports

Game Notes: Tennessee At Florida

Tennessee hits the road for the first time this season with a showdown against SEC East rival Florida in primetime on Saturday night in Gainesville. The Vols are coming off a 56-0 shutout of Tennessee Tech last weekend and will look to carry that momentum into Saturday as they look to spring the upset against the 11th-ranked Gators. BROADCAST INFO Saturday's game will be ... (click for more)

Covenant Women, Men Win Maryville Invitational

The Covenant cross country teams dominated the course at the Maryville Invitational Friday afternoon. The women came in first of five with 22 points in their 6k race, while the men were also first of five in their 8k race with 26 points. The women had three runners in the top five. Claire Mackes continued her stellar performance, coming in first place overall with her ... (click for more)