Tennessee Supreme Court Finds Case With Conflicting Evidence Cannot Be Decided Without Trial

Monday, July 22, 2019

The Tennessee Supreme Court has reversed an award of summary judgment and sent a contract dispute back to the trial court based on factual disputes about the parties’ intent to substitute a new contract for an existing one. 

A development company had contracted with a Nashville architect firm, TWB Architects, Inc., to design a condominium project in Ashland City.

The development company ran short of money and could not pay the architect fee. The Braxton, LLC, a subsequent owner of the project, entered into a contract with Timothy Burrow, TWB’s president and sole owner, to deed Mr. Burrow a penthouse condominium in the project instead of paying the architect fee. Braxton, however, did not fulfill the condominium contract because it had pledged the condominium as collateral for a construction loan. TWB sued Braxton in the Cheatham County Chancery Court to recover its unpaid architect fee. The trial court granted summary judgment to TWB, finding that TWB was entitled to its architect fee because there was insufficient evidence about whether the parties intended for the condominium contract to replace the original architect contract. The Court of Appeals affirmed.

In a unanimous opinion, authored by Justice Sharon G. Lee, the Tennessee Supreme Court reversed the trial court and the Court of Appeals, holding that there were disputed questions of fact about whether TWB and Braxton intended a novation when they entered into the agreement for Braxton to deed a condominium to Mr. Burrow. A novation occurs when the parties agree to substitute a new contract for an existing one. If a novation is established, the parties are no longer bound by the original contract, and their rights and obligations are determined by the new contract. After a novation, the parties cannot revert back to the original contract even if one party later breaches the new agreement. To establish a novation, a party must show an original valid contract; the parties’ agreement to a new contract; the extinguishment of the original contract; and a valid new contract.

At issue in this case was whether TWB and Braxton intended to extinguish the architect contract and be bound only by the condominium contract or whether the parties intended to be bound by the architect contract. The resolution of this issue would determine whether Braxton was required to pay TWB the architect fee under the original agreement. The Supreme Court found witness credibility problems and conflicting evidence about the parties’ intent on this issue. Thus, the Court held that summary judgment was inappropriate because this contract dispute cannot not be decided as a matter of law, and the trial court needs to hear witness testimony, resolve credibility issues, and then decide what the parties intended.

To read the opinion of the Court in TWB Architects, Inc. v. The Braxton, LLC, authored by Justice Sharon G. Lee, please visit the Opinions section of tncourts.gov. Oral arguments for this case were video recorded and are available on tncourts.gov under Supreme Court and Oral Argument Videos.


Access Garage Doors Expands Into South Raleigh Market

BBB Announces 2020 Torch Awards And Scholarship Winners

New Hamilton County Business Licenses


Access Garage Doors has expanded its growing company footprint into the south Raleigh market. Headquartered in Chattanooga, Access Garage Doors is a top-ranking authorized dealer for Liftmaster ... (click for more)

The Better Business Bureau Serving Southeast Tennessee and Northwest Georgia, celebrating its 60th anniversary year, announces the business winners of the BBB “Torch Award for Marketplace Ethics” ... (click for more)

Here are the new business licenses from the County Clerk's office: 4 CORNERS COURTNEY EVANS 3335 RINGGOLD RD STE 106 CHATTANOOGA TN 37412 ABSOLUTE HEATING & AIR LLC RON HAYNES 617 ... (click for more)



Business

Access Garage Doors Expands Into South Raleigh Market

Access Garage Doors has expanded its growing company footprint into the south Raleigh market. Headquartered in Chattanooga, Access Garage Doors is a top-ranking authorized dealer for Liftmaster Opener Systems, Clopay and Amarr Garage Doors. Their national headquarters employs 22 individuals who have over 100 years of combined experience to teach the entire business of installing ... (click for more)

BBB Announces 2020 Torch Awards And Scholarship Winners

The Better Business Bureau Serving Southeast Tennessee and Northwest Georgia, celebrating its 60th anniversary year, announces the business winners of the BBB “Torch Award for Marketplace Ethics” and “Student of Integrity” scholarship winners for 2020. Businesses recognized for the 2020 BBB Torch Award for Marketplace Ethics are: Category I Winner: Mr. Handyman of Chattanooga, ... (click for more)

Breaking News

Hamilton County Has Highest Number Yet Of Coronavirus Patients In Hospital; Tennessee Has 3,314 New Cases - A New Record For 1 Day

There are 74 coronavirus patients in Chattanooga hospitals - a new one-day high, Health Department officials said on Monday. Of that group, 39 are from Hamilton County. However, the number of Intensive Care Unit patients with the virus dropped to 15. Hamilton County had 52 new cases of coronavirus, but deaths remain at 38, officials said on Monday. The local case total is ... (click for more)

Dalton Municipal Court Suspends In-Person Sessions Due To Rise In COVID Cases

The City of Dalton’s Municipal Court is suspending in person court appearances through at least Aug. 12 in response to the recent increase in COVID-19 cases in Whitfield County and the northwest Georgia region. Payments for fines can still be made online or in person at the window in the Public Works building at 532 N. Elm Street. There will be no in person Municipal Court ... (click for more)

Opinion

Why I Will Not Be Voting For Commissioner Discretionary Spending

Most people that know me well know that I will not vote to reinstate the $900,000 commissioner’s discretionary spending of taxpayer money. My reasons are: 1. There could not be a worse economic time for the government to spend additional money. It’s time to tighten the belt of government spending and not expand it. All American families are having this conversation around their ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: Gracious! It’s A Comet!

There is a once-in-a-lifetime experience going on above us and it will put any child under the age of 99 years young absolutely in awe. On March 27, a NASA spacecraft known as NEOWISE (that stands for ‘Near-Earth Object Wide-Field Infrared Survey Explorer) was circling planet Earth in an effort to categorize as many asteroids as possible that are non-threatening yet orbit close ... (click for more)