Tennessee Supreme Court Finds Case With Conflicting Evidence Cannot Be Decided Without Trial

Monday, July 22, 2019

The Tennessee Supreme Court has reversed an award of summary judgment and sent a contract dispute back to the trial court based on factual disputes about the parties’ intent to substitute a new contract for an existing one. 

A development company had contracted with a Nashville architect firm, TWB Architects, Inc., to design a condominium project in Ashland City.

The development company ran short of money and could not pay the architect fee. The Braxton, LLC, a subsequent owner of the project, entered into a contract with Timothy Burrow, TWB’s president and sole owner, to deed Mr. Burrow a penthouse condominium in the project instead of paying the architect fee. Braxton, however, did not fulfill the condominium contract because it had pledged the condominium as collateral for a construction loan. TWB sued Braxton in the Cheatham County Chancery Court to recover its unpaid architect fee. The trial court granted summary judgment to TWB, finding that TWB was entitled to its architect fee because there was insufficient evidence about whether the parties intended for the condominium contract to replace the original architect contract. The Court of Appeals affirmed.

In a unanimous opinion, authored by Justice Sharon G. Lee, the Tennessee Supreme Court reversed the trial court and the Court of Appeals, holding that there were disputed questions of fact about whether TWB and Braxton intended a novation when they entered into the agreement for Braxton to deed a condominium to Mr. Burrow. A novation occurs when the parties agree to substitute a new contract for an existing one. If a novation is established, the parties are no longer bound by the original contract, and their rights and obligations are determined by the new contract. After a novation, the parties cannot revert back to the original contract even if one party later breaches the new agreement. To establish a novation, a party must show an original valid contract; the parties’ agreement to a new contract; the extinguishment of the original contract; and a valid new contract.

At issue in this case was whether TWB and Braxton intended to extinguish the architect contract and be bound only by the condominium contract or whether the parties intended to be bound by the architect contract. The resolution of this issue would determine whether Braxton was required to pay TWB the architect fee under the original agreement. The Supreme Court found witness credibility problems and conflicting evidence about the parties’ intent on this issue. Thus, the Court held that summary judgment was inappropriate because this contract dispute cannot not be decided as a matter of law, and the trial court needs to hear witness testimony, resolve credibility issues, and then decide what the parties intended.

To read the opinion of the Court in TWB Architects, Inc. v. The Braxton, LLC, authored by Justice Sharon G. Lee, please visit the Opinions section of tncourts.gov. Oral arguments for this case were video recorded and are available on tncourts.gov under Supreme Court and Oral Argument Videos.


Zeus Industrial Products To Expand In Chattanooga

Propex Receives 2019 Innovation Award

Chattanooga Startup Text Request Doubles Revenue, Triples Employee Headcount


Zeus Industrial Products, Inc. will invest $11.25 million to expand its Chattanooga operations and create 54 jobs over the next five years. Zeus has acquired and will renovate a 140,000-square-foot ... (click for more)

Last week PETROMAT Enviro, a paving fabric that easily mills and recycles, was awarded the 2019 Industrial Fabrics Foundation Innovation Award. “Innovation is what drives us,” said Mike ... (click for more)

Chattanooga-based software startup, Text Request, has doubled its annual recurring revenue and more than tripled its employee headcount since the close of 2018, all without taking a penny of ... (click for more)


Business

Zeus Industrial Products To Expand In Chattanooga

Zeus Industrial Products, Inc. will invest $11.25 million to expand its Chattanooga operations and create 54 jobs over the next five years. Zeus has acquired and will renovate a 140,000-square-foot facility at 3600 Cummings Road in Lookout Valley, where it will relocate its Hamilton County operations. Zeus manufactures precision polymer extrusions and custom tubing used in ... (click for more)

Propex Receives 2019 Innovation Award

Last week PETROMAT Enviro, a paving fabric that easily mills and recycles, was awarded the 2019 Industrial Fabrics Foundation Innovation Award. “Innovation is what drives us,” said Mike Gorey, CEO of Propex. “It’s a key part of our culture, and we will continue to invest in products and market development to ultimately offer our customers the best geosynthetic solutions. ... (click for more)

Breaking News

Man Shot In Shoulder By Officer After Domestic Disturbance Call At Charleston, Tn.

A man was shot in the shoulder by a police officer at Charleston, Tn., early Sunday after a domestic disturbance call. At approximately 2:02 a.m., Bradley County Sheriff’s Office deputies responded to a 911 call reporting a domestic disturbance between a male and a female involving a firearm near Laguna Drive in Charleston. The 911 call was made by a female reporting that ... (click for more)

Woman Injured In Red Bank House Fire Saturday Evening

A woman was injured in a house fire Saturday evening in Red Bank. A 911 call was made reporting a house fire at 133 Flora Circle. At 6:30 p.m., Red Bank Fire Department responded to the scene and arrived reporting heavy smoke and fire on the back of the residence. The Red Bank Fire Department immediately requested a mutual aid response for additional manpower. The Signal ... (click for more)

Opinion

Ignored By The Water Company

How much time do you spend at Tennessee American Water's website? It is worthless for online reporting problems. Replies? Never happen. Communication? They appear to consciously avoid honest communication with concerned citizens. This "Opinion Page" is an avenue of last resort to report a problem, because no one is trying to listen at Tennessee American Water. ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: The 1:59.40 Marathon!

First, we must tell the children, every little boy and girl must come. Anyone who has already started our next generation yet are less than only a few steps in their life’s race, must come. They must see. Yes, we who have nearly finished our distance or the promising millennials who are still in their climb, you too! We must call them and point to the picture of a 34-year-old they ... (click for more)