As a resident of one of the unincorporated areas, I want to address an issue that has been causing unrest among many of us who have chosen to make these areas our homes. We need to shed light on the regulation of short-term vacation rentals, especially in residential and A1 zones, and the lack of representation and protection for those of us residing in unincorporated regions. Additionally, I want to help others understand the stark differences between unincorporated areas and municipalities, highlighting the unique challenges and disparities faced by residents like ourselves.
Incorporated areas such as Collegedale, Lookout Valley, East Ridge and Red Bank possess the autonomy to enact their own rules and regulations regarding short-term vacation rentals. However, what often goes unspoken is the disparity in opportunities for voice and recourse between those living in incorporated municipalities and those in unincorporated areas.
Residents in unincorporated regions, like myself, lack the privilege of a dedicated commission or local government body to advocate for our interests and concerns. Our rules and regulations come directly from the Hamilton County commissioner, we do not have another agency to turn to. We do not have the luxury of municipal police or fire departments at our beck and call; instead, our fire services rely heavily on volunteers who selflessly serve our communities. Placing the burden of accommodating transient guests on these volunteers, who already dedicate their time and effort to ensure our safety, is simply unjust.
The allowance of Airbnbs and similar rentals in residential and A1 zones, while other commercial activities remain prohibited, is inherently discriminatory. It unfairly favors the interests of a few property owners over the collective well-being and desires of the entire community. It not only undermines the sanctity of residential zones but also undermines the efforts of small business owners who have adhered to zoning regulations and chosen appropriate locations for their enterprises. It is unfair to allow one type of commercial business in residential and A1 zones while actively keeping others out.
In light of these concerns, it is crucial for the Hamilton County Commissioners to recognize the unique challenges faced by residents in unincorporated areas and take decisive action to address them.
Colleen Kirk