It Is Outrageous That County School Administration Used Our Tax Dollars For Political Lobbying - And Response

Friday, May 24, 2019

Dear Dr. Johnson,


The campaign central at HCDE headquarters needs a Tennessee Little Hatch Act study time and education. The heart of the issue is that HCDE utilized our tax dollars to lobby against vouchers with employee time, equipment, and lobby payments.


Here is my point, I supported ESA vouchers for Hamilton County, and so did a lot of families that desired parental choice in school placement, including private.  The emails obtained from the server at HCDE clearly presents a full throttle political lobby with our tax dollars.  You and your staff spent our Hamilton County property tax dollars for political cause and issue campaigning.  I am certain HCDE is out of bounds with their political activity with our tax dollars.


When we the people have tax dollars mandated from us, there is expectation that the funds will be used for the intended purpose.  Every penny of public money sent to HCDE is for education, not political cause and issue work.


It is that simple.


The HCDE entered into agreement with an education lobby called CLASS for the sole purpose of ensuring the large school districts received their share of BEP funds from the state of Tennessee.

For participation in the collective lobby, HCDE paid $75,000 this year. The CLASS group is comprised of the largest school districts in the state. It was everyone’s understanding that this lobby was limited to BEP funding equity. HCDE took the political lobby to an entirely new level.


HCDE changed the CLASS pursuit to stopping vouchers with our public tax dollars, including my money.


I pored through emails acquired from HCDE for just one month. The emails are a testament to HCDE abuse of public tax dollars. HCDE ran a full throttle political lobby, and that is just one month  


Let’s analyze just one of those emails, because I am in a “twirl” over my property tax dollars diverted from the classroom to a private political issue campaign.


Example Email of Pollical Lobby by HCDE


“From: Johnson Dr. Bryan

To: Elizabeth Millsaps

Cc: Robert Gowan Subject: Re: Hamilton numbers - ESAs Date: Monday, April 15, 2019 10:03:32 AM


We continue to twirl. Thank you. I also met with Sen Watson Friday evening.


Sent from my iPhone On Apr 15, 2019, at 9:54 AM,


Elizabeth Millsaps <> wrote:


I just want to underscore what a testament it is to you and your team. He’s completely turned around his option of HCS since you came on board. He was one of our biggest obstacles because he had so little face in your predecessors. Thanks for your hard work and congratulations on a badge of honor!


Elizabeth Millsaps 615.310.1121 On Apr 15, 2019, at 6:42 AM,


Robert Gowan <> wrote:


Assume you saw that Gardenhire is a no on ESA. This is huge. And it sounds like he has a lot of confidence in you and your team. Also huge. Sent from my iPhone On Apr 11, 2019, at 5:23 PM, Robert Gowan <> wrote:

Dr. Johnson - We will talk about all of the information in this email and more during the conference call with the other CLASS district directors tomorrow at 3:15 eastern - but we wanted to touch base with you before then to see if you are planning to come to Nashville next week for the meeting with the Governor and when you are planning to be here. As you may have figured out, Hamilton County has become a focus of the voucher fight since Sen. Watson chairs finance. The voucher bill must have 6 votes to clear the Senate Finance Committee. We believe we have 5 no votes (Briggs, Gilmore, Hensley, Yager and Yarbro) and we are working to get one more no or a pass. Senators Watson, Haile and Stevens are our targets.”


HCDE Political Lobby Was About Keeping Millions


The majority of emails between you and HCDE School Board member Jenny Hill were all about loss of HCDE revenue due to vouchers. Not one of the HCDE emails from either one of you discussed the best interest of children trapped in the HCDE critical schools. HCDE emails speak volumes that the only HCDE concern was loss of the per child revenue. 


I am glad for the time I spent, I understand HCDE in their true light.


“1250 students in Hamilton County might take advantage of the ESA program 1,250 students  x $7,219 per voucher = $9,023,750


State payment: $4,602,112.50 [this would be reimbursed year one and possibly 3 years]


Hamilton County payment annually: $4,421,637.50 [ongoing and growing as students are added]”


Tennessee Little Hatch Act


I decided to take a look at whether public employees of county schools can engage in political lobby utilizing employee work time and equipment with so much zealous and “twirling.”


The State of Tennessee Attorney General described the Little Hatch act as applicable to county school employees,  he wrote,


“ The Little Hatch Act also seeks to prohibit the inappropriate use of public employees and property for political purposes. It prohibits teachers from using any building or land owned by a local education agency, including equipment and vehicles, for campaign or political advertising on behalf of any party, committee or candidate for partisan or nonpartisan political office.  Tenn. Code Ann. § 2-19-206(d)(2). It also prohibits any teacher employed by a local education agency from engaging actively in a political campaign on behalf of any party, committee, or candidate for partisan or nonpartisan public office, attending political meetings or rallies, or otherwise performing political campaign duties or functions during those hours of the day when the teacher is required to be performing school duties.  Tenn. Code Ann. § 2-19-207(c)(2).”


Tennessee Code Annotated is clear that HCDE buildings, equipment, and time for HCDE employees is not for political cause or issues. 


It is outrageous that HCDE used our property tax dollars for political lobby money to prevent Hamilton County vouchers, all to keep revenue from going to parental choice vouchers. It is only about money for HCDE.


I wanted to let you know that spending our tax dollars for political issue campaigns is completely unacceptable. Our public tax dollars are strictly for education. Diverting my money from the schools for political purposes is objectionable to me.


Read the Tennessee Little Hatch Act, Superintendent. It is time for your education.


April Eidson


* * *


Many parents who have the desire, and the financial means, decide to send their children to private school. For some it is a real sacrifice.


There are other parents who love their children just as much and want them to have a better chance at life but there is no way they can afford to send them to a better school. Their children are trapped with no way out.


The school vouchers were a way to make a way out possible for those underprivileged children. Why would the school administration, who say they want to give all children the same opportunities, spend taxpayers money on lobbying against the very thing that would do just that? The parents and children deserve an answer. 

Nancy Patty 

Sensitivity Training

Make Schools Individually Centralized

The Unfair Income Gap Between Teachers And Admin

As John Martin at WRCB reported on the story of the Tweets sent out on the EPB account I immediately began to be upset. In digesting this I now have to say that I am thankful for this one ... (click for more)

In my wildest dreams improving education of children I discovered something in my own work that might have validity today with costs of educating going up, not down. Let us begin with central ... (click for more)

The Hamilton County Education Department pay raise should be a fixed amount, not a percent, for all the employees. This would give the overpaid administrators a little, and the teachers and support ... (click for more)


Sensitivity Training

As John Martin at WRCB reported on the story of the Tweets sent out on the EPB account I immediately began to be upset. In digesting this I now have to say that I am thankful for this one who showed forth more faith than most so called Evangelical Christians. You may ask why and so let me tell you. First off the Bible tells us that in these last days that there will be ... (click for more)

Make Schools Individually Centralized

In my wildest dreams improving education of children I discovered something in my own work that might have validity today with costs of educating going up, not down. Let us begin with central office personnel. First and foremost there must be at least one leader, usually the school superintendent. An assistant is warranted if the school system is more then two to three schools. ... (click for more)

Breaking News

Tracy Calloway, 28, Dies After Being Shot Multiple Times On Trailwood Drive

Tracy Calloway, 28, has died after being shot multiple times on Trailwood Drive on Sunday afternoon. He had earlier been listed in critical condition at the hospital. At 2:13 p.m. , Chattanooga Police responded to a person shot call in the 4600 block of Trailwood Drive. U pon arrival, officers located the victim with multiple gunshot wounds as well as a vehicle that ... (click for more)

Girl, 16, In Critical Condition After Sunday Morning Rafting Accident On The Ocoee River

A 16-year-old girl was listed in critical condition at a Chattanooga hospital after a rafting accident on the Ocoee River. The incident happened around 10 a.m. on Sunday on a trip by Quest Expeditions. The girl was reportedly on life support. Ryan Cooke, president of the Ocoee River Outfitters Association, said, "I would like to extend my sincere sympathy to the family ... (click for more)


UTC's Tiano, Lawson At SoCon Media Days Monday

The 2019 Southern Conference Football Media Day is set for Monday, July 22, in Spartanburg, S.C. Representatives from all nine football playing schools in the league will be on hand for the afternoon of interviews and discussions leading into the 2019 season. Senior quarterback Nick Tiano and junior defensive back Jerrell Lawson, are making the trip, along with head coach Rusty ... (click for more)

Chattanooga Lookouts Drop Fourteenth Straight Game Losing To Jacksonville Sunday, 10-5

The Jacksonville Jumbo Shrimp defeated the Chattanooga Lookouts by a 10-5 score in the fourth game of the four-game series at AT&T Field on Sunday afternoon. Chattanooga's won-loss record for the second half stands at 8-21. The loss was the 14th straight for the stumbling Lookouts who are now just one loss away from tying the Southern League's longest losing streak record ... (click for more)