Tennessee Supreme Court Reverses Dismissal Of Legal Malpractice Suit

Wednesday, September 18, 2019
The Tennessee Supreme Court Wednesday reversed the trial court’s dismissal of a legal malpractice claim against a Davidson County attorney, holding that sworn statements the plaintiff made in her divorce settlement agreement did not directly contradict sworn statements she made in the malpractice lawsuit. 
 
Beginning in 2006, Nashville attorney Jeffrey Levy represented Polly Spann Kershaw for a period of about seven months in her divorce. The divorce proceedings were heated, and by the time Ms.
Kershaw hired Mr. Levy, the divorce court had already held her in contempt of court. The divorce court agreed to lift the contempt sanctions if Ms. Kershaw responded to the husband’s discovery requests by the trial court’s deadline. 
 
After Mr. Levy sent Ms. Kershaw’s discovery answers to her husband’s attorney, he told the divorce court that they were mailed by the court’s deadline. That turned out to be untrue. As a result, the divorce court imposed harsh contempt sanctions on Ms. Kershaw, including striking all of Ms. Kershaw’s claims and defenses, and requiring Ms. Kershaw to pay her husband’s attorney fees. 
 
Mr. Levy withdrew as Ms. Kershaw’s lawyer. Ms. Kershaw hired a new lawyer, filed a legal malpractice lawsuit against Mr. Levy in the Davidson County Circuit Court, and settled her divorce. 
 
In the legal malpractice action, Ms. Kershaw claimed that Mr. Levy’s actions in the divorce had caused her to face the prospect of a trial with no claims and no defenses. She said that his malpractice so compromised her negotiating position that she was left with little choice but to agree to an unfavorable divorce settlement. She sought damages from Mr. Levy for his alleged legal malpractice. 
 
Mr. Levy filed a motion to dismiss the legal malpractice lawsuit, based on what is known as “judicial estoppel.” Under judicial estoppel, if a party swears to a fact in one lawsuit, he is “estopped”—that is, not allowed—to swear to a contradictory fact in a second lawsuit. Mr. Levy argued that, in her divorce, Ms. Kershaw had acknowledged under oath that the settlement agreement was “fair and equitable,” so she was “estopped” from claiming in the legal malpractice action that the divorce settlement was unfavorable. 
 
The trial court granted Mr. Levy’s motion and dismissed Ms. Kershaw’s legal malpractice claim, and the dismissal was affirmed by the Tennessee Court of Appeals. Ms. Kershaw appealed to the Tennessee Supreme Court. 
 
The Supreme Court explained that judicial estoppel applies only to directly conflicting sworn statements about facts, such as “The stoplight was red” or “The stoplight was green.” It held that judicial estoppel did not apply in Ms. Kershaw’s case. 
 
First, the Court said, Ms. Kershaw’s acknowledgment that her divorce settlement was “fair and equitable” was more of a legal conclusion than a statement of fact. Second, the statements were not directly contradictory. In the divorce, Ms. Kershaw acknowledged that the settlement “was ‘fair and equitable’ given the circumstances in which she found herself.” In the legal malpractice action, she blamed those circumstances on Mr. Levy, contending his actions “severely compromised her divorce negotiating position.” For those reasons, the Court held, judicial estoppel did not apply. Consequently, it reversed the dismissal of the legal malpractice lawsuit against Mr. Levy. 
 
To read the unanimous opinion in Polly Spann Kershaw v. Jeffrey L. Levy, authored by Justice Holly Kirby, go to the opinions section of TNCourts.gov.

Sequoyah Unit 1 Begins Scheduled Refueling, Maintenance Outage

Gas Prices Rise 2.7 Cents In Chattanooga

New Hamilton County Business Licenses


The Tennessee Valley Authority’s Sequoyah Nuclear Plant Unit 1 started a scheduled refueling and maintenance outage early Saturday morning after generating nearly 1.4 billion kilowatt hours of ... (click for more)

Chattanooga gas prices have risen 2.7 cents per gallon in the past week, averaging $2.27 per gallon on Monday, according to GasBuddy's daily survey of 170 stations. Gas prices in Chattanooga ... (click for more)

Here are the new business licenses from the County Clerk's license: 20/20 SALON AND SPA JEASAMI D BROWN 3 HAIR SALON & SPA 3913 BRAINERD RD STE 110 CHATTANOOGA TN 37411 ADRIENNE R ... (click for more)


Business

Sequoyah Unit 1 Begins Scheduled Refueling, Maintenance Outage

The Tennessee Valley Authority’s Sequoyah Nuclear Plant Unit 1 started a scheduled refueling and maintenance outage early Saturday morning after generating nearly 1.4 billion kilowatt hours of carbon-free energy, following more than 500 days of power operation. “Outages like this demonstrate TVA’s investment to deliver reliable, low-cost, carbon-free electricity for the people ... (click for more)

Gas Prices Rise 2.7 Cents In Chattanooga

Chattanooga gas prices have risen 2.7 cents per gallon in the past week, averaging $2.27 per gallon on Monday, according to GasBuddy's daily survey of 170 stations. Gas prices in Chattanooga are 15.6 cents per gallon higher than a month ago, yet stand 30.5 cents per gallon lower than a year ago. According to GasBuddy price reports, the cheapest station in Chattanooga is priced ... (click for more)

Breaking News

Thurman Says Discipline Real Problem In County Schools; Johnson Says His Focus Is Academic Improvement

County School Board member Rhonda Thurman said Monday that teachers are quitting the county schools because they face attacks from unruly students and they don't get backing from the administration. Supt. Bryan Johnson said, "We absolutely have challenges," but he said he puts his focus on academic improvement. He said a disciplinary committee meeting took two hours, and he would ... (click for more)

Eyewitness Account Given Of Murder Of Tracy Calloway, Though 4 Defendants Tried To Waive Hearing

An expressive witness, general disorder, and a circus-like atmosphere defined a preliminary hearing involving four men accused of the July murder of Tracy Calloway. On July 21, Antonio Watkins, 25; Prandel Reid Jr., 27, Gary Cross, 23, and Jamichael Smith, 26, allegedly drove up to Mr. Calloway’s residence and began shooting. Calloway, who was located in a white car parked in ... (click for more)

Opinion

Would Foreign Teachers Make Better Instructors For Inner-City Students? - And Response

It seems a week doesn't go by, sometimes more in one week, without Roy or someone writing some coded messages denigrating inner-city schools and the students (using another code-hint hint) that attend inner-city schools. Which reminded me of something from decades ago about teachers from foreign countries perhaps making better instructors for inner city students. At least those ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: The Same Ole ‘Bored’

As it just so happened, on the same day the Hamilton County School Board held a special two-hour meeting on Monday over disturbing disciplinary concerns among its 44,000 students, the Nashville Tennessean published a revealing report on school suspensions in the Nashville Metro Public Schools. After five years and a $2 million study, the results were available -- Nashville had launched ... (click for more)