Signal's Promise Of Cheaper Groceries Isn't Worth It - And Response

Monday, September 9, 2019

This letter concerns the proposed big box grocery store for Walden on Signal Mountain.  Some residents hope that store will offer groceries at a “cheaper price.”  Unfortunately, most consumers do not understand the grocery business.

The “great” prices advertised on television and in printed circulars are known as “loss leaders.”  Grocers lower the prices on some items to get customers in the store.  However, prices on other items are raised to balance the difference or “loss.”  Grocers operate on very small profit margins.  Lower prices on all groceries is not a reality.  I think Signal Mountain residents who think a big box grocery will help lower their weekly food bill are going to be disappointed.

I wonder about how added transportation up and down the mountain will affect those prices.   It makes sense that additional millage has to be factored into the cost of most items. 

While on the subject of transportation, if you live on Signal you are experiencing waiting while Signal Mountain Road is repaired.  The state is doing a great job with the 4-minute traffic light and I commend their work and progress.  But this is a reminder of how fragile Signal Mountain Road is.  Additional large semi-trucks going up and down the mountain each day to stock the big box grocery means continued road destruction, more repairs and more sitting at temporary traffic lights.  Who pays for that?  Signal Mountain residents: in taxes, lost productivity and wasted gas waiting in line.

 And, let’s remember a few weeks ago when a downed tree closed the W road.  Longer traffic waits and lines going up and down the mountain similar to winter snow days.  Those of us who have lived on Signal also know the many times the road is closed because a delivery truck has “missed” the curve at the Space House.  

The unfounded promise of cheaper groceries just is not worth it. Let the big box stores stay where they are where all consumers can be served not just a very small constituency of the community.

Eugenia D’. Allderdice
Signal Mountain

* * * 

The comments made by Eugenia D' are old sad stories used by those opposed to our new grocery store in Walden, where she doesn't live. They've tried scare tactics to instill fear to those undecided on our store, had non experts whole claimed fires would get us all, and big trucks would run over our cars and children.

And it's not big box, Home Depot and Lowes are big box. You could put three or four of this store in either building.

First she claims groceries will cost more because they are hauled up and down the mountain. They already cost more because we have to drive up and down the mountain for affordable groceries. The only available store up here is so expensive a lot of the folks on the affluent end of mountain don't shop there because of their prices. They prefer Whole Foods and the like. They import shrimp and other fish from Bangkok, Ethiopia and maybe Bangledesh, who knows, with prices four and five times as high. Meat is terribly expensive along with most other things they sell. They do have a large outdoor patio, with fireplace, where you can sit and drink a $10 cup of coffee.

All her threats are old news. Does she not think the W road is going to close at times anyway? Or a big truck misses the turn at the space house, snow, ice, and fallen trees are not going to happen if we don't get our new store? Shoot, I bet we still have big trucks coming up and down the mountain.

They know, she knows, we need this store. Especially for folks on fixed income, those without transportation who rely on others, convenience and lower prices on all groceries. There are people up here who live on the real, not transplanted, Signal Mountain, who have to live on less money per month than they probably spend in a week.

We want and need our new store and those in Signal Mountain town limits need to stay out of our, Walden's, business. They already claim they won't shop there. Good.

Arlos Dempsey
Walden (Signal Mountain), Tn



Roy Exum: A Friend Back Home

The School Discipline Problems

Roy Exum: The Saturday Funnies


I promised myself I wouldn’t write about this until the timing was right but that was before I spent maybe the most fun hour I’ve had in I don’t know when on Friday morning. Now I am so excited ... (click for more)

Now we are told that we have so many disciplinary problems with our students that we have to open three more schools to take care of them? We go from one school to four. Does anyone not see ... (click for more)

In today’s edition of The Saturday Funnies, allow me to point out student loans for college are now $1.6 trillion (with a ‘t’) in the United States but what is mournful is the fact the life lessons ... (click for more)


Opinion

Roy Exum: A Friend Back Home

I promised myself I wouldn’t write about this until the timing was right but that was before I spent maybe the most fun hour I’ve had in I don’t know when on Friday morning. Now I am so excited about what might happen I’m about to pop. A couple of weeks ago I lost my phone and Bob Corker, our former Mayor and Senator and a lifelong friend, told me he went to considerable lengths ... (click for more)

The School Discipline Problems

Now we are told that we have so many disciplinary problems with our students that we have to open three more schools to take care of them? We go from one school to four. Does anyone not see that we are having a major problem with this. No wonder teachers are quitting and leaving Hamilton County Schools. It seems that we need to fix this before we fix anything else. How can ... (click for more)

Breaking News

Planning Commission Recommends Approval For Special Zoning For "Game Changer" Development At Alstom Property

The Planning Commission on Monday afternoon went along with a request for special zoning for a development on 81 acres at the Alstom property that City Councilman Darrin Ledford called "a game changer for the city of Chattanooga." Victor Dover, who helped plan the rejuvenation of the Southside 22 years ago, said all the aspects of the project called "The Bend" would not fit into ... (click for more)

Driver Killed When Vehicle Runs Off Middle Valley Road On Sunday Night

One person was killed when a vehicle ran off Middle Valley Road on Sunday night. At approximately 9:36 p.m., the Hamilton County Sheriff's Office responded to a single-vehicle crash in the 6500 block of Middle Valley Road. Preliminary investigation determined that a 2003 Chevy pick-up was southbound, left the west side of the roadway going down an embankment, struck a utility ... (click for more)

Sports

Lady Vols Take Road Win Over No. 16/14 Notre Dame

Rennia Davis tied her career high of 33 points to lead Tennessee (3-0) to victory over No. 16/14 Notre Dame on the road on Monday night, 74-63. It was the Lady Vols' first victory on the road in the series since 2008. Davis, the 6-foot-2 junior from Jacksonville, Fla., also pulled down 10 boards to record her second double-double of the season and the 20th of her career. Freshmen ... (click for more)

UTC Women Get Off To Fast Start; Win At Liberty, 71-54

The UTC women got off to a fast start, shooting 70 percent in the first quarter, and defeated Liberty on the road, 71-54, on Monday night. Abbey Cornelius had 15 points in that big first quarter in which UTC led 22-10. Cornelius, a sophomore from Knoxville, finished with 21 points and seven rebounds. Eboni Williams, getting back to her SoCon Freshman of the Year form, had ... (click for more)