Tennessee Supreme Court Holds Economic Loss Doctrine Bars Logistic Company’s Fraudulent Inducement Claim

Monday, August 2, 2021

In a unanimous opinion released Monday, the Tennessee Supreme Court ruled that the economic loss doctrine applies in fraud actions where the parties are sophisticated commercial entities and the claim is based solely on alleged misrepresentations or nondisclosures about the quality of the goods purchased through a contract. The economic loss doctrine states parties cannot recover under civil tort law for purely economic damages suffered under a contract and instead must look to the contract itself for remedies. In addition, the ruling addressed the application of the Tennessee Consumer Protection Act to commercial transactions.

In the case before the Court, Milan Supply Chain Solutions, Inc. purchased more than 200 commercial trucks that were manufactured by Navistar, Inc. and sold by Volunteer International, Inc. The trucks had MaxxForce engines, which were developed by Navistar to meet the Environmental Protection Agency emissions standards that became effective in 2010. The trucks were subject to Navistar’s standard limited warranty, and Milan also purchased an optional service contract, which extended the warranty coverage on certain components. 

Milan began experiencing problems with some of the trucks, and Navistar made all repairs pursuant to the warranties, returning the trucks to service each time. However, the problems continued, and Milan’s representative felt that the trucks were not as reliable as Navistar and Volunteer had previously represented they would be. As a result, Milan filed suit, alleging a number of claims including fraud. The damages alleged were for economic losses incurred by having the trucks out of service for repairs and for the likely shorter lifespan of the trucks than Milan anticipated.

The trial court granted Navistar and Volunteer summary judgment on several claims and the case went to trial on the fraud claim, as well as a claim under the TCPA. The jury awarded Milan over $10,000,000 in compensatory damages, $20,000,000 in punitive damages, and attorney’s fees. 

The Court of Appeals reversed the judgments, determining that, because Milan’s fraud claims were based on economic loss alone and concerned the quality of the trucks, the fraud claims were barred by the economic loss doctrine under Tennessee law. The intermediate appellate court also held that Milan’s claim under the TCPA failed because the trucks at issue did not qualify as “goods” under the statute. The Supreme Court agreed to hear the case.

The Supreme Court affirmed the Court of Appeals on separate grounds. The Court declined to adopt a broad exception to the economic loss doctrine and instead concluded that, where a fraud claim seeks recovery of only economic losses and is premised solely on alleged misrepresentations or nondisclosures about the quality of the goods that are the subject of a contract between sophisticated commercial parties, the economic loss doctrine applies. The Court found the quality and reliability of the trucks were matters which the parties could, and actually did, contract. Applying the economic loss doctrine in these circumstances is consistent with its historical underpinnings and with its central purpose of preserving the boundary line between tort and contract law.

The Court also affirmed the intermediate appellate court’s judgment that Milan’s TCPA claim was barred as a matter of law because the trucks at issue were not “goods” as the term is defined under the TCPA. Therefore, the Court set aside the trial court’s award of attorney’s fees and costs to Milan against Navistar based on the TCPA.  

To read the Supreme Court’s opinion in Milan Supply Chain Solutions, Inc. f/k/a Milan Express, Inc. v. Navistar, Inc. et al., authored by Justice Cornelia A. Clark, go to the opinions section of TNCourts.gov.



Dalton Sees A Decrease In Unemployment Rate In August

Northwest Georgia’s Unemployment Rate Remained Unchanged In August

Alchemy Spice Company Adds Marketing And Culinary Director; Products To Be Sold Nationally


Georgia Labor Commissioner Mark Butler said Thursday that Dalton saw a decrease in the unemployment rate over the month as the number of claims dropped 27 percent in August. "Although we ... (click for more)

Georgia Labor Commissioner Mark Butler said Thursday that Northwest Georgia’s unemployment rate did not change from July to August and ties the all-time low set last month. "Although we ... (click for more)

Alchemy Spice Company on Wednesday announced that following an extensive brand refresh earlier this year, it has hired Amanda Nelson Varnell as its new Marketing and Culinary director, and it ... (click for more)



Business

Dalton Sees A Decrease In Unemployment Rate In August

Georgia Labor Commissioner Mark Butler said Thursday that Dalton saw a decrease in the unemployment rate over the month as the number of claims dropped 27 percent in August. "Although we are seeing fewer unemployed individuals now than before the pandemic started, we are also still seeing a decreased total number of people in the workforce when compared to numbers recorded ... (click for more)

Northwest Georgia’s Unemployment Rate Remained Unchanged In August

Georgia Labor Commissioner Mark Butler said Thursday that Northwest Georgia’s unemployment rate did not change from July to August and ties the all-time low set last month. "Although we are seeing fewer unemployed individuals now than before the pandemic started, we are also still seeing a decreased total number of people in the workforce when compared to numbers recorded ... (click for more)

Breaking News

6 Juveniles Arrested For Theft And Shooting Of K9 Joker To Be Detained Until Hearing

Six juveniles (ages 13-17 years old), who were arrested for their criminal involvement in auto burglaries and shooting of BCSO K9 Joker, attended an arraignment hearing on Friday. They were ordered to be held at the Bradley County Juvenile Detention Center until their detention hearing next Thursday. Prior to their arraignment, the Cleveland Police Department charged them ... (click for more)

Hamilton County Reports 2 More Deaths From Virus, 143 New Cases; Tennessee Has 85 More Deaths

The Hamilton County Health Department reported two more coronavirus deaths on Friday and 143 new positive cases, down from 174 the day before. The total cases in the county now stands at 60,893. The death total is at 613. The deaths was reported to be two women, one black and one white, one age 51-60 and the other was age 61-70. The number of COVID-19 hospitalizations is ... (click for more)

Opinion

Why Is All The New Building Not Saving Us From A 40-Cent City Property Tax Increase? - And Response

With the number of homes, apartments and condos built downtown, why is a 40 percent property tax increase necessary? Are these new structures on the paying property tax role? I need to know what’s going on downtown and why isn’t that money benefiting the city? Georgia Vaughn * * * The answer is that tax exemptions for these projects have been given out freely and ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: The Degradation Of Nurses

Debbie Moore-Black, is a registered nurse whose blogs regularly appear on the medical news website, KevinMD.com. With the unearthly demands of COVID and historic lack of concern for the nursing populace, she wrote this week on the degradation and the devaluation of the nation’s nursing force. Perhaps we should all listen: * * * TIME WILL TELL IF LESSONS WILL BE LEARNED ... (click for more)