Ron Littlefield: County Building 2nd Animal Shelter Makes Absolutely No Sense

Thursday, November 15, 2018

I do not wish to diminish in any way the excellent work of Humane Society volunteers and staff, but the organization’s ancient physical facilities are another matter entirely. 

Several years ago Chattanooga suffered a steady stream of withering and well-deserved negative publicity relating to deplorable conditions at the Society’s property near downtown. Some of that bad publicity went viral and resulted in a number of harshly worded letters and emails from distressed animal rights advocates and individuals all across the country.  Most angry protests came from people questioning how a civilized community could let such terrible things happen and stating that they would never visit or invest a single dollar in our fair city as a result of our callous inhumanity to innocent dogs and cats.

Believe me, as chairman of the City Council at the time, I found myself the recipient of much of the wrath venting from those outraged animal activists . (People erroneously believed that the Humane Society was a city agency.) That experience motivated the late Councilman Jack Benson and others to organize an effort to implement an ambitious plan that had been drafted during the administration of Mayor Jon Kinsey in support of a new state of the art animal services center.

What followed was a very aggressive and open public process.  Committees were formed.  Modern facilities in other cities were studied. Several potential local sites were considered and fundraising got underway with a driven sense of determination. Ultimately, thanks to the leadership of then Mayor Bob Corker, the city donated 10 acres of unused property with a promise of more when needed.  There would be ample space for housing larger animals that might come from more rural environments. The site was and is centrally located on Access Road near Dupont and capable of conveniently serving the entire county. Out of all this activity came what is now known as The McKamey Center - named in recognition of the early and very significant commitment of local entrepreneur and animal lover Bob McKamey.

It was always intended that The Humane Educational Society would be an integral part of this new project and that special provisions would be made so that they could undertake a more active role in promoting the “Educational” part of their agenda.  In the early planning stages the organization was very much involved, but for whatever reason they ultimately decided to back away and stick with their cramped and crumbling buildings on Highland Park Avenue. Facing those untenable conditions at the time and believing that HES would ultimately come on board, the Mckamey group pressed on alone and successfully opened the new center in July of 2008 - early in my second term as mayor.

The spacious and colorful new facility was extremely well received and met immediate success - garnering national acclaim and attention that quickly overshadowed the bad reputation that had preceded. The success and prominence of McKamey Center has continued to this day.

Meanwhile, over the years, the dilapidated Humane Society facilities have been patched and painted over until it finally has become apparent that the site and situation are hopeless.  Now it seems that the Society wants to duplicate what has been done by McKamey and the county government is considering a $10 million gift to make it happen.  This makes absolutely no sense.

Development of a second new animal care facility will simply exacerbate the inefficiencies that we already suffer as a community due to ridiculous duplication of so many other governmental services and facilities.  We don’t need “two” - just a very well-funded and well-managed “one”.  Also, at the risk of reopening another old wound, why should citizens of Chattanooga, East Ridge and other municipalities that are already providing animal services be forced to pay through county general revenue for yet another facility from which those city residents receive no benefit.  It’s that old hot button issue of “double taxation” where the county underwrites a higher level of services for some citizens at the expense of others. In short, municipal residents pay twice while those in unincorporated areas pay once.

Finally, I could not help but note that prominent local veterinarian and HES President Tai Federico has been quoted as nixing any renewed efforts to merge local animal control efforts because, “It wouldn’t be a comfortable fit.”

The obvious question begging for an answer is: “Why not”.

Ron Littlefield

Former Mayor

Chattanooga


Aborting The Rescue Of Children's Education In Hamilton County

The Extension Of Abortion Rights

Guns Versus DUI Violence


I was really captivated by this morning’s story in the Chattanoogan.com, “County School Officials Mobilized To Keep Hamilton County Out Of Lee Voucher Bill; Emails Give Details” I have read ... (click for more)

I suppose that those people who support abortion up to the time of delivery will also support medically assisted suicide for hopelessly terminal patients, allowing parents to make all decisions ... (click for more)

Every day, 28 people die as a result of drunk driving crashes on average. In 2010, 10,228 people died in drunk driving crashes – one every 52 minutes – and 345,000 were injured. In 2010, people ... (click for more)


Opinion

Aborting The Rescue Of Children's Education In Hamilton County

I was really captivated by this morning’s story in the Chattanoogan.com, “County School Officials Mobilized To Keep Hamilton County Out Of Lee Voucher Bill; Emails Give Details” I have read these emails and one that was not published from Superintendent Dr. Bryan Johnson to Elizabeth Millsaps and copied to Robert Gowan on April 15, 2019 about “Hamilton County numbers -ESAs”. ... (click for more)

The Extension Of Abortion Rights

I suppose that those people who support abortion up to the time of delivery will also support medically assisted suicide for hopelessly terminal patients, allowing parents to make all decisions about child medical treatments [or refusal of same] regardless of reasons, and repeal all current state laws that define murdering a pregnant woman a double homicide? Ted Ladd Ooltewah (click for more)

Breaking News

One Of Athens Park Bloods RICO Defendants Gets 27 Months In Federal Prison On Gun Charge

Che'Anthony Cannon has been sentenced to serve 27 months in federal prison after being convicted of being a felon with a gun. Cannon, who is one of the Athens Park Bloods members charged in a RICO conspiracy in state court, appeared before Judge Curtis Collier. On Feb. 18, 2018, Chattanooga Police Department detectives encountered defendant Cannon stepping out of a vehicle ... (click for more)

Woman Says McCallum Choked Her, Threw Her Out Of Moving Car

A woman said she was choked and thrown out of a moving car by a man who was jealous that men flirted with her at a bar. Isaiah Ray McCallum, 28, of 2200 Elder St. was charged with kidnapping, aggravated assault, vandalism and interfering with emergency calls. McCallum had prior charges of assault, vandalism and passing worthless checks. In the incident on May 11, the woman ... (click for more)

Sports

Piskos Gets Game-Winning Hit In Baylor Win Over GPS

MURFREESBORO, Tenn. – There’s nothing quite like having senior leadership in critical situations with the game on the line in the state softball tournament. Such was the case for the Baylor Lady Red Raiders, who came from ahead to score the winning run with two outs in the bottom of the seventh inning to nip GPS by a 4-3 final at McKnight Field No. Three Wednesday afternoon. ... (click for more)

Bradley Rallies Late Again To Edge Independence, 6-3, In State Baseball

MURFREESBORO, Tenn. – Bradley Central’s baseball team could be excused if they start using the motto of Larry The Cable Guy. At the TSSAA Class 3A state baseball tournament, the Bears “Git-R-Done.” On Tuesday, the Bears scored two runs in the sixth inning and beat Riverdale, 2-1, in the first state tournament appearance since 2007. Coach Travis Adams called on the same ... (click for more)