A Better Plan Is Needed For Quarry Golf Course At Mountain Creek

Friday, December 6, 2019

With regard to the ongoing saga of the old Quarry golf course and its proposed development, I reject the proposed plan endorsed by the North Chickamauga Creek Conservancy (Chattanoogan - Breaking News 11/30/2019) and believe a better outcome can be achieved. There is a middle ground that involves all R-1 construction including preserving the tree, greenspace, streams and ponds.  The NCCC position is not in alignment with the Friends of Mountain Creek position and the compromise to which is alluded in the article is not consistent with the wishes of several thousand signatories to the FOMC petition.

However, in a perfect world, I prefer that the Quarry remain a recreational greenspace available to all, as it has been for generations. Mr. Pratt should accept FOMC’s offer to buy the property to create a conservation easement or create that easement himself.  

If you have not lived in this area you cannot understand the beauty of this acreage and the abundance of wildlife it supports. Canadian geese annually flock to the waters to lay their eggs and raise their goslings. River otters have been videoed plating in the creek just downstream from the ponds; kingfishers hunt here frequently. Herons, red-shouldered hawks and egrets can be found as well as snapping turtles. Deer roam the area as do other mammals including bobcats. The plan NCCC endorses will destroy most of this habitat.

Considering NCCC is a conservancy, why in God's name would they endorse a plan that would do basically nothing to conserve this beautiful area, but instead virtually destroy it? Is it due to short-sightedness, not willing to see the big picture outcome of gaining a parking lot while losing this extremely valuable habitat? Or is the sweetness of a quid pro quo an offer that can’t be refused? I encourage NCCC to rethink their stance in this matter, if conservation is actually something that you stand for.

These quotes are from the NCCC website:

"Each blade of grass has its spot on earth whence it draws ITS LIFE, ITS STRENGTH..."

"Conservation is a wide field of study and action that includes the effort to preserve natural environments that border on human developments."

"...remain aware of the world around us, to realize our part in contributing to the unbalance, and to consciously work to minimize our own impact on the natural world while doing what we can to repair it, too."

"The watershed represents some of what is best on the planet..."

"NCCC has protected over 14,000 acres throughout the watershed and takes pride in its historical successes, while being ever mindful of the future and the following generations."

"Through scientific, regulatory, historical, and other thoughtful mechanisms, NCCC strategically chooses an activist approach to all work relative to the ecological base of the watershed."

Now, when these statements are considered in light of the NCCC position regarding the Quarry, I cannot but help note a bit, perhaps a large bit, of hypocrisy in the NCCC position. It is not my intention or desire to offend or impugn the Conservancy, however...seriously? The Conservancy can make all of these statements and then support a position that is counter to them all - for the sake of a parking lot?

Furthermore, is NCCC not familiar with the current lawsuit against the developer due to claimed destruction and theft of property at one of his newer developments? Does this not raise a potential red flag?

I can understand somewhat the willingness to embrace this apparent bait-and-switch and how it must seem like a good deal for NCCC. But please consider the negative implications to wildlife, the residents and to the peace and beauty that can remain if this land is, at best, left unmolested and, at worst, developed sensibly with adequate greenspace. Once it's gone - it's gone. 

I trust that the Conservancy governance will carefully consider their position going forward. This actually could be a "watershed" moment for the organization. Frankly, I would think there could be PR blowback from the NCCC current position, but that's just one man's opinion.

I have offered my personal opinions in this piece and trust that others will look more deeply into this matter. If your opinions align with my own, I would encourage you to make them known to NCCC staff and to contact Friends of Mountain Creek.

In closing, I am probably close to twice the age of most NCCC staff. I have belonged to and financially supported at least seven different environmental organizations in my lifetime, serving as board member and vice-president of one of those organizations. I am also a mountain biker and kayaker. Knowing what I know about the overall situation, as an avid environmentalist and outdoorsman, I would never take the NCCC position. I implore them to reconsider.

And, finally a quote from Leo Tolstoy: “One of the first conditions of happiness is that the link between man and nature shall not be broken.”

Respectfully,
Gregory Smith


That Much Good

Roy Exum: The Saturday Funnies

A Plan For Making City Parks Accessible To Everyone


H.Q., John Cupp, Jim Hammond. As I grew up in Chattanooga, and throughout my 32 years of law practice, the Hamilton County Sheriff's Department and the larger than life men who have served ... (click for more)

These two hunters are out in the woods when one of them collapses. He doesn't seem to be breathing and his eyes are glazed. The other guy takes out his phone and calls the emergency services. ... (click for more)

As a mayoral candidate, I have a plan for making Chattanooga’s parks and outdoor recreational activities accessible to every Chattanoogan by reconnecting Outdoor Chattanooga with Youth and Family ... (click for more)



Opinion

That Much Good

H.Q., John Cupp, Jim Hammond. As I grew up in Chattanooga, and throughout my 32 years of law practice, the Hamilton County Sheriff's Department and the larger than life men who have served the voters and citizens in that seat have inspired me with their dedication and hard work. From time to time during my career, these gentlemen have coached me, counseled me and taught me. ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: The Saturday Funnies

These two hunters are out in the woods when one of them collapses. He doesn't seem to be breathing and his eyes are glazed. The other guy takes out his phone and calls the emergency services. He gasps: "My friend is dead! What can I do?" The operator says: "Calm down, I can help. First, let's make sure he's dead." In the silence that follows, allow me to welcome you to this ... (click for more)

Breaking News

Hamilton County Has 1 More Coronavirus Death, Cases Top 6,000; State Has 9 More Deaths

The Hamilton County Health Department reported on Saturday that the total number of Hamilton County resident deaths has risen one more to 54. Total cases now are 6,031 in Hamilton County, an increase of 104. Tennessee had 9 more deaths bringing the toll to 1,215. There were 1,803 new cases for a total of 120,585. There were 72 more hospitalized to bring that total ... (click for more)

Witnesses Saw Road Rage Killing Of 19-Year-Old Caleb McKean; Got Tag Number Of Mazda Driven By Terry Beard, Who Confessed

Police said several people witnessed the road rage killing of 19-year-old Caleb McKean on Friday afternoon. One got the tag number of the distinctive Mazda driven by the shooter. That let police to 43-year-old Terry Julius Beard, who confessed and has been charged with criminal homicide. At approximately 2:42 p.m., Chattanooga Police responded to a person shot call in ... (click for more)

Sports

Chattanooga FC Falls 2-1 To Michigan Stars

The Michigan Stars scored late in the match for a 2-1 victory over Chattanooga FC on Saturday. It was the start of the fall season of the National Independent Soccer Association. Steven Juncaj broke at 1-1 tie in the 88th minute while hitting an 18-yard shot at Ultimate Soccer Arenas Outdoor Stadium at Pontiac, Mich. After the Stars took the lead, Chattanooga FC had ... (click for more)

Chattanooga FC Strengthens Roster With New Players Before NISA Fall Season

When Chattanooga’s Football Club travels north for the NISA fall conference opener, there will be some new faces on the trip. The club is proud to announce the signing of defender Shaun Russell in addition to last month’s signing of midfielder David Koloko. Here’s a deeper dive into the new players joining the first team: David Koloko: Koloko is a 6’1” midfielder/defender ... (click for more)