HCDE's Proposed Budget AKA Social Experiment

Monday, June 24, 2019

Calling for a “hope and change” budget, Hamilton County’s Department of Education wants you to pay drastically more in property taxes to fund its hopes of changing our school system to an all-inclusive community and behavioral center. Moreover, HCDE intends to spend over one half billion taxpayer dollars next year, much of which will fund increases in administration and staff rather than support our great classroom teachers. Hopefully, the County Commission will have better sense.

Asking taxpayers for significantly more each year to fund HCDE’s social experiment spending spree is irresponsible. Though expected revenue represents an increase over previous years, HCDE wants an additional $34 million, much of which will never reach the classroom. In addition to its Learning Communities, HCDE proposes establishing an “office of social emotional learning to address non-academic needs.” It appears that the vast majority of the new funding will be used for counselors, social workers, and “behavior specialists,” not for academic positions.

We need more education, not indoctrination. Last year, the school board was urged to adopt objectives in the APEX Project Report, a 56-page document of leftist directives. Today, similarities between the APEX Report and HCDE’s budget proposal documentation is telling. For example, the APEX report calls for the implementation of “a community school model district-wide” where schools act as “hubs” for social services such as “food assistance, health and wellness clinics, and after-school programs” as well as “health and nutrition programs, counseling, child care, and parenting classes.” According to the report, “Schools must work to ensure student mental and emotional health needs are supported.” It urges policies that include creating support groups that “need professionally trained staff who are culturally competent.” Further, it urges implementing “culturally responsive teaching,” which requires educators to be “trained and supported to move past cultural biases to promote student participation and achievement.” The APEX report also calls for “restorative justice practices” in which schools are encouraged to focus on “community health rather than individual punishment.” Instead of holding people responsible for their actions, schools would focus on practices like “trust-building exercises.” This reeks of social engineering rather than promoting academic success.

Among the many questions the HCDE/Apex approach raises: Could tax revenue devoted to schools be more effectively used by social service agencies? Should the millions spent on social programs be moved to schools? Regardless, redundant government programs lead to fraud, waste and abuse with few positive results.

Moreover, money is not generally a good indicator of educational value. In fact, no meaningful correlation can be found between per-student spending and student performance. Thus, HCDE should focus on spending funds more wisely. With nearly half of HCDE students needing remedial math and over 35 percent remedial reading, education funds should be focused in classrooms, not backrooms. Speaking of which, HCDE spent $75,000 of taxpayer money on lobbyists to keep local, low-income children from seeking a better education through Governor Lee’s ESA program. A wiser use of funds would be supporting hardworking teachers, and growth funds being provided by the state could be used for teacher pay raises without the $34 million increase.

God created three primary institutions - family, church, and government. Society degenerates when any one institution tries to the do the job of another. Raising children is the duty of parents, not government. Research consistently demonstrates that family structure is the key to positively influencing a child’s future. Even for children from disadvantageous backgrounds, parents are crucial to overcoming educational and social difficulties. The primary factors influencing children’s educational and social achievement are parents who raise their educational expectations of their children and who get involved in their children’s lives. Even if it had the authority and unending funds, government doesn’t have the power to make people better parents. Moreover, throwing money into the system won’t make government good parents either.

Society’s ills will not be cured by heaping more money into an already bloated school administration, intertwining it with yet more bureaucracy, or embracing a radical social agenda. Rather, student success will be achieved when we downsize administrations, “right-size” classrooms, and support hardworking teachers. Only when our institutions reinforce rather than run over each other, will our community truly prosper.

Tina J. Benkiser, J.D.

Roy Exum: The Christians' Fault

Some Wonderful Things

Earl Freudenberg: Remembering Glenn Draper On Memorial Day (2)

A Harvard Law professor, Elizabeth Bartholet, has clamored for the spotlight in recent weeks seeking to ban homeschooling. She claims there is little oversight for what homeschooled children ... (click for more)

The word 'wonderful' has a variety of meanings, including amazing, astounding, and beneficial. That word came to mind this week. On Thursday a wonderful thing was all over the news -- ... (click for more)

This is Memorial Day Weekend and I can't think of a better time to remember my good friend, Dr. Glenn Draper. (he got on to me for calling him Dr. Draper, he would say “just call me Glenn”). ... (click for more)


Roy Exum: The Christians' Fault

A Harvard Law professor, Elizabeth Bartholet, has clamored for the spotlight in recent weeks seeking to ban homeschooling. She claims there is little oversight for what homeschooled children are learning, that in many places the uneducated adults are not qualified to teach their children, and that with child abuse on the rise, the fact there are no “mandated reporters,” such as ... (click for more)

Some Wonderful Things

The word 'wonderful' has a variety of meanings, including amazing, astounding, and beneficial. That word came to mind this week. On Thursday a wonderful thing was all over the news -- a new official map showing Hamilton County Chinese plague case numbers by ZIP code. The color code made it easy to see which parts of our county had been hardest hit, and which were relatively ... (click for more)

Breaking News

Silverdale Detention Center CoreCivic Employee Tests Positive For COVID-19

On Friday a CoreCivic employee who works at the Silverdale Detention Center tested positive for COVID-19 after a close family member tested positive. The employee was tested Thursday as a precautionary measure. CDC recommended guidelines are being utilized at the Silverdale facility to assure the safety and well-being of all staff and inmates. Jail personnel are also currently ... (click for more)

Hamilton County Jumps From 531 Virus Cases To 640 In 2 Days; Tennessee Has 7 More Coronavirus Deaths, Including 3 From Nashville, 2 From Memphis

Hamilton County has jumped from 531 coronavirus cases to 640 in two days. It remains at 14 deaths. Tennessee has had seven more coronavirus deaths. The new total is 336. There were 356 new cases, bringing the total to 20,145. There were 10 more hospitalizations for a total of 1,583. Nashville has three more coronavirus deaths for a total of 57. Memphis now has 94 ... (click for more)


Fulmer Issues Statement On SEC Decision To Allow Return To Activity By Student-Athletes

Tennessee Athletic Director Phillip Fulmer provided the following response to the SEC decision to allow student-athletes to return to campuses: Southeastern Conference leadership on Friday voted to allow voluntary, in-person athletics activities on league campuses starting Monday, June 8. Each SEC institution will make localized decisions regarding when and how student-athletes ... (click for more)

Dan Fleser: Tennessee In Lock Step With New SEC Athletic Guidelines

KNOXVILLE – The Southeastern Conference will make its first move back toward the playing fields when it allows the resumption of voluntary in-person athletic activities on June 8 on campuses. Tennessee will be lockstep with this first step, which was approved via vote of the schools on Friday. “We’ll continue to follow the guidance from medical experts and health officials ... (click for more)