Roy Exum: Erlanger's Poor Staffing Situation

Friday, July 3, 2020
Roy Exum
Roy Exum

I have never heard of a CRRT but when I found out that such an intensive care machine is used to facilitate a “continuous renal replacement therapy,” I was actually scared that some poor soul in the throes of acute kidney failure at Chattanooga’s Erlanger Hospital could die. Granted, kidney failure in a critically ill patient is a terrible thing but when one nurse is charged with operating two CRRT machines at the same time, the effects of understaffing can indeed be just as lethal.

On Tuesday night last week, a medical ICU nurse alerted me another RN in the unit was tasked with the impossible; since then two different sources have told me to operate one CRRT machine is enough to rattle the nerves of the best ICU nurses – operating two at the same time is “idiotic” (the nicest word that was used.)

Instead of a regular dialysis treatment (3 or 4 hours) the CRRT is rapidly becoming an ICU mainstay because the complex therapy is far gentler with its 24-hour cycle.

Dialysis, of course, is used when our kidneys shut down and cannot naturally cleanse our blood. As anyone might expect the process and the one patient requires close and constant monitoring. As one veteran ICU nurse confided, “That patient is somebody’s husband, dad, golfing partner. You try to block that from your mind,” she said, “until you hear that soft voice: ‘Thank you so much…’”

Since Erlanger’s nursing woes have been brought to light last month, two of the biggest antagonists in a horrifying story of mismanagement and abuse have been removed and the hiring of Rachel Harris over the nurses has meant even more to the weary. But today’s problem is that the patient-nurse ratios may be the worst in the Southeast, with COVID-19 now bearing down even harder.

An Erlanger nurse has just written me about the staffing shortages – knowing others who braved “instant firing and professional blackball” by contacting me but who, instead, exposed some of those who made the vicious threats, and brought Erlanger’s lack-of-caring attitude for those employees who care the most.

* * *


As of this Monday, Erlanger administration has shut down the Central West Wing 7 unit.  This planned shutdown of CWW7 was not because the rooms were not needed.  At the beginning of dayshift on Tuesday, there were 32 holds in the Emergency Department (ED), and 18 of those were intensive care (ICU) holds.  (“Holds” are patients that are admitted and just waiting to go to a bed on the floor.)

There were also other patients in the ED that were being tended to who weren’t necessarily being admitted.  During that time, there were reportedly only 6 RNs, 1 LPN, and 2 Paramedics.  That is definitely far too high of a nurse-to-patient ratio to provide the proper care needed for these patients.

Ratios are often bad in the Emergency Department, but 18 ICU holds cripples the department and makes it next to impossible to provide adequate care to both the ICU patients and the other patients that come in that medical staff is trying to resuscitate and make stable.

Meanwhile, there are perfectly good nurses who have been wrongfully terminated by the previous Chief Nursing Officer (CNO). There have been numerous accounts of experienced nurses being immediately terminated for speaking up against the ridiculously high nurse/patient ratios.  Most of these nurses had excellent nursing care records and had dedicated decades of their lives to Erlanger.  Some of these were the seasoned nurses who taught the new nurses fresh out of nursing school.

Instead of listening to the advice of these nurses who had vast experience working directly with patients on the floor, which was something (the former CNO) hadn’t been able to relate to in years (if ever), she chose to immediately terminate these nurses to make examples of them in an attempt to keep the rest of the staff in line.  This made the nurse-to-patient ratios even higher.  

The higher ratios caused other nurses to quit out of exhaustion and desperation. This snowball effect that the former CNO created has quickly caused Erlanger to be in the worst state that most nurses can ever recall witnessing during their years at the hospital.

A simple solution (and the responsible solution) would be for administration to review the decisions the former CNO made during her last several months at Erlanger, evaluate the records of any employees that she terminated recently, and reinstate those nurses who were wrongfully terminated.

Administration has basically acknowledged that the former CNO was a problem, which is evident by her conveniently-timed “retirement” following the multitudes of public complaints against her by employees who accused her of mistreatment.

If administration realizes there was a problem, and does not review and reinstate those nurses who were fired without even having had write-ups, probations, suspensions, or other courses of disciplinary actions taken before being terminated, then they are being negligent by turning a blind eye to what was taking place. 

Also, administration is, at the same time, doing themselves (and Erlanger as a whole) an injustice by not bringing exceptional nurses back to the floors to lower the nurse/patient ratios in order to provide sufficient patient care.

There was recently a petition circulating to have three nurses from the North Wing 8 unit reinstated.  It had over a hundred signatures from their co-workers (ranging from nurses, doctors, patient care techs, respiratory therapists, and other specialists) who know these nurses, who have no doubt in their nursing abilities, and who want to see justice for them.

Administration should also follow up with nurses who quit since the COVID-19 crisis began, find out why they quit, and encourage them to come back and be “reinstated” without having to wait out a rehire waiting period or repeat orientation (if they haven’t already found other jobs.)

Staffing should be concern ‘Number One’ with Erlanger Administration right now, whatever the cost.  Our patients and our community deserve the safest and most excellent care possible.

* * *

[NOTE: This was written by an Erlanger East nurse:]

I am honestly not sure who else to turn to with the current situation going on at Erlanger East. I trust that you can keep my name anonymous through this as I’m fearful of losing my job if this were to get out that I am the informant.

I work at Erlanger East and it is common knowledge a scrub tech in the surgery dept. started feeling badly and went and tested positive for Covid 10 days ago. No one that she worked with was notified of her positive test, even though she had been at work that day, eating in the same lounge as other employees.

She is back at work today though she has not received her negative Covid test. Erlanger management told her she didn’t need to get tested again and could return to work as long as she was “feeling better.” Having a conscience, she went ahead and got re-tested though the results are not yet back, and she is still feeling symptoms.

We are all being out at-risk and I’m honestly not sure what else to do other than wear my n95 (facemask) and wash my hands constantly as we’re all using the same lounge to eat in and the same locker and bathrooms.

If you need any more information, please reach out …

* * *
You betcha’.




Police Targeting And The "Good Trouble Ride"

I Still Don't Know Who I'm Voting For


I think Marie Mott is confusing targeting with openly breaking the law when she is quoted as saying, "The sheriff brought charges against me and C-Grimey, and the CPD brought charges against ... (click for more)

Election Day is upon us, and I still haven’t decided who I’m voting for in the HCS District 2 School Board race. With their background and skills and passion for education, I sincerely think ... (click for more)

Kaa-whack! “How many times have I told you to cover your mouth when you cough or sneeze!” a statement, not a question, of reasoning Mom would make as she scolded her first born whenever I ... (click for more)


Police Targeting And The "Good Trouble Ride"

I think Marie Mott is confusing targeting with openly breaking the law when she is quoted as saying, "The sheriff brought charges against me and C-Grimey, and the CPD brought charges against me and C-Grimey and several other people. The police have been targeting us because we've been putting pressure on them. We've been messing with the city's money.” I can only laugh as these ... (click for more)

I Still Don't Know Who I'm Voting For

Election Day is upon us, and I still haven’t decided who I’m voting for in the HCS District 2 School Board race. With their background and skills and passion for education, I sincerely think either would be a great addition to our Hamilton County Board of Education. Some perceive big differences between the two, but I don’t. Both have experiences in financial management, ... (click for more)

Breaking News

CBL Has Net Loss Of $69.8 Million For 2nd Quarter; Losses Over 6 Months Total $203.7 Million

CBL & Associates on Thursday reported a net loss attributable to common shareholders for the second quarter 2020 of $69.8 million, or $0.36 per diluted share, compared with a net loss of $35.4 million, or a loss of $0.20 per diluted share, for the second quarter 2019. Net loss attributable to common shareholders for the six months ended June 30, 2020, was $203.7 million, ... (click for more)

Hamilton County Has Another Death From The Virus And 84 More Cases; Tennessee Has 42 More Deaths

Hamilton County had another 84 new coronavirus cases on Thursday, as well as another death bringing the toll to 50. The number of COVID patients in Intensive Care is now at 39 after Wednesday's high of 40. Total cases now are 5,833 in Hamilton County. There are 4,591 that have recovered from the virus in the county. There are 88 COVID patients hospitalized as well as ... (click for more)


Chattanooga FC Defender Raymond Lee Moves To USL Championship Pittsburgh Riverhounds

Chattanooga Football Club is announcing that the club has finalized a deal with Pittsburgh Riverhounds in the USL Championship that will send defender Raymond Lee to the Keystone state, pending league and federation approval. “From a club standpoint, it is always difficult to see a good player and better person leave” said Peter Fuller, Head Coach, Chattanooga FC. “But I think ... (click for more)

UTC's Sept. 3 Football Game With Western Kentucky Is Delayed

The UTC football game set at Western Kentucky on Sept. 3 will be delayed. Western Kentucky Director of Athletics Todd Stewart said, “We have had continuing discussions with Chattanooga regarding the date of our 2020 football game. Given the recent changes among many programs regarding their start date for the upcoming football season, WKU and Chattanooga have mutually agreed ... (click for more)