Death Penalty In Tennessee - The Cost To Us And A Solution

Wednesday, August 8, 2018

I am going to wade off into the deep waters of public discourse for the first time. Favor me with a few moments.

Billy Ray Irrick is scheduled to die by the hand of the Tennessee state government Thursday night August 9, 2018. There is much debate regarding this case on a state and national level as well as others waiting in the wings for the same fate.

For those of you who are unfamiliar with this case there is more information on the 11alive website. Please, only read this if you have a strong stomach. I studied it last night. I wish I hadn’t, I did not sleep well. 

In reading the information, if you are so inclined, you will see enough blame to go around, poor decisions by the family of the child, less than stellar living conditions, human suffering and yes, a tragic end to the life of a very young girl. Ultimately though, Mr. Irrick is responsible as has been determined repeatedly.  

For over 30 years he has dodged the reaper, now his time is ‘nigh. And still there are those who fight for this person. The legal arguments in his defense have ran the gamut from ‘mental incompetence’, poor upbringing, drug, and alcohol addiction and finally in the world we live in today, the fear he will suffer due to an ineffective mixture of drugs to be administered to him.
While I understand the Constitution and the prohibition of ‘cruel and unusual punishment’ rule I do not understand the misplaced compassion for this person. Yes, he is a human, Yes, he deserves careful debate in the court of law as to his fate. But he has had all of that. And then some.

I’ll not go into the old ‘eye for an eye’ chestnut, just too Old Testament for me. What I will say is this: he has had more than his share of ‘days in court’, he has been found and verified guilty time and again. His time has run out. Now he must pay.  

Be that right or wrong is irrelevant to my opinion here, what matters to me, and should to you, whichever side you take is this simple thing. The relevance of the debate over the drugs used to kill him. We are not talking about a short rope and a tall tree here, but a lethal dose of drugs, some may say ‘cobbled together at the whim of a power that is’. That is fair enough. Suffering at the end, whether you say, ‘too bad’ or ‘oh no’, matters not. Quite simply it doesn’t have to be. And I’ll tell you why.

There is a much simpler solution, readily available to us in bulk. It is so simple in fact I’m surprised others who are much smarter than me haven’t thought of it. It is staring us in the face.

Fentanyl.

Each year the state of Tennessee spends several millions of dollars combating this drug, every year people die from it, each month it is seized in quantity, not only in this state but others. It is everywhere. Each year some tens of thousands of people die nationwide from it. It is deadly, it has a proven track record. 

It works. 

So, put it to use.

Instead of the last-minute arguments over this drug mixture or that. Just choose the obvious substance that has been proven beyond a doubt to absolutely, without fail, work every time. It’s just that easy. There has been an abundance of it seized. It will be burned or disposed of somehow, so use it.

We are spending money hand over fist on interdiction, seizure, prosecution, and Narcan. It’s time we finally found a way to save money on both execution drugs and lawsuits. I can’t see anyone saying, ‘It may not be effective!’. It is. It’s time. 

Stop wasting money and use the best tool available. 

Russ Donegan


Roy Exum: Jalen Hurts’ Decision

Lone Voice Against Another PILOT

Olympic Moments


Several weeks ago the “Ten Best-Mannered People of 2018” were named and of all the lists compiled in the country, this is my favorite. Drew Brees, the New Orleans Saints quarterback who virtually ... (click for more)

Thank you Commissioner Tim Boyd for recognizing the con foisted upon the taxpayers by the Patten Tower project. I have railed against these PILOTs for years knowing full well that these tax ... (click for more)

Excellent story by Roy Exum on Jesse Owens' performance at the 1936 Olympic Games in Berlin. I would only add that I think the 1980 Miracle on Ice in Lake Placid when our amateur hockey team ... (click for more)


Opinion

Roy Exum: Jalen Hurts’ Decision

Several weeks ago the “Ten Best-Mannered People of 2018” were named and of all the lists compiled in the country, this is my favorite. Drew Brees, the New Orleans Saints quarterback who virtually lives his life to enhance that of others, was the hands-down winner. He and his “Brees Dream Foundation” are so steeped in goodness it will make you cry. Justin Thomas, the pro golfer ... (click for more)

Lone Voice Against Another PILOT

Thank you Commissioner Tim Boyd for recognizing the con foisted upon the taxpayers by the Patten Tower project. I have railed against these PILOTs for years knowing full well that these tax deferments will be made up sooner than later on the backs of Hamilton County taxpayers. Unfortunately, you were the lone voice in this vote. Ron Ray (click for more)

Breaking News

Chattanooga Police Seek Information In Murder Of Taja Whiteside, 30, On Jan. 11

Chattanooga Police are seeking information in the death of Taja Whiteside, 30, which happened on Jan. 11. The death has now been ruled a homicide. Chattanooga Police responded a t approximately 11:52 a.m. to a CPR in progress call at a residence in the 5800 block of Moody Sawyer Road. Upon arrival, police located the victim who was unresponsive. Hamilton County EMS pronounced ... (click for more)

Governor-Elect Bill Lee Names Penny Schwinn Education Commissioner

Tennessee Governor-elect Bill Lee on Thursday announced the appointment of Penny Schwinn to lead the Tennessee Department of Education. “Penny leads with students at the forefront and I believe her experience is exactly what we need to continue improving on the gains we have made in the past few years,” said Governor-elect Lee. “As a former teacher and seasoned administrator, ... (click for more)

Sports

There Is More Meaning To Soddy-Daisy, McMinn Game Than Just Basketball

Basketball will share the spotlight with a more serious subject next week when McMinn County visits Soddy-Daisy for a District 5-3A game. Cancer. The “C” word can strike fear into any person on the planet. Young. Old. Middle-aged people. Able-bodied folks. Basketball players. Or relatives of basketball players and, in some instances, coaches. That last category is what ... (click for more)

Red Bank Uses Forfeits To Nip Notre Dame

Notre Dame won the battle, but Red Bank won the war. These two proud teams squared off at Notre Dame’s Jack Steiner Sr. Gymnasium for a non-district wrestling match. It was also a reunion event for former Fighting Irish wrestlers and coaches, so there were a lot of smiling faces present. Notre Dame ended up winning seven of eight matches, but the Lions were the team winner ... (click for more)