State Court Of Criminal Appeals Keeps Harold Wayne Nichols On Death Row

Thursday, October 10, 2019

The Tennessee Court of Appeals has ruled that Harold Wayne Nichols, who was convicting of raping and murdering a Chattanooga woman and who allegedly raped and assaulted several other women will remain on death row.

Nichols had appealed a decision of Judge Don Ash, who dismissed his post-conviction appeal.

Judge Ash ruled against Nichols and denied an evidentiary hearing, though the district attorney's office had agreed to enter into a settlement agreement that would change his status to life in prison.

The Court of Criminal Appeals said Judge Ash had the authority to dismiss the case without a hearing and to disregard the settlement.

Nichols pled guilty to first-degree murder, aggravated rape and first-degree burglary in 1990 in the slaying of Karen Pulley. A jury imposed the death penalty.

The appeals court said, "The proof showed that on the night of September 30, 1988, (Petitioner)broke into the house where the 21-year-old-victim, Karen Pulley, lived with two roommates in the Brainerd area of Chattanooga, Tennessee. After finding Pulley home alone in her upstairs bedroom, (Petitioner) tore her undergarments from her and violently raped her. Because of her resistance during the rape, he forcibly struck her at least twice in the head with a two-by-four he had picked up after entering the house. After the rape, (Petitioner), while still struggling with the victim, struck her again several times with great force in the head with the two-by four. The next morning, one of Karen Pulley’s roommates discovered her alive and lying in a pool of blood on the floor next to her bed. Pulley died the next day.

"Three months after the rape and murder, a Chattanooga police detective questioned [Petitioner] about Pulley’s murder while he was in the custody of the East Ridge police department on unrelated charges. It was at this point that (Petitioner) confessed to the crime. This videotaped confession provided the only link between (Petitioner) and the Pulley rape and murder. The evidence showed that, until his arrest in January 1989, (Petitioner) roamed the city at night and, when “energized,” relentlessly searched for vulnerable female victims. At the time of trial, [Petitioner] had been convicted on five charges of aggravated rape involving four other Chattanooga women. These rapes had occurred in December 1988 and January 1989, within three months after Pulley’s rape and murder."

The court also said, "In June of 2016, Petitioner moved to reopen his post conviction petition on the basis that the Supreme Court’s decision in Johnson v. United States, __ U.S. __, 135 S. Ct. 2551 (2015), announced a new rule of constitutional law requiring retroactive application. The post-conviction court granted the motion to reopen, but after Petitioner amended his petition and asserted additional claims, the post conviction court denied relief without a hearing.

"On appeal, Petitioner argues (1) that the sole aggravating circumstance supporting his death sentence is unconstitutionally vague under Johnson; (2) that a judge, rather than a jury, determined facts in imposing the death penalty in violation of Hurst v. Florida, __ U.S. __, 136 S. Ct. 616 (2016), a new rule of constitutional law requiring retroactive application; (3) that the State committed prosecutorial misconduct at Petitioner’s sentencing hearing, along with a related ineffective assistance of trial counsel claim; (4) that the post-conviction court erred in canceling the scheduled evidentiary hearing without notice and a fair opportunity to be heard; (5) that the post-conviction court erred in denying the parties’ proposed settlement agreement to vacate the death sentence and enter a judgment of life imprisonment; and (6) that Petitioner’s death sentence is invalid due to the cumulative effect of the asserted errors.

"Following our review, we affirm the judgment of the post-conviction court."

 


City Council Mulling Possible Meeting Room Renovations To Deal With Safety Concerns

Loss Control Services Owner Facing Federal Mail Fraud Charge

Members Of Large-Scale Heroin Ring In Chattanooga, Cleveland Get Federal Prison Sentences


The Chattanooga City Council’s assembly room may look a little different by the new year. During the strategic planning meeting, the council mulled some possible renovations of their customary ... (click for more)

The operator of a local firm specializing in filing insurance claims for those with property damage is facing federal criminal charges. Benjamin Reichel was charged in a criminal information ... (click for more)

Three members of a large-scale heroin distribution ring in Chattanooga and Cleveland, Tn., have been sentenced to time in federal prison. Cameron Hunter-Loftin appeared before Judge Sandy ... (click for more)


Breaking News

City Council Mulling Possible Meeting Room Renovations To Deal With Safety Concerns

The Chattanooga City Council’s assembly room may look a little different by the new year. During the strategic planning meeting, the council mulled some possible renovations of their customary meeting place at the quarters behind City Hall at Lindsay and 10th. However, some council members do not want to move so fast. One of the issues the council has with the current arrangement ... (click for more)

Loss Control Services Owner Facing Federal Mail Fraud Charge

The operator of a local firm specializing in filing insurance claims for those with property damage is facing federal criminal charges. Benjamin Reichel was charged in a criminal information with wire fraud. The information says Reichel heads Loss Control Services LLC that is headquartered in Cleveland, Tn. It says beginning in about March 2018 and continuing into June ... (click for more)

Opinion

The Wheel Tax Wouldn't Be A Sacrifice And Supports Our Teachers - And Response (9)

I appreciate our underpaid teachers here in Tennessee so much. We as a whole have a moral obligation to make sure we contribute to their pay. A wheel tax on our cars is a minimal expense to most of us. Sixty dollars is not enough for us to complain. We shouldn't even bat an eye at that if it contributes to the hard working teachers who sacrifice daily for our children. We ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: Me & Eric Trump

One summer’s day when I was in my early teens, I was walking home from swimming practice and decided I might stop by the house of the most beautiful girl my age that I had ever seen, which was about halfway between the pool and where I grew up. Told she was at the house next door; I went to find her and was confronted with something I had never experienced. She was being playfully ... (click for more)

Sports

Chattanooga State To Host TCCAA Volleyball Tournament

Chattanooga State Community College will host the Tennessee Community College Athletic Association (TCCAA) Volleyball tournament on Friday, October 25 and Saturday, October 26 on the main campus, 4501 Amnicola Highway. The #2 seed, Cleveland State will play #3 seed Chattanooga State on Friday at 6:00 p.m. The winner of that match will play #1 seed Walters State on Saturday at ... (click for more)

Mark Guhne: There's More To Coaching Than Winning A Trophy

Despite being UT-Chattanooga’s coach for over a decade, Mark Guhne’s enthusiasm and love for the job was evident as he addressed the Chattanooga Kiwanis Club. As the coach of the men’s golf team, the Chattanooga lifer and UTC graduate recalled the day he was offered the job. “I remember when I got the job. Steve Sloan was gracious enough to hire me as a volunteer. For the first ... (click for more)