Tennessee Supreme Court Clarifies Standing Requirements In Tennessee

  • Thursday, November 14, 2024
The Tennessee Supreme Court today issued an Opinion in Case v. Wilmington, involving a man who claimed he experienced “wrongful foreclosure” of his property.

In the Opinion, the Court held that state law does not recognize a common law claim of “wrongful foreclosure.” Rather, such claims must be brought as existing breach of contract, tort, or statutory causes of action.
The plaintiff, Terry Case, filed the underlying action to stop the foreclosure of his property. After the foreclosure was allowed to proceed, Case filed an amended complaint asserting claims for “wrongful foreclosure,” among others.
The trial court dismissed Case’s claims. The Court of Appeals reversed on the “wrongful foreclosure” claim and upheld dismissal of the remaining claims.

The Supreme Court granted defendant Wilmington’s application for permission to appeal and requested additional briefing on whether Case satisfied the requirements for constitutional standing. The Court first clarified that to establish standing in private rights cases, the Tennessee Constitution only requires a legal injury. The Court distinguished Tennessee constitutional requirements from the federal requirement of an injury in fact in all federal cases under the United States Constitution.

Because Case’s “wrongful foreclosure” claim was not a recognized cause of action, the Supreme Court reversed the Court of Appeals and sent the case back to the trial court to enter an order of dismissal.

Chief Justice Kirby filed a separate opinion concurring in the judgment.

To read the Supreme Court’s opinion in Case v. Wilmington, authored by Justice Dwight E. Tarwater, click here.
Business
Chattanooga Bar Foundation Fellows Class Of 2025 Honored
  • 6/26/2025

The Chattanooga Bar Foundation Fellows held its annual meeting to honor the Fellows Class of 2025. Selected are: Cameron S. Hill, Sr., focuses on construction, employment, ERISA and non-ERISA ... more

All TN Counties Report Unemployment Rates Of 5% Or Below
All TN Counties Report Unemployment Rates Of 5% Or Below
  • 6/26/2025

Every Tennessee county recorded an unemployment rate of 5 percent or less in May, the Tennessee Department of Labor and Workforce Development announced today. Ninety-four of the state’s ... more

Metro Dalton Unemployment Rate Holds Steady In May
  • 6/26/2025

The Georgia Department of Labor announced Thursday that the two-county Dalton Metropolitan Statistical Area recorded an unemployment rate of 3.2% in May, unchanged from the previous month. A ... more