Region's Cities Get More Bang For Buck On Main Street Than Big Box Retailers Expert Says

Thursday, November 1, 2012

Nationally-recognized real estate developer and regional growth expert Joe Minicozzi presented an economic development analysis of the region that says local governments get more return for their buck when they put the tax revenue potential of land in the city center at the forefront of their urban planning decisions. The perspective is contrary to conventional wisdom that big-box retailers bring big tax revenue and challenges economic developers in communities across southeast Tennessee to look at the value-per-acre return on their “Main Street” investments.

At a public meeting and luncheon sponsored by the Chattanooga Hamilton County Regional Planning Agency, Southeast Tennessee Development District, River City Company and the Lyndhurst Foundation, Joe Minicozzi of Urban3, a consulting company of the real estate developer Public Interest Projects out of Asheville, N.C., highlighted the fact that dense, mixed-use urban development pays better dividends than suburban mall counterparts when comparing on a value-per-acre basis.

To illustrate his point, Mr. Minicozzi studied Chattanooga and Hamilton County property taxes from 2012 to derive a yield-per-acre. In local comparison, Buffalo Wild Wings in downtown Chattanooga yielded a total of $39,555 in combined city and county sales tax revenue per acre compared with Courtyard by Marriott’s $300,765 and Republic Centre’s $524,537 per acre. When compared with the $5,940 combined per-acre tax revenue for Walmart in Cummings and the $26,452 per-acre tax revenue for Hamilton Place, it is clear the outright annual tax benefit lies in downtown development, said Minicozzi.

On a per-acre comparison, it would take 6.8 acres of mixed-use buildings, like the One North Shore condos in the Northshore District, to yield as much total property tax income as the 86.4-acre Hamilton Place site. Still, he notes that there is a place for both types of development in meeting the needs of a community and its residents, though decision makers should be conscious of the cost and benefits of each.

“As smaller communities throughout the region look for a return on the investment of tax-payer dollars, there is a significant lesson to be learned from Mr. Minicozzi’s presentation regarding the cost of developments throughout Chattanooga that should encourage reinvestment and revitalization of their small downtowns and central business districts,” said Beth Jones, executive director of the Southeast Tennessee Development District.

Mr. Minicozzi said that regardless of the size of the city or town, community leaders need to broaden their perspective in tax revenue opportunities. He said it’s like comparing the value of a car based on miles per tank (looking at the total value of the project) versus miles per gallon (looking at how each acre of development yields tax revenue). 

“As a whole, we’ve tended to look at real estate on a miles per tank basis,” said Mr. Minicozzi. “But our perspective on that vehicle may be totally different if you look at it on a miles-per-gallon basis.”

He says the cost-versus-benefit numbers become even more clear-cut when you compare the cost of public services to accommodate a large-scale development in an outlying area with a dense urban site. An outlying area development means increased capital investment and operating costs needed to provide public infrastructure and services such as roads, utility lines, garbage collection, emergency services and transportation.

“In today’s constrained fiscal environment, understanding ‘the math’ of development choices is critical to making smart policy decisions about how we grow,” said John Bridger, executive director of the Regional Planning Agency. “This study gives urban planners and community leaders alike new perspective on the many ways in which to assess the ‘fiscal value’ of any development – urban or suburban.”

Mr. Minicozzi believes Chattanooga is a good example of the value-per-acre assessment of development, because property values are even stronger in a walkable, energetic downtown. Still, he cautioned that the city has a long way to go in addressing the dichotomy of the East and West sides of US-27 and tying BlueCross BlueShield back into the fabric of the city. “We need to focus on missed opportunities as we plan for the future, because currently, there may as well be a mountain range bisecting the two sides of downtown.”

Mr. Minicozzi’s presentation, which has spurred conversation about the financial implications of how to grow a community, comes on the heels of River City Company’s recently-concluded Urban Design Challenge, which re-energized public discourse about the future growth of the City of Chattanooga.

Habitat Celebrates Life And Legacy Of Jeff Morelock

20-Unit Apartment Complex In East Brainerd Sells For $3,325,000

Real Estate Transfers For Oct. 14-20

The life and legacy of Jeff Morelock, who passed away on Feb. 13, was celebrated in the Victory Cove subdivision. Mr. Morelock's wife, Kathy, his son, Davis and family (wife, Ashlan, daughter, ... (click for more)

A 20-unit apartment complex in East Brainerd has sold for $3,325,000. It is located at 6466 East Brainerd Road. The apartments were built in 1985. The sale was to Battery Heights Apartments ... (click for more)

NOTICE: The Hamilton County Register’s Office did not publish this data. All information in the Register’s Office is public information as set out in T.C.A. 10-7-503. For questions regarding ... (click for more)

Real Estate

Habitat Celebrates Life And Legacy Of Jeff Morelock

The life and legacy of Jeff Morelock, who passed away on Feb. 13, was celebrated in the Victory Cove subdivision. Mr. Morelock's wife, Kathy, his son, Davis and family (wife, Ashlan, daughter, Emma Ann and son Jefferson), along with their church family from First Cumberland Presbyterian Church came together with Habitat staff for Jeff Morelock Day. They enjoyed lunch and shared ... (click for more)

20-Unit Apartment Complex In East Brainerd Sells For $3,325,000

A 20-unit apartment complex in East Brainerd has sold for $3,325,000. It is located at 6466 East Brainerd Road. The apartments were built in 1985. The sale was to Battery Heights Apartments Co from Harry L. and Sara M. Fields. (click for more)

Breaking News

County Commission Makes Last-Minute Redistricting Changes Before Vote Next Wednesday On 11-Member Plan; Sparks Fly Between Sharpe, Smedley

The County Commission made last-minute redistricting changes to its 11-member plan at a lengthy meeting on Wednesday. The commission is expected to pass the plan next Wednesday and send it on to state officials for their approval. Officials said the completed plan is within deviation standards (not having one or more districts too much larger or smaller than others) and keeps ... (click for more)

Arrest Made In Highway 153 Murder, Attempted Murder; Stewart Luttrell, 35, Killed; Woman In Same Car Also Shot; Child In Car Not Injured

Stewart Brodie Luttrell, 35, was killed in an incident Tuesday night on Highway 153 that resulted in traffic being clogged for hours. A woman, 27, was also injured, and a child in the car was uninjured. Police said Wednesday night that h omicide investigators have arrested 26-year-old Genesis Latroy Vaughn in connection with the incident. Vaughn is in custody at the Silverdale ... (click for more)


Pretending Is Dangerous - And Response

I’ve ‘seen some stuff’ in my time. I have followed politics for many years. I’m retired, I’m a realist and a Vietnam veteran, pretty much in that order. I’m not an alarmist or a conspiracy theorist. That said, I have never in my life been so concerned about the future of this Republic. Politics was once a legitimate contest of ideas, put forth by political figures who were sincere, ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: The Mandates Argument

I have taken the position that mandates of any kind that limit personal freedoms are awful. And I have watched with sorrow what has happened at Blue Cross Blue Shield of Tennessee and is now happening at CHI Memorial Hospital in Chattanooga. Good people are losing jobs all across America rather than surrender their personal beliefs. I also mourn the COVID vaccine has been divided ... (click for more)