$4.5 Million Fine For Scotts Highlights Need For Monitoring Bird Seed Safety

Tuesday, February 7, 2012 - by Robert Johns
American Goldfinches at feeder
American Goldfinches at feeder
- photo by Gary Smyle

The recent decision by Scotts Miracle-Gro Co. to plead guilty to charges of distributing insecticide-tainted bird seed highlights the need for continued monitoring of the safety of the nation's bird seed supply, says American Bird Conservancy, the nation's leading bird conservation organization. ABC is the only organization to have carried out independent, nationwide bird seed tests.

In April 2011, ABC announced the results of its independent bird seeding testing efforts that were undertaken as a result of sporadic wild bird seed contamination incidents. The study analyzed samples taken from four different supply sources across the country: Walmart, Home Depot, Lowes, and Target. Bird seed was randomly purchased from the stores and then shipped to the California Food Safety Laboratory at the University of California, Davis, where the detailed analyses were conducted. The studies specifically looked for harmful pesticides, such as organophosphate and carbamate insecticides.

"We found that all of the tested bird seed was either free from pesticides or that pesticides occurred at only trace levels that would not threaten bird health. For the safety of the billions of birds that are fed by millions of Americans at backyard feeders, and in the light of this recent case against Scotts, this is clearly an issue that requires greater public attention. ABC seeks additional funding for continuing, needed testing," said George Fenwick, president of ABC.

According to court records, in 2008, Scotts distributed 73 million packages of birdseed coated with the insecticides Storcide II and Actellic 5E (containing the active ingredient chlorpyrifos and pirimiphos-methyl respectively), intended to keep insects from destroying the seed. They did this despite being alerted to toxicity dangers by a staff chemist and ornithologist. Storcide II is even labeled as "Toxic to birds. Toxic to wildlife," and that "Exposed treated seed may be hazardous to birds."

No such warning exists on the Actellic 5E label, however. The Environmental Protection Agency's own fact sheet on pirimiphos-mehtyl states that "Ecological risks are not of concern to the Agency." Yet the same fact sheet also states "Although pirimphos-methyl is highly toxic to birds and fish, these risks are not of concern based on the use pattern of pirimiphos-methyl." This would seem to indicate that the EPA did not anticipate this chemical to be used on anything intentionally fed to birds.

"EPA needs to amend the use label for Actellic 5E and any other pesticide containing the same active ingredient, pirimiphos-methyl, to agree with their own fact sheet, and ensure that no other birds are poisoned by seed dosed with this toxic chemical," said Mr. Fenwick. "This highlights a key problem that pesticide labels are written by the pesticide registrant, not EPA. In some cases, it would seem that EPA is not effectively checking that the labels encompass the agency's responsibilities for birds."

The plea agreement that will result in Scotts paying $4.5 million in fines must still be approved by the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Ohio.

According to studies, one in five Americans engages in bird watching, spending a total of some $36 billion dollars annually on bird food, equipment, and travel.

The top five bird watching states by percentage of total population are: Montana (40%), Maine (39%), Vermont (38%), and Minnesota and Iowa (33% each). About 20 million birders travel away from home each year to see birds, making the activity an excellent source of tourism dollars. States with the highest percentages of out-of-state birders are: Wyoming (73%), Alaska (55%), Hawaii (51%), Montana (47%), Vermont (47%), and New Mexico (46%).


Senate Committee Approves “Restore Our Parks Act”

Senator Bell Re-Elected To National Assembly Of Sportsmen’s Caucuses Executive Council

Volkswagen Helps Protect 1,500 Acres


United States Senator Lamar Alexander on Tuesday said a bill he sponsored, along with three of his colleagues, to reduce the maintenance backlog at our nation’s 419 national parks, including ... (click for more)

State Senator Mike Bell (R-Riceville) on Thursday was re-elected to serve a second term as a member of the Executive Council for the National Assembly of Sportsmen’s Caucuses (NASC) . The announcement ... (click for more)

Volkswagen of America and The Conservation Fund announced an initiative to help protect and restore forestland in the United States, starting with making some 1,500 acres. Officials said the ... (click for more)


Outdoors

Senate Committee Approves “Restore Our Parks Act”

United States Senator Lamar Alexander on Tuesday said a bill he sponsored, along with three of his colleagues, to reduce the maintenance backlog at our nation’s 419 national parks, including the Great Smoky Mountains National Park, is “one step closer to becoming law.” “This legislation could do more to restore our national parks than anything that has happened in the last half ... (click for more)

Senator Bell Re-Elected To National Assembly Of Sportsmen’s Caucuses Executive Council

State Senator Mike Bell (R-Riceville) on Thursday was re-elected to serve a second term as a member of the Executive Council for the National Assembly of Sportsmen’s Caucuses (NASC) . The announcement was made at the 16th annual NASC Legislator Summit in Greensboro, Ga., following a ballot vote among states in attendance. “As an avid sportsman, I have enjoyed the opportunity ... (click for more)

Breaking News

Judge Poole Denies Post-Conviction Relief For Chattanooga Man On Death Row

Criminal Court Judge Don Poole on Tuesday morning announced that he was denying Lee Hall’s request for post-conviction relief. Hall was convicted in the April 1991 murder of his ex-girlfriend, Traci Crozier. He is set to be executed on Dec. 5. In explaining his decision, Judge Poole said, "The petitioner’s second post-conviction petition is barred by Tennessee Code ... (click for more)

15-Year-Old Arrested In Sept. 28 Murder Of Marshon Langford, 40

Chattanooga Police, with the assistance of the Lookout Mountain Drug Task Force, arrested a suspect wanted in connection with a homicide that occurred in the 3800 block of Larry Drive on Sept. 28. Marshon Langford, 40, was shot on Larry Drive, then he drove to Pin Oak Drive, where he crashed his vehicle. He was taken to the hospital where he later died. The suspect, a 15-year-old ... (click for more)

Opinion

Rhonda Thurman: We Can Learn From The Private Schools

At Monday night’s School Board Agenda Session, I brought up the fact that I had received many complaints from parents and some school personnel about the half day of school on Wednesday, Nov. 13. This half day caught many parents off guard because students had just been off October 7-14 for Fall Break. This half day caused many to have to scramble for childcare. Some also noted ... (click for more)

All Property Owners Deserve The Right To STVR

Changes are coming to Chattanooga’s Short-Term Vacation Rental Ordinance. Chattanooga City Council is working on a draft of changes that would affect every Chattanooga property owner’s right to open their home to paying short term guests. This includes upping the ante on fines for those who are denied an application for permits. This first draft is to be presented to the council ... (click for more)