Roy Exum: The Goal: The Truth

Wednesday, September 26, 2018 - by Roy Exum
Roy Exum
Roy Exum

As of late yesterday afternoon, the American citizens have believed there would be a hearing this week like no other since 1776. No matter where I turn, it seems like the claims from a drunken night involving two minors, this over 30 years ago, has morphed into a political donnybrook, mesmerized our nation, and dashed any civility we have towards one another worse than when Moses threw down the Ten Commandments.

My gracious goodness, I have gotten emails from three women – each who said they were sexually abused many years ago – and I wanted to cry with each one. But we also have a distinguished judge who swears he never did any such thing and for him to now tuck-and-run would be a direct affront to the very truth he has espoused in the courtroom for most of his life.

It's little secret that my favorite politician in Washington is also a man who has prosecuted evil as a noted District Attorney. Trey Gowdy (R-SC), who has served masterfully as chairman of the House Oversight Committee, appeared with CBS host John Dickerson on “Face the Nation” last Sunday and was brilliant. He’s just like me – what can the FBI investigate with no crime scene, no forensics? “They re not human polygraphs …” he said.

At the start of the show the producers had a soundbite where UN Ambassador Nikki Haley weighed in on the travesty: “I think it's very important that accuser-- that accusers are heard and that their story is heard. But I also think the accused needs to be heard.

“This is a situation where the Senate really needs to lead on this in the way that they are responsible, in a way that they are conscious of hearing both stories, and they do it quickly for the sake of both families and they take the politics out of it,” she said

“We see way too much politics in this,” the former South Carolina governor added, “And I think at the end of the day the goal is the truth. And you do that in a way that's not with a lot of fanfare. You do it in a way that's with a lot of respect. And I think that's what everybody-- and-- I think that's what the American public wants to see.”

The CBS host Dickerson was at the top of his game and Gowdy’s answers so good I want to take you to the television newsroom for some excerpts of the dialogue:

* * *

JOHN DICKERSON: This hearing that's going to happen this week in the Senate Judiciary Committee. You've-- you've chaired some pretty high-profile, politically-charged hearings. What are the risks involved?

REPRESENTATIVE TREY GOWDY: There's a risk to either side, that's not perceived as being fair. I-- I've never-- I've been in lots of sex assault cases, but not since I've been in Congress. You have got to be fair to the witness. You have got to give the witness an opportunity to fully answer the question.

You need to eschew these five-minute increments that we so often use in Congress. Five minutes is not long enough for anyone to appropriately question either Doctor Ford or Judge Kavanaugh. I am confident the judge-- that Senator Grassley, Chairman Grassley will run this in a respectful way but the American people regardless of whether you're a Republican or a Democrat expect these witnesses to be treated fairly and I am confident that they will be.

JOHN DICKERSON: One of the questions that Christine Blasey Ford has said is that she would have liked the FBI to do a kind of neutral fact finding on this. What do you think about that?

REPRESENTATIVE TREY GOWDY: I'm a big fan of the FBI, John, but they don't investigate sex assault cases. There are very, very few federal sex assault cases.

So, my first question would be, for the FBI to investigate what? There's no crime scene to process, there are no forensics to evaluate. What the FBI could do is go interview Doctor Ford and interview Judge Kavanaugh. But they've already interviewed Judge Kavanaugh. And even if they did interview Doctor Ford, she still has to testify. So, the only role I can see the bureau playing is identifying other witnesses that may have knowledge.

Some of that's already been done by Doctor Ford. Judge Kavanaugh's defense is he wasn't there so you wouldn't expect him to produce witnesses. But I-- I don't know what people expect the FBI to do. They're not human polygraphs so--

JOHN DICKERSON: Right. Well--

REPRESENTATIVE TREY GOWDY: --they can't tell us who's telling the truth.

JOHN DICKERSON: But my understanding, though, is that the President in these nomination-- nominations the President can ask the FBI to do it. So while they may not investigate sexual assault he could in-- in terms of getting an accurate record.

I guess the thinking is the FBI is a neutral fact finder here and we don't know what we-- we don't know and so they without all the partisanship and-- and the charged nature of partisanship could get some of the basic facts down which would-- it's not just about finding information for the general record it's informing also the questions that the senators may then ask of both of them.

REPRESENTATIVE TREY GOWDY: The FBI I know has already interviewed Judge Kavanaugh. I -- I have no issues with the FBI taking a second, third, eighth look if that's what it takes to find out what happened and to fully air all the facts. I just want people to have realistic expectations --what the FBI can do is go interview Doctor Ford which is what the Senators are planning on doing this week.

They can interview Judge Kavanaugh which is what the senators are doing but they can't then come in and-- and repeat back what either of those witnesses say. You can't determine credibility unless you actually hear from the witness herself and himself.

JOHN DICKERSON: Let me ask you about what standard one should use in trying to sort through all of these facts. This is not a court of law. What's your feeling about the standard that should be used to determine who's telling what the truth of this is?

REPRESENTATIVE TREY GOWDY: That's a great question, John, and I have struggled with that question. My bias is toward sex assault victims. I spent twenty years believing them sometimes when nobody else did. I am used to the ‘beyond a reasonable doubt.’

That is an incredibly high burden, but it ought to be if you're going to take away someone's freedom. It also ought to be a high burden when you are going to impact someone's reputation. And-- and make no mistake both Doctor Ford and Judge Kavanaugh will live with consequences of this for the remainder of their lives.

But-- but as it relates to Judge Kavanaugh, when you have been accused of something that is a crime it's an incredibly serious crime. It is a crime that goes to the heart of your character. I think American people expect there to be a high evidentiary burden … and I am really disappointed when I hear senators say they either believe or don't believe witnesses that they have never interviewed or heard from.

How can you do that, John? How can you make a credibility assessment if you've never bothered to interview either of the two principals?

* * *

It’s true. How can any of us make such a judgement without knowing what is yet to come? And the “standard of measure” that Dickerson mentioned is what? I don’t believe that even the Supreme Court is that smart.

royexum@aol.com


Reasons To Choose Another Sewer Treatment Plant Site

Why WWTA's Plan Should Be Discarded

The Deck Is Rigged Against Howard


The Hamilton County Commission is being asked to make a tough decision when it comes to the location of the WWTA WWTP. On one side, you have a handful of people who are pro WWTP at Mahan Gap ... (click for more)

Thanks to a live feed, I was able to watch about three hours of the very important Hamilton County Commission meeting on Dec. 12 while in Alabama. This was the first time I have been able to ... (click for more)

I was more than appalled when I read the list of vocational programs per school across Hamilton County. We put a man on the moon nearly 60 years ago, yet HCDE can’t figure out how to make opportunities ... (click for more)


Opinion

Reasons To Choose Another Sewer Treatment Plant Site

The Hamilton County Commission is being asked to make a tough decision when it comes to the location of the WWTA WWTP. On one side, you have a handful of people who are pro WWTP at Mahan Gap because they want to develop northern Hamilton County and on the other hand, you have residents who want to protect the largest investment that they've made, i.e., their home and their ability ... (click for more)

Why WWTA's Plan Should Be Discarded

Thanks to a live feed, I was able to watch about three hours of the very important Hamilton County Commission meeting on Dec. 12 while in Alabama. This was the first time I have been able to hear both sides of the WWTA vs. Ooltewah Homeowners fully present their arguments. One thing we can all agree on is that they have to do something, the question is what is the best for all. ... (click for more)

Breaking News

34 Homes To Go In On Large Tract In Red Bank That Will Be Clearcut

A new neighborhood is being planned for Red Bank. Ethan Collier, owner of Collier Construction Company, has requested rezoning for a large tract of undeveloped property at 4701 Delashmitt Road from R-1A residential to R-T/Z Townhouse/Townhouse/Zero Lot Line to build a development of 34 single family homes. At the last commission meeting of 2018, he told the commissioners that ... (click for more)

No One Home When Wheeler Avenue Home Burns

A house on Wheeler Avenue burned late Tuesday night, and it was later found that no one was at home at the time. At approximately 11:32 p.m., the Chattanooga Fire Department, Chattanooga Police and Hamilton County EMS Medic 14 were dispatched to 1803 Wheeler Ave. on a fully involved house fire. Engine 4, Engine 5, Quint 10, Squad 1 with Engine 15, Battalion 1 and Battalion ... (click for more)

Sports

Cleveland Boys' And Girls' Basketball Teams Involved In "Inappropriate Conduct"

Reports surfaced Monday that Cleveland’s boys’ and girls’ basketball teams broke curfew and engaged in inappropriate conduct after a basketball double-header last Friday in Oak Ridge. The Blue Raiders and Lady Blue Raiders played doubleheaders at Fulton and Oak Ridge over the weekend. On Tuesday, Russell Dyer, director of Cleveland schools, released a statement through the ... (click for more)

St. Francis Knocks Off East Hamilton, 58-53, Despite Hayes' 33-Point Effort

East Hamilton’s Lady Hurricanes fell to St. Francis (Georgia), 58-53, in their opening game Tuesday in the CresCom Bank Holiday Invitational at the Myrtle Beach Convention Center in Myrtle Beach, South Carolina. Junior Madison Hayes scored a game-high 33 points on 12-of-20 shooting and also grabbed 11 rebounds for the Lady Canes (7-5), but even that wasn’t enough to overcome ... (click for more)