Rep. Colton Moore Calls On Governor Kemp To Veto Bill Naming New State Appellate Courthouse For Nathan Deal

Wednesday, March 6, 2019

Rep. Colton Moore, of Dade County, has asked new Governor Brian Kemp to veto a bill that would name the new state Supreme Court building for former Governor Nathan Deal.

He said:

"SUBJECT: Veto HR1 Our State’s Highest Courts Must Remain Neutral and Impartial

"Dear Governor Kemp, House Resolution 1, which has passed the House and Senate, seeks to rename one of the most important and expensive government buildings in Georgia history. The new $127 million State of Georgia Appellate Courthouse will hold the highest, most precious courts of justice in Georgia. Should this Resolution obtain your approval, the building would be renamed the “Nathan Deal Judicial Center.”

"Respectfully, such a designation would be highly inappropriate for a building where the Georgia Supreme Court and Court of Appeals will be housed. Former Governor Deal continues to be extremely active in Georgia politics. He owns and operates a lobbying firm which already represents clients, such as Pruitt Health, that have significant cases before these State appellate courts on matters ranging from wrongful death to fraud against state agencies.

Should you approve HR1, these clients and their critical court cases will be heard in the very building named after the lobbying firm they have hired. This is a serious conflict of interest that eternally jeopardizes the crown jewel of justice in Georgia. Furthermore, potential challenges to executive actions taken by former Governor Deal’s administration, and appeals of such challenges, would be made to a court housed in a building named in his honor. In light of this, I request you veto any Resolution that names a living person to a building equal to the reach and influence of our State Capitol. If such an honor is ever appropriate for a courthouse, I believe it is only appropriate to recognize someone in this fashion once our State has had the opportunity to process the entire body of one’s contributions to our society, freedoms, and way of life.

"I submit to you the example set by one of the first and greatest symbols of justice in our country, President George Washington. After leading our nation to freedom, presiding over the Constitutional Convention and later serving as our first President, he declined the honor of being featured on the first U.S. silver dollar, symbolizing his humble nature of service. Congress later cemented President Washington’s tradition of humility in public service by passing 31 US Code § 5112 (n)(2)(e): “No coin issued under this subsection may bear the image of a living former or current President, or of any deceased former President during the 2-year period following the date of the death of that President.”

"If you allow our State’s highest courts to conduct the business of Georgia’s citizens in a courthouse named after a living person, who continues to be actively involved in the public policy and business of the State, we will sacrifice the neutrality and impartiality so critical to the administration of justice. Even the appearance of impropriety damages public trust in Georgia’s judicial branch, impairing the ability to uphold the Constitution and laws of our State.

"Our Founding Fathers created a nation of laws, not of men. The citizens of Georgia must be able to trust that our State’s highest courts are operating free of political influence or bias, beyond even the smallest doubt. House Resolution 1 is a clear conflict of interest. It should be vetoed."


Lesser-Known U.S. Senate Candidates Make Pitch To Chattanooga Pachyderm Club Members

Former Senator Corker Gets Close View Of 29th Night Of Chattanooga Demonstrations

TBI Releases 2 New Crime Data Publications


Manny Sethi and Bill Hagerty may be the most well-known candidates to replace Lamar Alexander, but they are far from the only ones. The downtown Pachyderm Club provided a platform for some of ... (click for more)

An unlikely figure was present for the 29th day of demonstrations for divestment from law enforcement. In the far corner of Miller Park, away from the fray and commotion, sat former United States ... (click for more)

The Tennessee Bureau of Investigation released two publications, detailing the volume and nature of hate crime in Tennessee, along with one detailing violence directed toward the state’s law ... (click for more)



Breaking News

Lesser-Known U.S. Senate Candidates Make Pitch To Chattanooga Pachyderm Club Members

Manny Sethi and Bill Hagerty may be the most well-known candidates to replace Lamar Alexander, but they are far from the only ones. The downtown Pachyderm Club provided a platform for some of the lesser-known senatorial candidates in the 2020 race. Aaron Pettigrew, Roy Dale Cope and Jon Henry all told the club why they are the best man for the job. Jon Henry, a former Marine ... (click for more)

Former Senator Corker Gets Close View Of 29th Night Of Chattanooga Demonstrations

An unlikely figure was present for the 29th day of demonstrations for divestment from law enforcement. In the far corner of Miller Park, away from the fray and commotion, sat former United States senator and Chattanooga mayor Bob Corker. He quietly observed what the organizers had to say, and then left the park once the march began. “No thank you. I’m just here to listen,” said ... (click for more)

Opinion

Erlanger's Problems Started Long Before Will Jackson

I, too, am a former Erlanger employee. I loved my 28 years there and was devastated when I was laid off three years ago. Roy, I find it incredulous that you think that Erlanger’s downward spiral began in the few short months that Will Jackson has taken the helm. It started when Kevin Spiegel started the “ no divert” policy. This policy put undo pressure on every ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: The Side Of Freedom

J.R.R Tolkien, who quite famously wrote books like ‘The Hobbit’ and ‘The Lord of the Rings’, made a very astute observation one day before he died almost 50 years ago. “All we have to decide is what to do with the time given us.” None of us knows when the bell will toll, so my sole responsibility is to squeeze the most and best and brightest out of “the time given me” and I enjoy ... (click for more)

Sports

Auto Racing Pioneer Joe Richey Dies At 85

A true pioneer of local auto racing passed away Saturday. Joseph W. “Joe” Richey, 85, was surrounded by his loving family. Joe Richey is a member of the Georgia Racing Hall of Fame and was a familiar sight around area tracks fielding race cars including his families #87 carried on by his son Rex in the 80's, 90's and beyond. He was a lifelong resident of the Chattanooga, North ... (click for more)

Chattanooga Women's Golf Sets Tee Times For Tuesday's Team Play

CHATTANOOGA WOMEN’S CITY TEAM PLAY Black Creek Golf Club 9:30 SHOTGUN START 1A COUNCIL FIRE A TEAM – COLLETTE MURRAY, KYNDALL SHAMBLIN, AMY LONG, PRESLEE YODER 1B COUNCIL FIRE B TEAM – DARLENE WERYNYAK, PATTY DONAHOO, SANDRA YODER, CARLENE RYON 18A COUNCIL FIRE C TEAM – PHYLLIS LOFTSGARD, LYNN MCGEE, NANCY LOGUE, DONA ROBINSON 18B BLACK CREEK A TEAM – MEG BUCHANAN, ... (click for more)