Tennessee Supreme Court Upholds Hamilton County Court's Decision To Exclude Videotape Of Post-Polygraph Statements

Thursday, August 22, 2019
In an opinion released Wednesday, the Tennessee Supreme Court held that a trial court acted within its discretion in excluding from trial a defendant’s videotaped statements given in a post-polygraph interview. In so doing, the Court reversed the decision of the Court of Criminal Appeals.

The defendant, Quintis McCaleb, was indicted on one count of aggravated sexual battery and two counts of rape of a child in Hamilton County.   During the investigation of the charges, Mr. McCaleb agreed to take a polygraph examination.  At the end of the examination, a law enforcement officer additionally interrogated Mr.
McCaleb. Many of the questions contained references to the polygraph.  Mr. McCaleb sought to suppress the videotape of these statements.  Any testimony related to polygraphs is strictly prohibited under Tennessee law.  The trial court held that the statements should not be admitted because of the many references to the polygraph.

The State then pursued an interlocutory appeal, and the Court of Criminal Appeals held that the trial court abused its discretion in excluding the videotape of Mr. McCaleb’s statements from trial.  The intermediate court held that the trial court possibly could have admitted into evidence a redacted portion of the videotaped interrogation, even though no redacted version had been offered by the State.  As a result, the Court of Criminal Appeals reversed the trial court’s decision.  The Supreme Court then granted Mr. McCaleb’s application for permission to appeal.

The Supreme Court held that the trial court acted within its discretion in determining that the videotape of Mr. McCaleb’s post-polygraph statements should be excluded from trial.  In reaching this decision, the Court noted that a trial court has broad discretion in determining whether particular evidence should be admitted at trial.  As a result, as long as the trial court’s action was an objectively reasonable decision, an appellate court should not substitute its judgment for that of the trial court. Instead, it should uphold that decision, even if the appellate court would have reached a different result.  Under the facts of this case, the decision by the trial court was a reasonable option.  Therefore, the trial court did not err in deciding to exclude the evidence.   Accordingly, the Supreme Court reversed the judgment of the Court of Criminal Appeals and remanded the matter to the trial court for further proceedings.

To read the Supreme Court’s opinion in State of Tennessee v. Quintis McCaleb, authored by Chief Justice Jeff Bivins, go to the opinions section of TNCourts.gov.

EPB Warns Public Of Robo Call Scam

Food City Continues To Expand Home Delivery Service

Unemployment Across TN Holds Steady In August


EPB is receiving reports that some customers are receiving robo calls demanding immediate payment for their electric/fiber bills to avoid disconnection. Many of these calls have an (888) area ... (click for more)

Food City officials announced Thursday the expansion of its new same-day delivery service into several new market areas, including Dalton and Ringgold, Maynardville Highway in Knoxville, and ... (click for more)

Statewide unemployment for Tennessee held steady in August. The latest statistics released by the Tennessee Department of Labor and Workforce Development show the new seasonally adjusted rate ... (click for more)


Business

EPB Warns Public Of Robo Call Scam

EPB is receiving reports that some customers are receiving robo calls demanding immediate payment for their electric/fiber bills to avoid disconnection. Many of these calls have an (888) area code. EPB officials warn the public to disregard. Real EPB calls have a (423) area code, and it never requests payment in the message but simply ask customers to call for more information. (click for more)

Food City Continues To Expand Home Delivery Service

Food City officials announced Thursday the expansion of its new same-day delivery service into several new market areas, including Dalton and Ringgold, Maynardville Highway in Knoxville, and Tennessee Avenue in Chattanooga. The program is made possible through a joint partnership between the local retail supermarket chain and Instacart, a nationwide on-demand grocery delivery service. ... (click for more)

Breaking News

Man Shot On Sylvan Drive After Accosting Two People At Residence

Chattanooga Police said a man accosted two people at a residence on Sylvan Drive before he was shot early Saturday morning. Jeremy Brister, 25, was charged with aggravated criminal trespass, aggravated burglary and two counts of aggravated domestic violence. The victims were listed as a woman, 38, and a juvenile male. At 1:28 a.m., police responded to the 600 block ... (click for more)

4 Juveniles Arrested In Ridgeside On Aggravated Assault And Robbery Charges

East Ridge Police have arrested four juveniles for suspicion of aggravated assault and attempted aggravated robbery in the city of Ridgeside. Officers were in the Ridgeside area investigating a report of suspicious people walking in the area. While in the area, a call came in of an attempted car-jacking. Within minutes, East Ridge officers had three of four suspects in custody. ... (click for more)

Opinion

Let The Water Company Pay The Bill - And Response (2)

Tennessee American breaks a line and 35,000 people lose water for three days. Well they don’t exactly admit they broke it, they were working on it a few feet away and it just broke….so they say. One half of TAWC service area is out of water three days and nights, hospitals canceling surgery, schools closed and opened and then sending the children home, businesses shut down, government ... (click for more)

Hypocrisy Of Tennessee American Water Company Critics - And Response

All pump-pressure systems have acute failures. It is expected that utilities will experience system failures that are unanticipated, even with the best prevention. These would be acute failures. That is why all utilities from electric, water, and yes municipal sewer collection systems and treatment plants have response plans. Tennessee American Water Company experienced an acute ... (click for more)