Tennessee Supreme Court Holds Statutory Cap On Non-Economic Damages Doesn't Violate State Constitution

Wednesday, February 26, 2020

In an opinion released Wednesday, the Tennessee Supreme Court answered three certified questions from the United States District Court for the Middle District of Tennessee, holding that Tennessee’s statutory cap on non-economic damages in civil cases does not violate the Tennessee Constitution. 

This case arose from injuries sustained by Jodi McClay in a store at the Nashville International Airport in 2016.  Ms. McClay filed a personal injury lawsuit against Airport Management Services, LLC, in the United States District Court for the Middle District of Tennessee.  Following a trial, a jury awarded damages to Ms. McClay, including $930,000 for non-economic damages.  Her non-economic damages included pain and suffering, permanent injury, and loss of enjoyment of life.  

After the District Court entered judgment, the defendant sought to apply Tennessee’s statutory cap on noneconomic damages, which limits non-economic damages to $750,000 in most civil liability actions.  Ms. McClay argued that the statutory cap is unconstitutional, and the District Court then certified three questions of law regarding constitutionality under the Tennessee Constitution to the Tennessee Supreme Court for consideration.  The Tennessee Supreme Court accepted certification of the questions and heard oral argument in the matter.

In the majority opinion, the Supreme Court first held that the statutory cap on non-economic damages does not violate a plaintiff’s right to a trial by jury.  The Court concluded that the General Assembly’s adoption of the cap on non-economic damages was consistent with prior case law that had upheld statutes limiting remedies available at common law and statutes abolishing common law causes of action.  Moreover, the Court reasoned that a jury retains the opportunity to make a factual determination as to the amount of non-economic damages.  Only after that determination does the trial court then limit the award as a matter of law based on the statutory cap.  Second, the Court rejected a challenge to the cap under the separation of powers provision of the Tennessee Constitution.  The Court concluded that the cap is a substantive change in the law that rests within the authority of the legislature and does not interfere with the courts’ authority to apply and interpret the law.  Finally, the Court held that the statutory cap does not violate the equal protection provision of the Tennessee Constitution.  Specifically, the Court concluded that Ms. McClay’s claim that the statute had a disparate impact on women was not a cognizable claim under the equal protection provisions of the Tennessee Constitution without proof of a discriminatory purpose.  Accordingly, the majority of the Court held that the statutory cap on non-economic damages was constitutional under the Tennessee Constitution.

Justice Holly Kirby joined in the majority opinion and also filed a separate opinion further explaining her reasoning for holding that the cap does not violate the constitutional right to a jury trial.  Justice Kirby said that the State’s founders included a right to a jury trial in the constitution to address whether the judge or the jury will decide issues to be resolved in a court case.  It was not intended to prohibit substantive legislative enactments.  Instead, she said, the constitutional provision historically was intended to function as a restraint on judicial power.

Justice Cornelia A. Clark filed a dissenting opinion.  Justice Clark concluded that the statutory cap violates the right to jury trial provision of the Tennessee Constitution, which guarantees that the right of trial by jury as it existed at common law “shall remain inviolate.”  Justice Clark opined that this constitutional provision guarantees litigants the right to have a jury determine both the type and amount of damages.  Justice Clark reasoned that the statutory cap usurps the jury’s constitutionally protected function and renders the jury’s factual findings meaningless. 

Justice Sharon G. Lee filed a separate dissenting opinion stating that the cap renders a jury's verdict for non-economic damages meaningless when the verdict exceeds the cap.  In addition, she noted that the majority's analysis did not follow previous case law which emphasized that injured parties have a right under the Tennessee Constitution for a jury to decide both the type and the amount of damages awarded at trial.  The cap on non-economic damages takes away that constitutional right and essentially reduces the jury's role to a mere procedural formality.  Justice Lee's dissenting opinion explains that Tennessee does not have a problem in Tennessee with "runaway juries" and, by using real-life examples, points out that the cap affects only the most seriously injured victims.

To read the Supreme Court’s majority opinion in Jodi McClay v. Airport Management Services, LLC, authored by Chief Justice Jeff Bivins, as well as the concurring opinion authored by Justice Holly Kirby and the dissenting opinions authored by Justices Cornelia A. Clark and Sharon G. Lee, go to the opinions section of TNCourts.gov.


Signal Mountain Nursery Still Selling Local-Grown Plants

UT, TVA Sign Agreement On Advance Nuclear Reactor Demonstration

Martin Pierce: Make Or Update Your Will And Advance Directives


Governor Bill Lee’s shelter in place order has changed many people’s lives. With parks closed and trails unavailable for use, there are fewer things to do out in the open air. But throughout ... (click for more)

The University of Tennessee and the Tennessee Valley Authority signed a memorandum of understanding to evaluate the development of a new generation of cost-effective advanced nuclear reactors, ... (click for more)

With the COVID-19 pandemic, we are having many people ask us about getting their wills and estate planning done and updated. Our office is open and we are helping people daily with this important ... (click for more)




Business

Signal Mountain Nursery Still Selling Local-Grown Plants

Governor Bill Lee’s shelter in place order has changed many people’s lives. With parks closed and trails unavailable for use, there are fewer things to do out in the open air. But throughout this strange time, one popular activity has been gardening and landscaping. For those around the Signal Mountain area, Mark Bonastia and the Signal Mountain Nursery is the place to go if they ... (click for more)

UT, TVA Sign Agreement On Advance Nuclear Reactor Demonstration

The University of Tennessee and the Tennessee Valley Authority signed a memorandum of understanding to evaluate the development of a new generation of cost-effective advanced nuclear reactors, such as small modular reactors, at TVA’s 935-acre Clinch River Nuclear Site in Roane County. TVA has not made a decision to build and would first need approval from the Nuclear Regulatory ... (click for more)

Breaking News

Georgia Coronavirus Cases Now Over 10,000; 369 Deaths

Georgia state health officials said Wednesday evening that another seven people have died from the coronavirus since Wednesday morning, bringing the total to 369. The confirmed cases are now over 10,000, at 10,189, up from 9,156 on Tuesday. Officials said 2,082 have been hospitalized in Georgia with the deadly virus - up from 1,899 on Tuesday. Whitfield County remains ... (click for more)

7 More Die Of Coronavirus In Tennessee; Cases Go To 4,362; Hamilton County Has 94 Cases With 49 Recovered

Tennessee now has 79 coronavirus deaths - up seven since the Tuesday report. Cases have gone up from 4,138 to 4,362. Officials said 449 people have been hospitalized in the state from coronavirus. The state report shows 94 cases in Hamilton County and nine deaths. Of the total cases, 49 have recovered and 27 are still in the hospital. County Mayor Jim Coppinger said ... (click for more)

Opinion

Chaos Is The Enemy

What if there is a COVID-19 conspiracy? The internet, radio talk shows, and the national news networks talk conspiracy all night and all day from all angles. Pro Trump, anti Trump, 5G network, Chinese bio-lab accident or maybe not. Could be as advertised, a new virus (read flu) that is very strong because no one has ever had it before and there is no natural built up immunity. Like ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: Manny Sethi's Weekend

On Friday morning the phone rang at 1 a.m., calling Manny Sethi – who is in a race to become the next senator from Tennessee – to come to the hospital. Sethi, who is one of Nashville’s premier trauma surgeons, would then perform not one surgery, but nine more before he went back home about mid-morning on Monday. “I guess I was working about 80 hours a week in the operating room,” ... (click for more)