Playing Chess In Public Policy

Friday, May 29, 2020
In chess each player begins the game with the same 16 pieces: one king, one queen, two rooks, two knights, two bishops, and eight pawns. The most powerful chess piece is the queen, and the least powerful piece is the pawn. The object is to capture your opponent's king. To reach this objective, a player's pieces are used to attack and capture your opponent's pieces, while at the same time supporting your own pieces and protecting your king.

Politics and public policy are like chess. Unlike chess, politics is not a polite and gentle game. In fact, politics is a blood sport in many circles, where victors vanquish their foes. It isn’t as if this is some current phenomena either; Yale University historian Joanne B. Freeman writes in her book, The Field of Blood: Violence in Congress and the Road to Civil War, that 19th-century House and Senate members were a rough crowd. Freeman states they were “frequently drunk, often armed, and quick to take offense — and political disagreements regularly turned physical.”

It could be reasoned that today is mild in comparison, but I am also not certain we are far from the actions of our ancestors; we have simply traded weapons for keyboards. It is worth remembering that you cannot make friends of your enemies by making enemies of your friends. Too often politicians do not understand their own base of support and lose their followers. It may be from clinging too long to wrong ideas, or not engaging directly with people who may share similar ideas but offer differing approaches to solutions.

Morton Blackwell summarizes political conflict this way: “To succeed inside a political party, one must cultivate an ability to sit still and remain polite while foolish people speak nonsense.” That is probably easier said than done. Roman Emperor Marcus Aurelius had two rules in dealing with differing opinions: The first rule was to “keep an untroubled spirit.” The second was to “look things in the face and know them for what they are.” In other words, don’t be bothered by opposing ideas and keep to your principles. We are all shaken by circumstances and frightened by challenges. No person, no organization, nor any political party has all the answers.

I would argue that civility actually matters in politics. Ravi Zacharias nailed this issue when he said: “respect for the right of another to be wrong does not mean that the wrong is right.” We need more statesmanship in our world. Statesmanship is not just playing the game of politics well, but making that very game possible. Wendell Coats describes statesmanship as “an activity directed toward securing the conditions for politics to occur, as the basis for agreement about general courses of action, and for moderate reconciliation of differences among fellow citizens.” The same is true in public policy - we must account for differing opinions.

Good policy is intertwined with good politics. Never personalize the issue. Instead of screaming at each other from opposite sides of the political spectrum, imagine policies focused on helping those it is designed to help. When it comes to dealing with COVID-19 Pandemic issues, taking a long-range view, as we have on other policy issues, will require years of fiscal discipline, policy prudence, and deep community engagement. In education policy, we have to maintain funding for public education, which gives impetus to our economy. It is good policy, as well as good politics.

Choose your battles carefully in politics, and fight for what really matters. Not every issue or personnel matter is important. However, it is true personnel is policy, because the people you place in leadership roles make decisions that either support or hurt your agenda. While we should strive to have a diversified group of people to help build consensus, it does not serve the public to have a contentious leader in charge of an area that makes you lose ground in policy areas, or with your political base. Every problem in politics or public policy requires your time, energy, and political capital. Sally Percy, writing in Forbes Magazine, asks a very thoughtful question leaders must always ask: Is this your battle to fight?

In discussing chess, Rudolph Spielmann writes about the goal: “Play the opening like a book, the middlegame like a magician, and the endgame like a machine.” Chess is a journey of pain, sacrifices, determination, and triumph. It can be argued that it mirrors the public policy process. Just like politics, you may learn much more from a game you lose than from a game you win.

JC Bowman
Executive Director of Professional Educators of Tennessee

The Connection Between Nashville And Connecticut - And Response

2 Realities

Just Win, Baby

Excellent article by Roy on the financial travails of our capital city. Nashville is one of the fastest growing metro areas in the country. Connecticut is one of the wealthiest states in the ... (click for more)

There is a case in the United States today that exist as two realities. One is the absolute belief in Donald Trump and the other is absolute belief that the country is heading for a possible ... (click for more)

Former Raiders owner Al Davis of the National Football League had a motto: "Just win, baby." As a former coach, it pains me to say this: “Winning is not everything.” It certainly isn’t the only ... (click for more)


The Connection Between Nashville And Connecticut - And Response

Excellent article by Roy on the financial travails of our capital city. Nashville is one of the fastest growing metro areas in the country. Connecticut is one of the wealthiest states in the country. So what does a city in the Mid-South have in common with a New England state? Well two things actually. 1. They are both overwhelmingly governed by Democrats. 2. They are both ... (click for more)

2 Realities

There is a case in the United States today that exist as two realities. One is the absolute belief in Donald Trump and the other is absolute belief that the country is heading for a possible calamity the likes of which have never been seen nor experienced in the democratic country we live. The normal checks and balances for government have been put aside for what is likely ... (click for more)

Breaking News

Hamilton County Has 2 More COVID Deaths And 91 More Cases

Hamilton County has two new coronavirus deaths as the toll climbs to 94. The number of new cases in Hamilton County on Friday was 91 - up from the prior day's 64. The new total is 9,542. Hamilton County has had 8,833 people recover from the virus (93 percent) and there are 615 active cases - up from 603 yesterday. There are 52 people hospitalized in the county from coronavirus, ... (click for more)

Chattooga And Walker Counties Each Have Another COVID Death; Georgia Has 53 Deaths

Georgia state health officials reported on Friday there have been an additional 53 deaths due to the coronavirus. The new total is 6,874. There were 1,547 new cases as that total reached 312,514 confirmed cases of coronavirus. Hospitalizations are at 28,035, up 132 from Thursday. Here are the numbers by county: Catoosa County: 1,171 cases, up 16; 18 deaths; 77 ... (click for more)


Dalton State Ladies Picked To Win SSAC Cross Country Championship

MONTGOMERY, Ala. – Defending SSAC champion Dalton State (Ga.) claimed the top spot in the 2020-21 SSAC Women's Cross Country Coaches' Preseason Poll. 2020-21 SSAC Women's Cross Country Coaches' Preseason Poll 1. Dalton State (Ga.) – 63 (7) 2. William Carey (Miss.) – 53 (1) 3. Blue Mountain (Miss.) – 52 4. Mobile (Ala.) – 39 5. Middle Georgia – 31 6. Brewton-Parker ... (click for more)

Chattanooga FC Announces The Addition Of Midfielder Cutler Coleman

Chattanooga FC is strengthening their squad as the NISA Fall Championship Tournament continues. The team today announces the signing of midfielder Cutler Coleman from Amherst College. Coleman captained Amherst to the NCAA DIII finals, earning third team All-American honors, First team All-NESCAC and Second Team All-Region. “We are very happy to have added to our roster Cutler ... (click for more)