Chamber, Quit Virtue Signaling - And Response (2)

Tuesday, May 4, 2021

Sprinkled liberally throughout the Chattanooga Chamber of Commerce’s “CEOs for Racial Equity – Pledge”, to be signed by its members, are the words “Equity”, “Equality” and “Prosperity”. Let’s call these words the new “virtues”. The Pledge is asking that these virtues be embraced, and that the business community admit its past indiscretion of systematic racism.

 

A friend, who I greatly admire, shared some thoughts on his theory of what is behind the Pledge.

He said, after a close read of the Chamber Pledge –

“Equitable”, in common parlance, means “just and fair.” I don’t understand what “just and fair” prosperity is. I don’t understand “just” prosperity or “fair” prosperity. I don’t understand “the ability for everyone to prosper” either. All we can provide, and what we should provide, is the opportunity for everyone to prosper. We cannot make people able to prosper. We can and should make education and training a level playing field and, in some instances, a field slanted to be favorable for people who need it. The pledge insinuates we as a community have not addressed these problems. But they have been addressed, and more than addressed, by most any business leader who would have the opportunity to sign the pledge. The Pledge, pure and simple, is virtue signaling.

 

So, what is virtue signaling? My Google search reveals that – “Virtue signaling is the conspicuous expression of moral values. Academically, the phrase relates to signaling theory and describes a subset of social behaviors that could be used to signal virtue. Since 2015 the term has been more commonly used within groups to criticize those who are seen to value the expression of virtue over action.” Virtue signaling is a pejorative term.

Business owners should “signal” to the Chamber leadership that it needs to focus on its mission of attracting businesses and well-paying jobs to the Chattanooga area. Call your County Commissioner and ask that the county demand the Chamber leave social justice warrioring to our local foundations and to leftist political activists.

Second, withhold your membership dues to the Chamber as your “Pledge” to help get the Chamber back on track.

Tom Decosimo

* * * 

I found it interesting, yet disappointing, to read Mr. Decosimo’s opinion regarding the Chamber’s CEO Pledge for Racial Equality. If Mr. Decosimo is under the impression that systematic racism does not or has not existed in this community, then I would recommend about 20 minutes with Google to bring him up to speed. Further, I would steer him toward the Harvard Business Review article in which he will note: “Research has shown that companies with effective Corporate Social Responsibility programs are more profitable than those that aren’t.”

Perhaps we can chalk his opinion up to implicit bias. Mr. Decosimo may be one of those folks who has no conscious knowledge of his own prejudices. This, sometimes, can be a powerful obstacle to overcome.

I applaud the courage and the risk taken by Ms. Gillenwater with her willingness to lead the charge in this rather politically sensitive endeavor. Numerous corporations around the nation have for some time embraced social responsibility and, now more than ever, corporations are implementing social justice programs into their business models.

The claims made by Mr. Decosimo’s admired friend are also disheartening. He (or she) states: “The pledge insinuates we as a community have not addressed these problems. But they have been addressed, and more than addressed, by most any business leader who would have the opportunity to sign the pledge.” What? We have more than addressed the problems of inequity and racially discriminatory problems in the Chattanooga region’s private sector? Really? This speaks to textbook implicit bias.

The old guard is clinging tenaciously to the status quo and the disinformation that surrounds it. As a nation, we seem to be finally waking up to our long, insidious efforts to oppress and deny power to people of color. Ms. Gillenwater is suggesting a call to action by CEOs. Hers is not a case of virtue signaling; I repeat, it is a call to action.

Now, if Mr. Decosimo and friend do not support or do not want to participate in social justice, that’s their prerogative. But to attempt to throw shade at an important, timely and needed initiative from the Chamber is, in my opinion, totally unnecessary and strongly counterproductive to much needed change.

Mr. Decosimo seems to fairly clearly indicate that he frowns on social justice, stating in essence that it only belongs in foundations and with leftist political activists. Okay, we understand. He also seems unable to understand that the Chamber can incorporate into its mission positive, proactive components that can and will benefit the entire community.

Lastly, to suggest that businesses withhold their Chamber dues is simply an undignified proposal for which I trust Mr. Decosimo is regretful.

Gregory Smith

* * * 

I do not know Mr. Smith, but I suspect that the Decosimo family has done more to alleviate poverty and provide opportunity in Chattanooga then his lecturing rhetoric on the Chattanoogan will accomplish.

John Hollingsworth


Dean Moorhouse Thanks Supporters

Send Your Opinions To Chattanoogan.com; Include Your Full Name, Address, Phone Number For Verification

Roy Exum: Sethi Wants Term Limits


I would like to thank my many supporters in District 9 who sent emails, made calls to commissioners on my behalf, and encouraged others to do likewise. Unfortunately I fell short of the necessary ... (click for more)

We welcome your opinions at Chattanoogan.com. Email to news@chattanoogan.com . We require your real first and last name and contact information. This includes your home address and phone ... (click for more)

Manny Sethi, the son of immigrants from India, had no experience whatsoever in 2020 when he, a 42-year-old, challenged Bill Hagerty to replace a retiring Lamar Alexander as a Senator from Tennessee. ... (click for more)



Opinion

Dean Moorhouse Thanks Supporters

I would like to thank my many supporters in District 9 who sent emails, made calls to commissioners on my behalf, and encouraged others to do likewise. Unfortunately I fell short of the necessary five votes. Your continued support, your encouragement, and especially your love of our community makes District 9, indeed the crown jewel of Hamilton County. And to Commissioner Bankston ... (click for more)

Send Your Opinions To Chattanoogan.com; Include Your Full Name, Address, Phone Number For Verification

We welcome your opinions at Chattanoogan.com. Email to news@chattanoogan.com . We require your real first and last name and contact information. This includes your home address and phone number. We do not post the contact information, but need it for verification. There is no word limit, but if your article is too long you may lose your reader. Please focus more on issues ... (click for more)

Breaking News

Greg Vital, Hoyt Samples, D'Angelo Jelks Pick Up For House District 29 Race

Businessman Greg Vital, who lost a squeaker of a race to Todd Gardenhire for state Senate in 2012, has picked up papers to run as a Republican for House District 29. Attorney Hoyt Samples also picked up to run on the GOP side. D'Angelo Jelks is a Democratic candidate. The County Commission has appointed Joan Carter to serve until the election. She is the widow of Mike Carter, ... (click for more)

National Cemetery Director Says 6 Potential Sites Picked For Expansion Of Cemetery; Veteran Services To Move Back To Cemetery

Chattanooga VA National Cemetery Director Deborah Kendrick said the VA has identified six possible sites for cemetery expansion in Chattanooga. She said those locations have not been made public. Ms. Kendrick said the VA hopes to break ground for a new cemetery in 2027 or 2028. The federal government said last year that it was running out of ground at the cemetery and was ... (click for more)

Sports

Chuckie Robinson's Bomb Is The Difference - Greene Strikes Out Nine E

Jose Barrero is known for his bat, but he showed his glove was just as good in a great play during the fifth inning of the Lookouts 1-0 win against the Pensacola Blue Wahoos. On a difficult ground ball, he slid to one side, scooped up the grounder, tapped on second, and jumped to avoid the sliding runner while rifling a throw to first. In what was a scoreless game, web gems like ... (click for more)

Jumbotron Completed At Red Wolves' CHI Memorial Stadium

Chattanooga Red Wolves officials announced on Friday the completion of CHI Memorial Stadium's brand new Jumbotron. The Jumbotron boasts over 2,000 square feet in size or approximately 34’ by 61’ making it the largest in the city of Chattanooga and one of the largest digital scoreboards in the state of Tennessee. The Jumbotron houses 732,672 LEDs, 4k video resolution and 3 in ... (click for more)