Supreme Court Grants Tax Refunds To Insurance Companies

  • Friday, October 2, 2015

In a unanimous opinion, the Tennessee Supreme Court ruled Friday that the Tennessee Department of Commerce and Insurance must refund more than $16 million in taxes paid by five groups of out-of-state insurance companies. 

Tennessee, like every other state except Hawaii, has adopted a retaliatory tax statute unique to the insurance industry. The statute, which is designed to equalize tax burdens across state lines, protects each state’s domestic insurance companies against discriminatory or excessive taxes that may be imposed when doing business in other states. The way the statute works is that if “State A” charges higher fees, taxes, or fines against “State B’s” insurance companies when they do business in “State A,” then “State B” can impose a retaliatory tax on “State A’s” insurance companies when they do business in “State B.” 

In 2012, five groups of Pennsylvania insurance companies requested refunds from the Tennessee Department of Commerce and Insurance for taxes they were required to pay under the retaliatory tax statute after the state of Tennessee conducted an audit. The Pennsylvania companies argued that they should not have to calculate certain Pennsylvania workers’ compensation assessments as part of their retaliatory tax in Tennessee because the assessments were paid by policyholders, not the insurance companies themselves. 

The Supreme Court agreed, concluding that the Tennessee Department of Commerce and Insurance could not impose a retaliatory tax because the assessments do not impose a direct financial burden on Tennessee insurance companies doing business in Pennsylvania. 

To read the unanimous opinion in Chartis Casualty Company et al. v. State of Tennessee, authored by Justice Gary R. Wade, go to the opinions section of TNCourts.gov.

Business
New Hamilton County Business Licenses
  • 7/14/2025

Here are the new business licenses from the County Clerk's office: AFTERGLOW BEAUTY MALEAH TAKROURI 5139 RINGGOLD RD STE D CHATTANOOGA TN 37412 BARNES YARD SERVICES JEREMY G BARNES 6005 ... more

The Chattery Announces Keynote Speaker For 2nd Annual Bloom Creative Summit
The Chattery Announces Keynote Speaker For 2nd Annual Bloom Creative Summit
  • 7/11/2025

Local nonprofit, The Chattery, is hosting Bloom Creative Summit, a one-day conference designed for Black women and nonbinary creatives to connect, cultivate community and learn from one another. ... more

Annual Sales Tax Holiday Is July 25-27
  • 7/11/2025

The State of Tennessee’s annual sales tax holiday weekend will take place Friday, July 25 through Sunday, July 27. During this holiday, Tennesseans can save nearly 10 percent on qualifying ... more