Supreme Court Grants Tax Refunds To Insurance Companies

Friday, October 2, 2015

In a unanimous opinion, the Tennessee Supreme Court ruled Friday that the Tennessee Department of Commerce and Insurance must refund more than $16 million in taxes paid by five groups of out-of-state insurance companies. 

Tennessee, like every other state except Hawaii, has adopted a retaliatory tax statute unique to the insurance industry. The statute, which is designed to equalize tax burdens across state lines, protects each state’s domestic insurance companies against discriminatory or excessive taxes that may be imposed when doing business in other states. The way the statute works is that if “State A” charges higher fees, taxes, or fines against “State B’s” insurance companies when they do business in “State A,” then “State B” can impose a retaliatory tax on “State A’s” insurance companies when they do business in “State B.” 

In 2012, five groups of Pennsylvania insurance companies requested refunds from the Tennessee Department of Commerce and Insurance for taxes they were required to pay under the retaliatory tax statute after the state of Tennessee conducted an audit. The Pennsylvania companies argued that they should not have to calculate certain Pennsylvania workers’ compensation assessments as part of their retaliatory tax in Tennessee because the assessments were paid by policyholders, not the insurance companies themselves. 

The Supreme Court agreed, concluding that the Tennessee Department of Commerce and Insurance could not impose a retaliatory tax because the assessments do not impose a direct financial burden on Tennessee insurance companies doing business in Pennsylvania. 

To read the unanimous opinion in Chartis Casualty Company et al. v. State of Tennessee, authored by Justice Gary R. Wade, go to the opinions section of TNCourts.gov.


Chattanooga Startup Text Request Shortlisted For Global 2021 SaaS Awards

Commissioner Parker Announces Retirement

Kayleigh McEnany To Speak At Athens Chamber Event In 2022


Chattanooga-based startup, Text Request, has been named a finalist in the 2021 SaaS Awards in the category “Best SaaS Product for Small Business/SMEs.” This is the second year in a row that the ... (click for more)

After 38 years of service to the Tennessee Department of Correction, Commissioner Tony Parker has announced his retirement, effective this fall. Comm. Parker began his career as a correctional ... (click for more)

The Athens Chamber of Commerce announces their 15th Annual Benefit will be June 25, 2022, with Kayleigh McEnany. The event will be held in the McMinn County High School gymnasium. Tickets ... (click for more)



Business

Chattanooga Startup Text Request Shortlisted For Global 2021 SaaS Awards

Chattanooga-based startup, Text Request, has been named a finalist in the 2021 SaaS Awards in the category “Best SaaS Product for Small Business/SMEs.” This is the second year in a row that the business has earned this distinction. Now in its sixth year of celebrating software innovation, the Software-as-a-Service Awards program accepts entries worldwide, including the US, ... (click for more)

Commissioner Parker Announces Retirement

After 38 years of service to the Tennessee Department of Correction, Commissioner Tony Parker has announced his retirement, effective this fall. Comm. Parker began his career as a correctional officer and rose through the ranks to commissioner following his initial appointment by former Governor Bill Haslam in 2016 and re-appointment by Governor Bill Lee in 2019. “I am forever ... (click for more)

Breaking News

Federal Government Will Not Further Prosecute Former Pilot President Mark Hazelwood, 2 Co-Defendants

The federal government has decided not to further prosecute Mark Hazelwood, the former president of Pilot Travel Centers, as well as two co-defendants. After a trial that concluded three years ago, Hazelwood got 12 1/2 years and a $750,000 fine, while Scott Wombold received six years and a $75,000 fine and Heather Jones got 2 1/2 years for defrauding trucking firms of promised ... (click for more)

Signal Mountain Council Still Struggling With How To Cover Needed Pay Increases For Employees

The Signal Mountain Town Council unanimously wants to support the town’s employees with a pay increase but cannot decide where the money will come from. None of the members are happy with the options that they have, since this significant expense was added after a balanced budget had already been presented. Two scenarios are being considered: Taking $645,185 from the fund balance. ... (click for more)

Opinion

McDonald Farm Was Certainly No Bargain

I attended the meeting held by county officials on Thursday at Sale Creek High School. Mr. Coppinger gave a background on the purchase of the farm and also what possible future uses might be. In his comments he mentioned the word “transparency” multiple times. To my way of thinking this so called transparency in the use of taxpayer money would have been to put this before the county ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: "Variant" Scares Parents

The public schools within the limits of Hamilton County (TN) will register all students on Friday, Aug. 6, and the first official school day will follow on Thursday (Aug. 12). At summer’s beginning, we thought the return might be easy. People were vaccinating and our masks were laid aside. After the last school year, which was chaos and a total disaster to any child’s development, ... (click for more)