Mother Of 15-Year-Old Killed By His Father Said McElrath Had Been Acting "Manic"

Wednesday, September 19, 2018
Michael McElrath
Michael McElrath

The mother of a 15-year-old boy who was killed by his father said Michael McElrath had been acting "manic" in the days leading up to the tragic incident in Hixson on Aug. 18.

Judge Alex McVeigh bound a charge of criminal homicide against McElrath, a former jail officer, to the Grand Jury.

He is charged in the death of Dylan McElrath, who was a sophomore at Hixson High School.

Ms. McElrath said her husband of 21 years began acting strangely on Thursday prior to the Saturday incident in which Scout, the family's Labrador Retriever, was also shot and killed.

She said the "odd behavior" began when McElrath said he wanted her to know that he had cheated on her. She said he asked for forgiveness, and she said she told him he would forgive him.

The witness said her husband also told her their son had had sex. She said the son was "petrified" about that statement and told her privately it had not happened.

She said McElrath told her and their son, "Good things are going to happen." She said he stated they were going to get $150,000 - either through his invention or the lottery. He said it was going to happen in three days.

She said the invention involved use of two TENS unit to relieve pain. She said her husband was in constant pain (complex regional pain syndrome) after a surgery. She said he was mainly confined to a wheelchair.

The witness said, "He was so excited that it was going to happen. He was happy."

She said she was able to calm him down, and she said she would buy some lottery tickets.

Ms. McElrath said her husband also talked about inventions, science and God. She said, "Everything was in threes." 

She said her husband on Friday said "if he didn't die that something bad was going to happen the next night."

That Saturday she said she fixed his breakfast and "he seemed fine." She said he had her wake up their son and he talked more about God, religion and "wanting to get rid of war."

She said the family gathered in their master bedroom at their house on Cotter Road and he had them hugging each other. She said he told them he was God, their son was Jesus Christ and she was the Holy Spirit.

Ms. McElrath said she always used reading glasses, but he told her he would rub her eyes three times with a chemical and she would no longer need the glasses. She said he did so, but she still could not see well.

She said she told him he was "acting manic" so he calmed down. She said he then appeared to be fine.

Ms. McElrath said she went back to bed around 9 p.m. She said she sleeps with ear plugs and a mask over her face because her husband ans son would keep the TV on..

She said she woke up during the night and her husband came in carrying their dog Scout. She said he gave her a fierce hug with one hand while doing the same with the dog with the other.

The witness said she noticed McElrath had blood on the lower part of his shirt, but he said, "Don't worry about it. It's just a bad dream. Go back to sleep."

Then she said he asked her to shoot him in the head. She said she noticed that two handguns had been placed on the bottom of the bed.

She said she got up and saw the dog lying on the floor. "It looked like he was dead," she stated.

Ms. McElrath said she then went into her son's room and found where he had been sitting on his knees. She saw several wounds on his arms.

She said there were two gunshot wounds to his chest, and he had no pulse.

By then, she said McElrath was gone. She said she had not seen or talked to him since.

A county deputy said he found McElrath on the porch of a neighbor's house. The neighbors had called 911, saying a naked man was knocking on their door.

He said McElrath was still completely without clothes. Following commands, he slid down the front steps and was handcuffed.

The deputy said McElrath stated, "I'm so sorry. I shot my son. I don't know why."

He said McElrath afterward was lying on his stomach and saying he could not feel his legs. He was taken to a nearby hospital to be checked out.

McElrath then asked for a lawyer, it was stated.

County Investigator Adam Patterson said some 10 9mm shells were found in Dylan's bedroom. He said two handgun (a 9mm and a 22) were found on the TV stand. 

Click here to listen to the court recording. 





Top Hamilton County Schools Salaries 2019

Man Who Has Been In Jail Since Last October On Rape Charge Is Seeking Bond Reduction

Christopher Hedrick, 44, Identified As Victim In Last Thursday's Stabbing On East Main Street

Here are the top Hamilton County Schools salaries for 2019: (click for more)

A man who has been in jail since last Oct. 9 on a rape charge is seeking a lower bond. Jay Perry, attorney for Richard Hymon Jr., said the alleged victim in the case is not cooperating with ... (click for more)

The victim from the homicide which occurred last Thursday morning in the 1200 block of East Main Street has been identified as Christopher Hedrick, 44. Chattanooga Police ask anyone with ... (click for more)

Breaking News

Top Hamilton County Schools Salaries 2019

Here are the top Hamilton County Schools salaries for 2019: (click for more)

Man Who Has Been In Jail Since Last October On Rape Charge Is Seeking Bond Reduction

A man who has been in jail since last Oct. 9 on a rape charge is seeking a lower bond. Jay Perry, attorney for Richard Hymon Jr., said the alleged victim in the case is not cooperating with the prosecution. Prosecutor Andrew Coyle said the woman testified at the preliminary hearing. He said when she is called, she says she will work with the state. However, he said she has ... (click for more)


What Does The White Privilege Presentation Have To Do With Education?

On Aug. 2, Hamilton County Schools held a professional development presented by motivational speaker Robert Jackson. The PD was for the teachers in the Opportunity Zone, which includes the 12 lowest-performing schools in Hamilton County where 90 percent of the students are black. During the 90-minute presentation, there was a 15-20-minute segment concerning “White Privilege”. ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: 'White Privilege' Is A Myth

Several weeks ago, I must admit I had never heard of Patrick Hampton, an African American who has just joined a promising conservative think talk not-for-profit group known as Hamilton Flourishing. Headed by longtime executive and dream-maker Doug Daugherty, the group is in the perfect position to make a lasting impact on our all-inclusive community. Patrick Hampton made a huge ... (click for more)


Grace Rally Tops Hixson In Volleyball Opener

High school volleyball teams have been practicing for several weeks and no doubt, are ready for a real match so they can show what they’ve learned so far. Monday was the first day of the season. No question some coaches were happier than others with final results, but it’s a good bet that all identified multiple areas where improvement needs to be made if they have a chance of ... (click for more)


Opening night volleyball action saw CSAS defeat East Ridge, 3-0, while Rhea County blanked Red Bank. In other area matches East Hamilton continued to build on a great 2018 campaign with a 3-0 win over Silverdale, Lookout valley defeated Patriots, 3-0 and Boyd-Buchanan blanked Soddy Daisy. CCS won, 3-0, over Bradley Central. Opening night also saw one of last year’s state finalists ... (click for more)