Jerry Summers: The Other Side Of The Story Of "When Justice Prevailed"

Saturday, September 26, 2020 - by Jerry Summers
Jerry Summers
Jerry Summers

On Thursday, Sept. 17, I wrote an article in Chattanoogan.com titled “When Justice Prevailed” wherein I portrayed the heroic efforts of two white Hamilton County deputies - jailer Holt and deputy Frank Selcer under Sheriff John Skillern. They prevented the lynching of a black man, Frank Weims, in May 1882, for an attempted sexual assault of a white woman under the laws that provided hanging of a black man for having consensual sex with a white woman.  Weims was threatened to be hung under the “lynch law” as described by the facts stated in my September 17 article.  (Available under “All Happenings Articles.”)

The same law did not provide a criminal punishment for a white man having sex with a black woman and even then, she was presumed to have consented although not necessary.

The purpose of this follow up story is that when I researched the facts of the Weims case further for the purpose of perhaps writing a favorable article about some person that may have also acted honorably in our community I came up with some startling facts.

Yes, Weims was allowed to plead guilty after a trial, receive a sentence of 25 years and escape the lynch mob.

However, an excerpt from Digital History I.D.

3614 based on the novel by one of the most outspoken female African American critics of lynching, Author Ida B. Wells, written in 1892, “Southern Horrors.  Lynch Law in All Its Phases” adds significant facts to the original article and needs to be presented to the reading public.

Yes, Weims got a trial after the alleged victim’s “public men” demanded that he receive one and “guarded him while the trial was in progress.”

Unfortunately, the trial only lasted 10 minutes and Weims then chose to plead guilty and accept the 21-year sentence (my original article stated 25-year-old sentence).

It was stated that going to a full trial would “invite the certain death of which awaited him outside that cordon of police if he had told the truth and shown the letters he had from the white woman in the case.  Whether the letters revealed a consensual relationship or the alleged victim denied that a crime had taken place was not explained.

Which version is true is like today watching a story on a liberal news channel and then switching to a conservative news channel?  The truth in reporting any events is often lost in its airing to the public.

This is not the type of historical story that I feel comfortable about reporting with the Sept. 24 article or Sept. 17 article without telling both sides.

Based on Ida B. Wells’ anti-lynching position in her Memphis Newspaper, “The Free Speech” it was destroyed by a mob and the event in great part was published in an edition of the paper, “New York Age” on June 25, 1892.

* * *

Jerry Summers

(If you have additional information about one of Mr. Summers' articles or have suggestions or ideas about a future Chattanooga area historical piece, please contact Mr. Summers at jsummers@summersfirm.com)


Dr. Mary Walker Exhibit Is At Medal Of Honor Heritage Center 1 More Week

East Hamilton High's 3rd Annual Community Day Car Show Is Nov. 7

Chattanooga Skydiving Company To Host Women's State Record Skydiving Attempt


Due to popular demand, the current exhibit at the Charles H. Coolidge National Medal of Honor Heritage Center, Dr. Mary Walker: Surgeon, Spy, and Patriot, will stay at the Heritage Center one ... (click for more)

East Hamilton High School's third annual Community Day Car Show will be held on Saturday, Nov. 7 from 10 a.m.-2 p.m. at 2015 Ooltewah Ringgold Road. The event is free to the public. Activities ... (click for more)

The Chattanooga Skydiving Company announces the Tennessee Women’s State Record attempts will be held Saturday at 8 a.m. at the Marion County Airport, 300 Airport Road, in Jasper, Tn. These ... (click for more)



Happenings

Dr. Mary Walker Exhibit Is At Medal Of Honor Heritage Center 1 More Week

Due to popular demand, the current exhibit at the Charles H. Coolidge National Medal of Honor Heritage Center, Dr. Mary Walker: Surgeon, Spy, and Patriot, will stay at the Heritage Center one week more. This is the last chance to see in person Dr. Walker's reissued Medal of Honor on loan from the Pentagon in Washington D.C., as well as many of her personal items from museums ... (click for more)

East Hamilton High's 3rd Annual Community Day Car Show Is Nov. 7

East Hamilton High School's third annual Community Day Car Show will be held on Saturday, Nov. 7 from 10 a.m.-2 p.m. at 2015 Ooltewah Ringgold Road. The event is free to the public. Activities include food and live music, featuring Rock-It Science. Car entry fee is $10 or an unopened toy. Prizes include dash plaques, Top 10 and 50/50 drawing. Vendor booths are $20. ... (click for more)

Breaking News

General Motors To Invest Nearly $2 Billion In Spring Hill Manufacturing Plant

Governor Bill Lee, Department of Economic and Community Development Commissioner Bob Rolfe and General Motors officials announced Tuesday that the automaker will invest nearly $2 billion in its Spring Hill manufacturing plant to build fully electric vehicles, including the all-new, luxury Cadillac LYRIQ. This announcement adds to the more than $2.3 billion GM has invested in ... (click for more)

Lepard Says City Council Resolution On City Dealings With His Lighting Firm Should Include Apology For Alleged Actions Of Berke, Hinton

The owner of Global Green Lighting said a City Council resolution regarding the disposal of millions of dollars worth of lights sold to the city should include an apology to his company. Don Lepard said Mayor Andy Berke and City Attorney Wade Hinton conspired to discredit his company. The council today was to consider a resolution that is critical of former City Attorney Hinton, ... (click for more)

Opinion

BBB Identity Protection Day Failure

I was truly disappointed in the BBB’s actions on Saturday. They advertised a Shred and Prescription Medication take-back day in order to help protect identity. It was advertised from 9 a.m.-noon. I arrived on Saturday before 11 a.m., more than an hour before the scheduled and advertised end. I found a line of cars going both ways on Lee Highway, blocking traffic in both directions. ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: Stewart Statue Will Stay

There is no doubt the Hamilton County Commissioners will respond negatively tomorrow when a petition that calls for the removal of a Civil War statue from the courthouse grounds is brought before the group. The nine-person board will likely defeat the petition by a very predictable 6-3 margin and, for what it’s worth, the Tennessee Historical Commission will almost certainly balk ... (click for more)