Tennessee Supreme Court Rules Health Care Liability Act Applies To Medical Battery And Intentional Misrepresentation Claims

Against Health Care Providers

Thursday, January 20, 2022

The Tennessee Supreme Court has ruled that the Tennessee Health Care Liability Act applies to a lawsuit based on theories of medical battery and intentional misrepresentation against health care providers for injuries arising from a surgical procedure.

The Health Care Liability Act, among other things, requires a person who sues a health care provider for injuries arising from a health care service to give the provider 60 days’ notice before filing a lawsuit and to submit proof of compliance when the complaint is filed. The person filing the lawsuit must also file a certificate of good faith certifying that an expert witness has determined there is a good faith basis for the lawsuit if expert testimony is necessary to prove liability. Failure to comply with the notice and filing requirements of the Act may result in dismissal of the case.

The plaintiffs, Donna Cooper and her husband, Michael Cooper, sued the defendants, Dr. Mason Wesley Mandy, his employer, NuBody Concepts, LLC, and Middle Tennessee Surgical Services, PLLC in the Williamson County Circuit Court for medical battery and intentional misrepresentation. The plaintiffs claimed Ms. Cooper agreed for Dr. Mandy to operate on her after the defendants told her Dr. Mandy was a board-certified plastic surgeon with years of experience. But Dr. Mandy was not board-certified as a specialist in any field. The plaintiffs alleged that the surgery was unnecessarily painful, was performed in a barbaric fashion in unsterile conditions, and left Ms. Cooper disfigured and with grotesque and painful bacterial infections. The plaintiffs claimed Ms. Cooper would not have agreed to the surgery if she had known the truth about Dr. Mandy’s qualifications, and that the misrepresentations negated her consent to the surgery.

The defendants moved to dismiss the lawsuit because the plaintiffs failed to comply with the Health Care Liability Act’s procedural and filing requirements. The plaintiffs admitted their noncompliance but argued the Act did not apply because the misrepresentations were made in a “sales meeting” before Ms. Cooper and Dr. Mandy established a doctor-patient relationship. The trial court agreed with the plaintiffs, ruling that the defendants’ misrepresentations were unrelated to the provision of health care services because they were made before Dr. Mandy provided any health care services. The Court of Appeals affirmed.

The Tennessee Supreme Court unanimously reversed the judgments of the trial court and the Court of Appeals. The Supreme Court held that the Health Care Liability Act applied to the plaintiffs’ claims. Under the language of the Act, it applies to all claims alleging that a health care provider caused an injury that related to the provision of health care services, regardless of the theory of liability. Here, the plaintiffs alleged claims against the defendant health care providers arising from an unsuccessful surgical procedure. The defendants’ misrepresentations occurred during a pre-surgical meeting between Dr. Mandy and Ms. Cooper in which Dr. Mandy gave her information about the procedure, such as its risks and benefits, so she could give him informed consent to proceed. This meeting was a necessary part of the health care service provided by Dr. Mandy. Thus, under the Act’s broad definition of “health care liability action,” the Supreme Court held that the plaintiffs’ claims fell within the scope of the Act and returned the case to the trial court for further proceedings.

To read the opinion of the Court in Donna Cooper et al. v. Dr. Mason Wesley Mandy et al., authored by Justice Sharon G. Lee, please visit the Opinions section of TNCourts.gov.


Tennessee Employment Surpasses Pre-Pandemic Levels

Tennessee Supreme Court Holds Education Savings Account Pilot Program Doesn't Violate Home Rule Amendment

Chattanooga Chamber Calendar Of Events May 23-27


Tennessee nonfarm employment has fully rebounded from the pandemic, surpassing pre-pandemic levels of employment with 45,500 more people holding jobs now than in February 2020. The Tennessee ... (click for more)

In an opinion released Wednesday, the Tennessee Supreme Court determined that, while two Tennessee county governments had standing to challenge the Education Savings Account Pilot Program (the ... (click for more)

May 25, Red Bank/Signal Mountain Council Meeting 8:30-9:30 a.m. Red Bank Community Center: 3653 Tom Weathers Dr. Our speaker this month will be Dan Reuter, Administrator of the Department ... (click for more)



Business

Tennessee Employment Surpasses Pre-Pandemic Levels

Tennessee nonfarm employment has fully rebounded from the pandemic, surpassing pre-pandemic levels of employment with 45,500 more people holding jobs now than in February 2020. The Tennessee Quarterly Business and Economic Indicators report issued by Secretary of State Tre Hargett’s office shows that state unemployment dropped to 3.2 percent, below the national rate of 3.6 ... (click for more)

Tennessee Supreme Court Holds Education Savings Account Pilot Program Doesn't Violate Home Rule Amendment

In an opinion released Wednesday, the Tennessee Supreme Court determined that, while two Tennessee county governments had standing to challenge the Education Savings Account Pilot Program (the “ESA Act”), the Act is not rendered unconstitutional by the Home Rule Amendment, article XI, section 9, of the Tennessee Constitution. In 2019, the Tennessee General Assembly enacted ESA ... (click for more)

Breaking News

Man, 25, Shot And Killed On 13th Avenue

A 25-year-old man was shot and killed on 13th Avenue early Friday morning. At approximately 12:45 a.m., Chattanooga Police responded to the 3600 block of 13th Avenue on a report of a person shot. Upon arrival, officers located a man suffering from apparent gunshot wounds and secured the scene. Hamilton County EMS responded and pronounced the victim deceased on ... (click for more)

Man Bowfishing On Nickajack Lake Dies When Boat Sinks

Ronnie D. Gholston, age 24, of Whitwell, along with two other men, were bowfishing Thursday evening on Nickajack Lake. Around 10:30 p.m. their 15-foot Lowe fishing boat started to take on water. The three men jumped into the water to swim to shore. As they swam, two men in the group observed that Mr. Gholston was no longer communicating with them. The two men swam to an island ... (click for more)

Opinion

Reaching Across The Aisle

What comes to mind when I hear the outcry of sore losers in a mayoral race in Hamilton County in 2022? What comes to my mind is we have had elected officials in this county dating back years who were applauded for being able to bring Republicans and Democrats together in a race for mayor, sheriff, commissioner, council person, Senator, or State Representative. So why now does ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: No Longer ‘Pure’

There was a time, in the not-so-distant past, when college athletics were pure. There was no transfer portal, where the disgruntled athletes could scoff at commitment, loyalty, and tradition in vain pursuit of the NFL. And there was no “name, image, and likeness” (NIL) where college-aged teenagers are now paid for endorsements, autographs, appearances, and the like. During this ... (click for more)