Audit Says Assistant County Schools Nutrition Director Misappropriated Over $12,000

  • Tuesday, April 23, 2024
Andrew Woodbury
Andrew Woodbury

A report from the state's Comptroller office says the former assistant director of the county schools nutrition department misappropriated over $12,000 from the program.

Andrew Woodbury, 44, was suspended, then later terminated.

He was indicted by the Hamilton County Grand Jury on one count of theft of property over $2,500, one count of forgery, one count of misrepresenting information to the state auditor, and one count of official misconduct.

Officials said, "The Office of the Comptroller of the Treasury investigated allegations of malfeasance related to the Hamilton County Schools Department of School Nutrition. The investigation was initiated after Hamilton County Schools officials reported allegations that an employee misappropriated school nutrition assets and abused his position for personal gain."

Officials said, "The HCSN warehouse contains assets such as equipment and supplies not currently in use. When an asset is identified as broken or unusable, HCSN employees recommend that the asset be repaired, scrapped, salvaged for parts, or sold via auction. In order for an asset to be sold via auction, a Surplus Property Disposal Authorization Form must be completed for each warehouse inventory asset by the HCSN Accounting Manager. The form requires signature approval from the HCSN Director, the Hamilton County Schools Superintendent, and the Hamilton County Schools Board Chairman.

"After the approval process is complete, the asset can be listed for sale. During the investigative scope, the HCSN used GovDeals to facilitate surplus equipment sales. GovDeals is an “online marketplace that provides services to government, educational, and related entities for the sale of surplus assets to the public.”

The report says Woodbury "exceeded his authority as Assistant Director and intentionally or knowingly misappropriated assets valued at $12,374.68 by circumventing the HCSN’s established property disposal process.

"Investigators determined that three GovDeals accounts existed under the HCSN name. The third was identified as an unauthorized account created by Woodbury on October 18, 2021, and sale proceeds from this account were directly deposited into his personal bank account.

"Woodbury stated that the items sold through the unauthorized GovDeals account included:

- The sale of personal items, - The sale of items taken from HCSN dumpsters, and - The sale of HCSN’s surplus property assets.

"Woodbury did not request or receive proper authorization from the HCSN Accounting Manager or the HCSN Director for the sale of the HCSN’s surplus property through his unauthorized GovDeals account.

"Woodbury further bypassed the approval process by completing and signing his name on the line designated for the HCSN Director on the Surplus Property Disposal Authorization Form for each asset sold. The HCSN Accounting Manager did not give Woodbury consent to complete the authorization form in her place, nor did the HCSN Director give Woodbury consent to sign the authorization form in her place. Subsequent form approvers incorrectly assumed that Woodbury was permitted to sign the authorization form instead of the HCSN Director, which allowed him to sell unapproved surplus property on GovDeals, and personally collect the proceeds therefrom.

"Woodbury’s first unauthorized listing was a stainless-steel table. The table was listed on his unauthorized GovDeals account the same day the account was created on October 18, 2021. The table sold for $160, and the sale proceeds were directly deposited into his personal bank account on November 5, 2021. The sale was discovered by HCSN officials, as the table had not been classified as surplus property or approved for sale.

"Woodbury told HCSN officials the table was paid for in cash, but the sale proceeds were actually paid via direct deposit to his personal bank account. After being confronted with this information, Woodbury turned over cash for the sale of the table to the HCSN on October 29, 2021.

"After the first sale, Woodbury subsequently sold an additional 18 HCSN assets without the knowledge or approval of HCSN officials prior to his suspension. All sales proceeds were directly deposited into Woodbury’s personal bank account. When Woodbury listed the unapproved HCSN surplus property for sale on GovDeals, he undervalued the assets. Woodbury received a total of $2,304.33 for the sale of unauthorized HCSN surplus property; however, the surplus property was valued by HCSN officials at $12,374.68.

"Woodbury acknowledged he was responsible for properly remitting sales proceeds to Hamilton County Schools in a timely manner. Woodbury refrained from performing this duty and did not remit the funds back to Hamilton County Schools; instead, a portion of the misappropriation was found in his office in the form of cash contained in envelopes. The total amount of cash in the envelopes was $1,576.

"One envelope was labeled for the sale of a stainless-steel table and contained $160, but the cash for the sale of the table had already been remitted to HCSN. After Woodbury’s suspension, the envelopes of cash discovered in Woodbury’s office were properly remitted to Hamilton County Schools by HCSN officials.

"Woodbury did not tell anyone about the cash contained in the envelopes prior to being suspended and questioned by investigators. The table below summarizes by month and year the sales proceeds directly deposited into Woodbury's personal bank account, the fair market value of the HCSN assets sold, as well as the cash in sealed envelopes found in Woodbury’s desk.

"Woodbury knowingly exceeded the authority of his position for personal gain by selling his personal property on an unauthorized HCSN GovDeals account. On Woodbury’s unauthorized GovDeals account, 24 listings were identified as a combination of items he owned and items he had taken from Hamilton County dumpsters. The 24 listings sold for $1,219.11 in total. The items taken from the Hamilton County dumpsters were considered abandoned trash and free for anyone to take, and the disposed items collected became Woodbury’s property after he retrieved the items. Woodbury stated that he knew using the unauthorized HCSN GovDeals account to sell his personal property was wrong. Woodbury also confirmed that he never asked for or received permission, or authorization from HCSN officials to sell his personal property on GovDeals using the HCSN name."

The Comptroller found "an internal control and compliance deficiency, which resulted in Woodbury’s ability to misappropriate HCSN assets.

"The deficiency included:

"Hamilton County Schools officials did not provide adequate oversight or separate financial duties for the HCSN surplus property disposal process Hamilton County Schools officials did not provide adequate oversight or separate financial duties for the HCSN surplus property disposal process. Hamilton County Schools officials and Hamilton County School Board members should be aware of, and confirm, authorized signatories prior to giving their approval. If a document is signed by an unauthorized signatory, officials should make inquiries to verify authenticity and proper authorization before providing their approval via signature.

"Due to the lack of oversight by officials, the HCSN surplus property disposal process proceeded despite having an unauthorized signatory on the Surplus Property Disposal Authorization Form. Failure to provide proper oversight and segregate financial duties increases the risk that fraud, waste, or abuse will occur without prompt detection. Hamilton County Schools officials failed to reconcile the assets sold on GovDeals with the collection of sales proceeds from GovDeals. A Hamilton County Schools official not involved in the HCSN surplus property disposal approval process or sales process should obtain a monthly sales report for reconciliation, regardless of the third-party auction site used. Proper reconciliation of sale proceeds ensures that all sales were authorized and appropriate and that the funds collected are accurately accounted for, and timely deposited."

Breaking News
Latest Hamilton County Arrest Report
  • 5/26/2024

Here is the latest Hamilton County arrest report. (If your case is dismissed, just email us your name and date we ran it and we will promptly take off. Email to news@chattanoogan.com ) ALFORD, ... more

City To Advertise Walnut Street Bridge Renovation Project For Bids
  • 5/25/2024

The city on Sunday will place a legally-required public advertisement for bids for work on the Walnut Street Bridge renovation project. The advertisement marks the official beginning of the project, ... more

UTC’s Olivia Reeves Selected To U.S. Olympic Weightlifting Team
UTC’s Olivia Reeves Selected To U.S. Olympic Weightlifting Team
  • 5/25/2024

University of Tennessee at Chattanooga student Olivia Reeves has been announced as one of the five athletes representing USA Weightlifting during this summer’s Paris Olympic Games. The announcement ... more