Forensic Science Makes the Case

Wednesday, March 15, 2000

Laboratory tests on a set of white-tailed deer antlers were key evidence leading to the Federal conviction of a Portage, Wisconsin, man of illegally killing and transporting a trophy deer in interstate commerce, between Wisconsin and Michigan. Clyde H. Masten III, age 24, was sentenced today in Federal court for violating the Lacey Act. U.S. Magistrate Judge Stephen L. Crocker sentenced Masten to serve 30 days in jail with work release privileges and pay a $2,000 fine. He was placed on probation for five years and ordered to perform 1,000 hours of community service. As Conditions of probation, Masten may not hunt or fish, possess firearms or fishing equipment, purchase a hunting or fishing license, or accompany anyone hunting or fishing. The investigation was conducted by U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Special Agent Ed
Spoon and Conservation Wardens of the Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources. The
laboratory tests, used for the first time in a case of wildlife law, proved conclusively that the
deer was not killed in Michigan, as Masten had claimed. The investigation showed that the deer
was killed illegally, at night, near Portage, Wisconsin.

"This poacher would not have been brought to justice without the work of scientists Brian Beard
and Clark Johnson at the University of Wisconsin." said Spoon. "Dr. Beard analyzed the strontium isotope content of the deer's antlers to establish the geographic fingerprint of the area where the deer had lived. The fingerprint turned out to be identical with deer living in the Portage, Wisconsin area."

When Masten pled guilty to the charge, he admitted that he tagged the Wisconsin deer with a Michigan archery deer tag in an attempt to legitimize his actions. After poaching the deer in Wisconsin, he took it to Michigan, where he staged the "hunting" of the deer on videotape.

Agent Spoon enlisted the help of the Department of Geology and Geophysics and the Geology Museum at the University of Wisconsin to disprove Masten's claim that the deer was killed legally in Michigan. Comparing the fingerprint obtained from laboratory analysis with that of the area where the deer had lived, proved that the deer could not have come from Michigan.

"Strontium isotope fingerprinting was used during the Vietnam War and to determine migration histories of ancient humans in the southwestern United States." said Beard. "But with this case, we can now see the potential for its use in a wide variety of law enforcement investigations."

Masten has a long history of violating Wisconsin fish and wildlife laws. He has a string of 27 convictions in state court for violations beginning in 1993. At the time of this latest offense, Masten's hunting privileges in Wisconsin were revoked for three years.

The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service is the principal Federal agency responsible for conserving,
protecting and enhancing fish, wildlife and plants and their habitats for the continuing benefit of
the American people. The Services manages the 93-million-acre National Wildlife Refuge System of more than 520 national wildlife refuges, thousands of small wetlands and other special management areas. It also operates 66 national fish hatcheries, 64 Fishery Resource Offices and 78 ecological services field stations. The agency enforces Federal wildlife laws, administers the Endangered Species Act, manages migratory bird populations, restores nationally significant fisheries, conserves and restores wildlife habitat such as wetlands, and helps foreign governments
with their conservation efforts. It also oversees the Federal Aid program that distributes hundreds
of millions of dollars in excise taxes on fishing and hunting equipment to state fish and wildlife
agencies.


Chattanooga Tree Commission And Take Root Chattanooga To Hold Citizen Forester Classes

TFWC Meeting Set For Dyersburg

Public Invited To Submit Hunting Regulations Comments


The Chattanooga Tree Commission and Take Root Chattanooga will hold their annual Citizen Forester Classes over four Saturdays in February from 9 a.m. to noon at several locations around Hamilton ... (click for more)

The Tennessee Fish and Wildlife Commission will hold its first 2022 meeting Jan. 20-21 at the Lannom Center in Dyersburg. Thursday, the 20th meeting begins at 1 p.m. Friday, the 21st, begins ... (click for more)

The Tennessee Wildlife Resources Agency is welcoming comments for its 2022-24 hunting regulations. This is an opportunity for the public to share ideas, comments and make suggestions about hunting ... (click for more)



Outdoors

Chattanooga Tree Commission And Take Root Chattanooga To Hold Citizen Forester Classes

The Chattanooga Tree Commission and Take Root Chattanooga will hold their annual Citizen Forester Classes over four Saturdays in February from 9 a.m. to noon at several locations around Hamilton County. Two Beginner Classes will be offered on Saturday, Feb. 5, at the Ivy Academy (8520 Dayton Pike, Soddy Daisy) and Feb. 12 at the Hamilton County Ag Center (6183 Adamson Cir., Chattanooga). ... (click for more)

TFWC Meeting Set For Dyersburg

The Tennessee Fish and Wildlife Commission will hold its first 2022 meeting Jan. 20-21 at the Lannom Center in Dyersburg. Thursday, the 20th meeting begins at 1 p.m. Friday, the 21st, begins at 9 a.m. There will be a preview of the Tennessee Wildlife Resources Agency’s recommendations for the 2022-23 migratory game bird hunting seasons. Recommendations are for the statewide ... (click for more)

Breaking News

Hamilton County Has 14 More COVID Deaths, Including 13 That Were Not Previously Reported; 479 New Cases

The Hamilton County Health Department on Tuesday reported 479 new positive COVID-19 cases. The total number of cases in the county now stands at 80,480. There were 14 more deaths from the virus in Hamilton County reported on Tuesday, since the last update on Friday, for a total of 936. The Hamilton County Health Department said that 13 of the 14 individuals were added to Tuesday’s ... (click for more)

City Pays Developer Pratt $425,000 As Settlement For "Over-Reach" In Zoning Case; Restrictions To Remain On Quarry Property

The city of Chattanooga has agreed to pay developer James Pratt $425,000 as settlement of a federal lawsuit he brought after the City Council in 2018 voted 6-3 to squelch a development he planned at The Quarry on Read's Lake Road. Mr. Pratt agreed to drop his lawsuit and the restrictions that were approved by the council on the property remain in place. Also as part of the ... (click for more)

Opinion

Use Emission Testing Sites As Vaccination Site

Here's a no-brainer! Now that the emissions testing sites are closed... thank goodness... open these empty eyesore shells for something really useful like testing sites and vaccination bays. Genius. This would eliminate long lines everywhere. They are (somewhat) conveniently located and have several bays. At least these over-worked health care workers would be out of the elements, ... (click for more)

Thank You For Supporting The S. M. Robertson Police And Fire Christmas Fund

Dear Residents of Signal Mountain, On behalf of the 44 police and fire officers and their families of the town of Signal Mountain, we want to take this opportunity to thank you for your contribution to the 2021 S. M. Robertson Police & Fire Christmas Fund. The fund was started over 50 years ago and we continue to see the generosity of the citizens of our community. Even ... (click for more)