Hearing Expected Next Week On Peter Murphy Suit Contesting Election Commission Certification Of Yusuf Hakeem

  • Friday, March 22, 2013

A hearing is expected next week on the lawsuit filed by City Councilman Peter Murphy on Thursday afternoon contesting the Election Commission's certification of former Councilman Yusuf Hakeem as the winner in their close District 9 contest.

Chancellor Frank Brown said he did not have any time on his schedule on Friday, but he said he had given attorneys four different possible dates for next week.

The eight-page complaint was filed by Chattanooga attorney Neal Thompson. A Washington, D.C., attorney, Elizabeth Howard, of "of counsel" on the case.

It seeks a court ruling that a runoff election in District 9 be held on April 9.

Early voting has already started for a District 4 runoff on April 9 between Jack Benson and Larry Grohn in District 4.

The suit is filed against the Election Commission, commission members and Charlotte Mullis-Morgan, election administrator.

Other plaintiffs are District 9 residents Jessie Phillips, Lettie McIntire and Olin Ivey.

Mr. Hakeem got six more votes than the incumbent in the March 5 election. Mr. Hakeem got 49.8 percent of the vote when seven write-in ballots were counted. A majority on the Election Commission discounted two write-in votes that had no name on them, pushing Mr. Hakeem above the 50 percent mark.

The suit says that according to the certified results the write-in ballots were included and no candidate got a majority, thus requiring a runoff.

It asks for a writ of mandamus directing the Election Commission to hold a District 9 runoff on April 9.

Click here for the full complaint.

 

More to follow. . .

Breaking News
Man, 53, Found Dead In Whitfield County
  • 8/20/2025

A man was found dead in Whitfield County on Tuesday. The Whitfield County Coroner’s Office was dispatched around 8:15 p.m. to New Zion Hill Road in reference to a deceased man. He was identified ... more

Ooltewah Man Killed In Plane Crash In Arkansas Monday
Ooltewah Man Killed In Plane Crash In Arkansas Monday
  • 8/20/2025

Barry Boes, 54, of Ooltewah was killed in a plane crash in Lafayette County, Arkansas on Monday. A release from the Arkansas State Police said, "On Monday, August 18, 2025, at approximately ... more

Stolen Gun Recovered From East Hamilton High School Student
Stolen Gun Recovered From East Hamilton High School Student
  • 8/20/2025

An East Hamilton High School student was arrested on multiple charges on Wednesday. The school resource deputy assigned to East Hamilton High School investigated a suspicious vehicle ... more