Legislative Survey Is Biased

  • Saturday, February 6, 2016

Recently I received a survey from Gerald McCormick. I started to complete the survey but discovered that numbers 2 and 3 were so biased that any results are invalid. The voucher question (#2) is extremely biased with a very leading question, 3 "Yes" responses framed in positive language, and one "No" framed in negative language. 

McCormick is using faulty data and sweeping generalizations to support his pro-voucher position. I am disappointed that he is playing politics with our tax dollars. 

Vouchers will undoubtedly be as effective a "reform" as the virtual school and achievement school district debacles have been.  

Vouchers must be opposed because:
1. Vouchers violate the state Constitution.
2. Vouchers result in the loss of accountability for taxpayer dollars. 
3. Private schools will "cherry-pick" students, taking only the best further degrading low performing schools. 
4. They will also take the money for a student then kick them out at their discretion.
5. There can be no valid data regarding success of vouchers because students who go to private schools are not required to take state mandated tests. 

Legislators should support public education and not subvert it.  

Click here for the survey.

Gil Highlander 

Hixson
 


Opinion
Questionable Penalties
  • 6/30/2025

Today’s edition, side by side articles…. One person guilty of emptying a pistol into another man and then proceeds to beat him to death, already has 21 prior criminal convictions, gets 18 ... more

Two Laws Make It Clear
  • 6/30/2025

Action on the “Big, Beautiful Bill” in the Senate has the national attention right now, but two other recent bills in the House deserve equal attention. The first, by Rep. Austin Pfluger, R-TX, ... more

The 11 Worst New Laws In Tennessee In 2025
  • 6/30/2025

When the 2025 legislative session kicked off, Tennesseans had one clear demand: help working families build a better life. Voters asked for relief from inflation and rising costs. They asked ... more