State Supreme Court Denies Hearing On Death Row Inmate’s Claim Of Intellectual Disability

Thursday, April 7, 2016

The Tennessee Supreme Court has denied a request by a death row inmate to have a hearing to determine whether he is eligible to be executed because he is intellectually disabled, concluding that the procedural avenues he sought to use in this case do not entitle him to such a hearing.

Pervis Tyrone Payne was convicted by a Shelby County jury in 1988 of two counts of first degree murder and one count of assault with intent to commit first-degree murder. Payne was sentenced to death for each of the two murders. The convictions and sentences were upheld by the Tennessee Supreme Court and the United States Supreme Court in the early 1990s. Since then, Payne has pursued numerous secondary reviews of the case in the state and federal courts, all of which were unsuccessful.

In 2001, the Tennessee Supreme Court held that the federal and state constitutions prohibit the execution of individuals who are intellectually disabled. In this case, Payne asserted that he is entitled to a hearing to determine whether he meets the legal definition of intellectually disabled.

The Court determined that the many theories advanced by Payne do not create a right to a hearing on his claim of intellectual disability. One of the theories considered by the Court included Payne’s reliance on a recent United States Supreme Court decision from Florida, Hall v. Florida, regarding the use of IQ scores and other factors in determining intellectual disability. The Tennessee Supreme Court held that Hall did not apply retroactively and thus did not provide an avenue for the hearing that Payne was seeking in this case.

To read the unanimous opinion in Pervis Tyrone Payne v. State of Tennessee, authored by Justice Jeffrey S. Bivins, go to the opinions section of TNCourts.gov.


TVA Launches “In Charge: Life With An Electric Vehicle” Video Series

Telor Products Launches New Product, The Breezy Ryder Motorcycle Seat Cushion

New And Used Vehicle Sales Drop In July


Ride along with host Raven Hernandez, CEO of Earth Rides, as she tours the Tennessee Valley in the latest EVs—like Volkswagen’s all new VW ID.4, Chevy Bolt, Tesla Model Y Porsche Taycan, and ... (click for more)

Telor Products, LLC, a local manufacturer of concealed carry holsters and wheelchair seat cushions, has launched a new product, the Breezy Ryder motorcycle seat cushion. David Leverett, owner ... (click for more)

New vehicle sales in Hamilton County dropped in July with new vehicle sales at 1,321 and used vehicle sales dropped to 3,872, according to figures from the County Clerk's office. That compares ... (click for more)



Business

TVA Launches “In Charge: Life With An Electric Vehicle” Video Series

Ride along with host Raven Hernandez, CEO of Earth Rides, as she tours the Tennessee Valley in the latest EVs—like Volkswagen’s all new VW ID.4, Chevy Bolt, Tesla Model Y Porsche Taycan, and the Nissan Leaf. Joining her are guests including Trevor Bayne, the youngest winner of the Daytona 500, Nashville singer/songwriter and host of Apple Music’s “Today’s Country” Kelleigh Bannen, ... (click for more)

Telor Products Launches New Product, The Breezy Ryder Motorcycle Seat Cushion

Telor Products, LLC, a local manufacturer of concealed carry holsters and wheelchair seat cushions, has launched a new product, the Breezy Ryder motorcycle seat cushion. David Leverett, owner and designer for Telor Products in Ringgold, has over 25 years of medical seating design and development and was on the ISO and RESNA Standards committee for wheelchair seating for nine ... (click for more)

Breaking News

Man Charged In Pikeville Axe Murders Told Police He Can't Remember Grisly Killings, But "It Must Have Been Me"

A man charged with using an axe to hack a mother and her daughter to death told authorities he cannot remember any details of the grisly killings at Pikeville, but Robert Joe Whittenburg said he concluded "it had to be me." Whittenburg, 47, faces two counts of first-degree murder in the killing of 46-year-old Deanna Lawrence and her 24-year-old daughter (and his girlfriend) Dedra ... (click for more)

Red Bank Commissioners Vote On 1st Reading To Raise Taxes 11 Cents

Red Bank Commissioners voted unanimously on first reading on Tuesday night to raise the property tax by 11 cents. The new $1.10 per $100 of assessed valuation was 10 cents below what Interim City Manager John Alexander had recommended and had been supported by Mayor Hollie Berry and Vice Mayor Stefanie Dalton. Red Bank's tax rate previously was $1.39. However, under the certified ... (click for more)

Opinion

Meacham Hit On What Has Harmed America The Most

I was recently involuntarily sent a copy of the December 2019 House Intelligence Committee’s report on its investigation into Donald Trump and the Ukraine which I immediately prepared to put in the trash as being outdated in 2021. However, I noticed the six-page foreword had been written by McCallie School and Sewanee graduate Jon Meacham who also happens to be a Pulitzer Prize ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: ‘The Worst Ever’ In Louisiana

Not since the COVID pandemic first began 18 months ago have conditions been as grave as they are right now in Louisiana. Today a sweeping masking mandate will begin statewide for “everybody,” vaccinated or not, after the state’s hospitals on Tuesday set an all-time record for inpatients with 2,112, breaking the previous mark of 2,069 set in January. On Monday there were 11,109 confirmed ... (click for more)