Doggart Gets Almost 20 Years For Plot To Attack Islamic Community In New York

Wednesday, June 14, 2017

Robert Doggart was sentenced Wednesday to serve almost 20 years in federal prison for plotting to kill members of an Islamic community in New York.

Judge Curtis Collier set the sentence for the 66-year-old Sequatchie County man after a day-long hearing. He got 120 months on one count and 115 months on a second count.

His attorney, Leslie Cory, said Doggart never would have actually carried out the plot, but liked to shock people due to a personality disorder and mental issues. She said he i "by and large truly a wonderful person."

Prosecutor Perry Piper said Doggart may have lived an exemplary life for 64 years, "but when he went off the rails he went off hard."

The judge heard from the sister and daughter of Doggart as well as two work associates. All said he was non-violent and often helped others. His sister, Anita, said, "There is no possible way he would have followed through with this." She said he has "a tendency to embellish and exaggerate."

Daughter Terri Lee said he is "a giving man with a generous spirit" who held no animosity toward anyone."

She said, "He taught us to embrace those who were different from us."

Fellow TVA worker Ed Seay said Doggart told him that he met a black lady on a dating service and took her to his daughter's wedding shortly after he and his wife divorced.

The judge also heard from a representative of the small community of Islamburg at Hancock, N.Y. The courtroom was filled with Islamburg residents.

Attorney Cory said she believes that Doggart got in with a different crowd when he ran for Congress. She said he began talking about militia movements and believe there were terrorists at Islamburg.

She said he has a severe heart condition and bad shoulder. Prosecutor Piper said he should be able to get excellent medical treatment in prison.

Doggart has been held at the jail in DeKalb County, Ala.

Doggart got a 12-point enhancement to the sentence due to terroristic activities.

Attorney Cory noted that under the original plea agreement worked out with the government that he would have been in the sentencing range of 12 to 18 months or, at worst, 18-24 months. Judge Collier rejected that agreement.

Prosecutor Piper said the residents of Islamburg "were threatened, intimidated and horrified by his threats." He said members of the group had been at every court hearing, traveling all the way from the Catskill Mountains.

Doggart addressed the court, saying he is not a violent person and has no animus against any race or religion. He acknowledge that he committed "a serious error."

He said of Islam, "There has never been a time that I hated or been afraid of it."

Doggart said he was targeted by the government and said the jury acted too quickly.

He turned to the residents of Islamburg and said, "To the members of Islamberg, I am sorry. Please forgive me."

Judge Collier said Doggart was not a "monster," but said he did not feel comfortable trusting him if he did not trust the justice system. He said the jury took a longer time than usual in reaching verdicts.

The judge said, "You were guilty and charged with a crime against the United States of America. A strict sentence is appropriate for this situation."

He added, "The allocution that you gave. It gave me more concern about you than anything I've heard on tape."


Latest Hamilton County Arrest Report

Hamilton County Has 1 More COVID Death With 20 In Intensive Care; County Has 156 New Cases; State Has 2,677 More Cases

Georgia Has Another 6,480 New Coronavirus Cases, 21 More Deaths


Here is the latest Hamilton County arrest report: ADDISON, LINDSEY GRACE 1109 MCDONALD DR CHATTANOOGA, 37421 Age at Arrest: 34 years old Arresting Agency: Hamilton County VIOLATION ... (click for more)

Hamilton County had 156 new coronavirus cases reported on Tuesday, bringing the total to 47,711. There has been one more death from the virus, and the total is at 516 in the county. It is ... (click for more)

Georgia state health officials reported on Tuesday there have been 21 additional deaths due to the coronavirus. The current total is 18,750. There are 6,480 new cases, as that total reaches ... (click for more)



Breaking News

Latest Hamilton County Arrest Report

Here is the latest Hamilton County arrest report: ADDISON, LINDSEY GRACE 1109 MCDONALD DR CHATTANOOGA, 37421 Age at Arrest: 34 years old Arresting Agency: Hamilton County VIOLATION OF PROBATION (THEFT UNDER 1000) --- BIAGIOTTI, JOI SOONE 45 SKYLINE DR ELLIJAY, 30540 Age at Arrest: 30 years old Arresting Agency: Collegedale Police Booked for Previous Charges ... (click for more)

Hamilton County Has 1 More COVID Death With 20 In Intensive Care; County Has 156 New Cases; State Has 2,677 More Cases

Hamilton County had 156 new coronavirus cases reported on Tuesday, bringing the total to 47,711. There has been one more death from the virus, and the total is at 516 in the county. It is reported to be a white male, age 41-50. The number of those who have recovered from coronavirus in Hamilton County is 45,776, which is 96 percent, and there are 1,419 active cases. ... (click for more)

Opinion

Meacham Hit On What Has Harmed America The Most

I was recently involuntarily sent a copy of the December 2019 House Intelligence Committee’s report on its investigation into Donald Trump and the Ukraine which I immediately prepared to put in the trash as being outdated in 2021. However, I noticed the six-page foreword had been written by McCallie School and Sewanee graduate Jon Meacham who also happens to be a Pulitzer Prize ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: ‘The Worst Ever’ In Louisiana

Not since the COVID pandemic first began 18 months ago have conditions been as grave as they are right now in Louisiana. Today a sweeping masking mandate will begin statewide for “everybody,” vaccinated or not, after the state’s hospitals on Tuesday set an all-time record for inpatients with 2,112, breaking the previous mark of 2,069 set in January. On Monday there were 11,109 confirmed ... (click for more)

Sports

Dan Fleser: Dodgeball, Kickball Part Of Vol Football Team Building

The football conversation on Tuesday at Tennessee’s Neyland-Thompson Sports Center was almost exclusively about football. The fare was typical for a media-day setting and timely, considering preseason practice begins on Wednesday and the season opens Sept. 2 against Bowling Green. There wasn’t a second spent on recounting any games of dodge ball or kick ball that took ... (click for more)

Lookouts Snap Losing Streak With Timely Hitting

The Chattanooga Lookouts didn’t exactly knock down the walls at AT&T Field with their bats Tuesday night, but they did manage to get enough clutch hits to snap a two-game losing streak with a come-from-behind 5-1 victory over the Rocket City Trash Pandas. The Lookouts improve to 17-17 at home and 40-36 overall while Rocket City falls to 37-39 overall. More importantly, ... (click for more)