John Shearer: Researching Professor John Roy Baylor’s Time In Anniston, Al.

Friday, September 21, 2018 - by John Shearer

With Baylor School observing the 125th anniversary of its founding this year, I thought it might be fun to examine some aspect or aspects of the school’s history I have not really researched before.


One area that likely no one connected to Baylor has apparently focused on a whole lot is the life of founder John Roy Baylor before he came to Baylor.


Many patrons know he attended the University of Virginia, and that he focused on U.Va.’s and founder Thomas Jefferson’s philosophies of education. 


And it has also been told that five Chattanooga civic leaders – four of whom had young boys – were interested in finding someone to start a boys college preparatory school in Chattanooga in 1893.

They came across Professor Baylor’s name after he was recommended during some correspondence with University of Tennessee president D. Charles Dabney, who happened to be a good boyhood friend of Professor Baylor in Virginia.


It has also been documented that the school was first located – ironically -- in the former McCallie family home across present day Lindsay Street from what is now Memorial Auditorium.


Regarding his pre-Baylor days, former teacher Jim Hitt’s detailed 1971 history of Baylor, “It Never Rains After Three O’clock,” briefly mentions some of the places he worked before coming to Chattanooga.


And they were kind of an eclectic mix of schools. In the 1870s, he first served as an instructor and later principal at the Mountain Spring School in the North Alabama town of Trinity near Decatur.


From 1878 to 1888, he was an instructor at the Miller Manual Labor School for orphaned children in Albemarle County, Va., by Charlottesville. During that time, he married his wife, Julia L. Howard.


From 1888 to 1890, he was principal of an unnamed school for boys in Savannah, Ga., before going to the Noble Institute in Anniston, Ala., just below Gadsden.


Mr. Hitt does not give any detail about the Noble Institute, so I decided to see what I could find when I went down to Anniston several weeks ago with my wife, Laura, to see the family of her son, Robert Whitelaw.


As it turned out, I think I ended up going away with more questions than answers, but it was still enlightening.


I did my research at the Anniston Public Library located off the tree-lined Quintard Avenue, likely one of the prettier urban streets in Alabama. I went into the Alabama Room, and two or three staff people were quite helpful in giving me some folders on the history of the Noble Institute and showing me the old Anniston city directories from that time period.


Unfortunately, I could get no help from the available printed information on Professor Baylor’s role at the school. I did not see his name anywhere in the material, and while the library had several city directories from that time period, they had none from the years of 1890 to 1893 when he was in Anniston.


Adding to the mystery was the fact that I later realized there were two Noble Institutes in Anniston during that time period – one for girls that stayed open longer, and a lesser-known school for boys located in a different part of town.


The girls school had opened in 1886 at the corner of Leighton Avenue and 11th Street by the affiliated Grace Episcopal Church, which still has a large and handsome church facility on that block. The school was named for Samuel E. Noble, the president of the Anniston Pipe Works.


It was in operation until the 1920s. A nice-looking dorm building for girls was built by Mr. Noble’s family in the late 1800s after his death. After the school closed, it became an inn. It burned to the ground in 1965 in a memorable moment in Anniston’s history.


Since I could not find Professor Baylor’s name anywhere in the information on the Noble girls school – even in a list of principals or school heads – I deduced rightly or wrongly that he might have been connected with the boys school.


After all, he went to Anniston from a boys school in Savannah, and Baylor School was a boys school his first year there, although it was briefly coed after that.


In 1890 when he would have arrived in Anniston, the school was going through its period of greatest growth since its founding in 1887. Located in a pretty stone and brick building on Stringfellow Hill seven blocks north of the girls school on Leighton Avenue, it had 59 students in second through 12th grades when Professor Baylor apparently came.


Whether he served as headmaster is not known, although Mr. Hitt said that he took “charge” of the school after moving from Savannah.


He likely was or held some top administrative position, but much less printed information on that school was found than exists on the girls school. There was no list of school heads with the boys school, for example.


The Noble Institute for boys later became a public Boys High School in 1896 and was in operation until January 1910, when it, like the former Noble girls building, was destroyed by a fire.


Today, the modern Stringfellow Memorial Hospital sits on the small hilltop location, but one can easily imagine that it would have made a nice location for a boys school. Behind the hospital are the football stadium and other athletic fields used today by Anniston High. They were likely once part of the school grounds, too.


What helps one visualize that this might have been Professor Baylor’s stomping grounds in the early 1890s is a Victorian-style house a block south of the hospital. Now a medical office, it was likely built shortly before or slightly after Professor Baylor’s time there.


And Grace Episcopal Church, which has a style of Gothic stone architecture similar to the buildings at the University of the South at Sewanee, is a real eye catcher. Since it was built in 1885 with the help of the Noble family and others, it was likely worshiped in by Professor Baylor, who was an Episcopalian.           


Unfortunately, though, Professor Baylor’s name is apparently out of eyeshot to those seeking information on him in the fine collection of archives in the Anniston Public Library.


But in Chattanooga, where he came in 1893 and served until his death in 1926, his name is still found on the school he started.


* * * * *


(Note: In connection with Baylor’s 125th anniversary, this is the first of several stories over the fall related to its history).


* * * * *

McClung Museum Director To Retire

4 Tennessee Sites Added To National Register Of Historic Places

Wayne Shearer’s Word War II Memoir, Part 2: Six Months After Dec. 7, 1941, Attack, Wanting To Be A Pilot – And Having Fun Before College!

Jeff Chapman, director of UT’s McClung Museum of Natural History and Culture, will retire at the end of the 2019 spring semester after 29 years as the museum’s director. Under Mr. Chapman’s ... (click for more)

The Tennessee Historical Commission today announced the addition of four properties to the National Register of Historic Places. They include a 20th century school, a 19th century church and ... (click for more)

(Editor’s Note: Dr. Wayne Shearer, 94, is a retired optometrist and retired colonel from the U.S. Air Force Reserve now living in Hixson. In his early 90s, he decided to sit down and write from ... (click for more)


McClung Museum Director To Retire

Jeff Chapman, director of UT’s McClung Museum of Natural History and Culture, will retire at the end of the 2019 spring semester after 29 years as the museum’s director. Under Mr. Chapman’s leadership, the McClung Museum has established itself as central to research, teaching and interdisciplinary programming at UT, officials said. The only museum on the university’s campus, ... (click for more)

4 Tennessee Sites Added To National Register Of Historic Places

The Tennessee Historical Commission today announced the addition of four properties to the National Register of Historic Places. They include a 20th century school, a 19th century church and two houses associated with country music. “Tennessee’s unique heritage is exemplified by these recent National Register nominations. Ranging from a historic rural school to two Davidson county ... (click for more)

Breaking News

Heavy Rains Continue For Chattanooga, While It's Not Cold Enough For Snow

Heavy rains continued in Chattanooga on Sunday, but temperatures did not drop low enough for the heavy snow that areas to the north and east received. The rain was bringing some minor flooding, especially in the Trenton and New England, Ga., areas and along Lookout Creek. South Chickamauga Creek was also rising, and was expected to exceed flood stage by late Sunday afternoon. ... (click for more)

County Schools Won't Give Information On Ooltewah High Rape Settlement, Attorney Charges

Hamilton County School officials say they won't give any information about the amount of money paid out to settle two lawsuits brought in Federal Court by students who were injured in the Ooltewah High rape incident. They also said they would not release the amount the county schools had to pay in legal expenses for defending the cases. filed an Open Records ... (click for more)


Eminent Domain And Property Taxes

There is understandable anger and resistance to TVA's sudden land grabbing in Meigs County. Surely the various governments in this area already own enough land to meet all their needs for a long time to come, and surely some of that land would be perfectly satisfactory for TVA's proposed new power center. But, as with the local animal welfare groups and their inability or unwillingness ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: Quit Embarrassing Us

Ever since I got word that a new Publix grocery store will be built on South Broad Street I have been excited. And every time our city Zoning Appeals Board seemingly does everything within its power to kill the project it is increasingly an embarrassment, a kerfuffle that has no logical explanation and sadly kowtows to a small minority that is flat-out wrong. On Wednesday the ... (click for more)