Resident Of Wilder Street Suing City Because She Is Not Allowed To Operate Airbnb

Wednesday, October 9, 2019

A homeowner who says the city’s Airbnb ordinance is unconstitutional is challenging her prosecution to city court in a filing with City Court Judge Sherry Paty.

 

Mary Alice Crapo, 65, of 2512 N. Wilder St., filed the complaint.

 

Mrs.

Crapo says her council member, Russell Gilbert, and others have deprived thousands of homeowners like her for two years of their right “to earn at least a partial living by participating in the Gig City economy via the Internet.”

 

She said, “The STVR ordinance infringes on my rights of liberty and my property rights. If I am not free to use my property like everybody inside the overlay map, my rights have been infringed upon. I can no longer invite vacationers with the Internet to Chattanooga use my home, but others in Chattanooga are allowed to do so.  We live in the same city, but the City of Chattanooga has created two groups by drawing a line on a map. This is what makes this law vulnerable to being overturned. That is totally illegal and unconstitutional. 

 

In a brief citing Supreme Court cases and the Constitution, Mrs. Crapo said the law in favor of a free market in rental housing is longstanding.

 

“There are many cases to cite to prove that the overlay map violates all kinds of statutes. For example, Crass v. Tennessee Valley Authority, “The equal protection right is violated by selective enforcement only when the selection is based on ‘arbitrary classification.’ If we find the overlay map is an arbitrary classification, that makes it invalid.”

 

Mrs. Crapo cited an early 19th century case, Vanzant v. Waddell, 1829. “The right to life, liberty and property, of every individual, must stand or fall by the same rule or law that governs every other member of the body… under similar circumstances.”  

 

She said, "The political jockeying that created the map reflects political pressures on council members to have their districts inside — or outside — the 'map of permission.' The fluctuating opinions of each councilman formed the overlay map. So there is no special classification for an individual be chosen to live ‘inside the line on the overlay map.’ This means the selection is arbitrary and unconstitutional.”

 

“The first thing I told all the councilmen when I learned about the new ordinance,” Mrs. Crapo said, “‘This is the Jim Crow laws of 2019.’ I just became ‘black,’ one of the deprived ones, because I was outside of the overlay map.

 

“Rosa Parks in 1955 refused to get out of her seat on the bus for some white man because of the Jim Crow laws and the 14th Amendment came to Park’s rescue.  I will be citing a lot of cases that used the 14th Amendment as well to ensure this law is overturned.”

 

The City Council has set up certain areas where short-term vacation rentals are allowed. They are not allowed elsewhere.

 

 


Hixson Man Drowns After Canoe Capsizes On Tennessee River Near Scottsboro

Latest Hamilton County Arrest Report

Fire Department Helps Family Stranded On Williams Island


A Hixson man died near Scottsboro, Ala., when his canoe capsized on Friday evening. He was identified as Gregory Lawson, 51. A woman who was with him swam to shore. Authorities are investigating ... (click for more)

Here is the latest Hamilton County arrest report: ADAMS, AUSTIN TYLER 711 BELVISTA AVE CHATTANOOGA, 37411 Age at Arrest: 33 years old Arresting Agency: Chattanooga CRIMINAL TRESPASSING ... (click for more)

The Chattanooga Fire Department came to the aid of a family stranded on Williams Island on a rainy Saturday. The parents and two children had planned to camp on the island near Baylor School. ... (click for more)


Breaking News

Hixson Man Drowns After Canoe Capsizes On Tennessee River Near Scottsboro

A Hixson man died near Scottsboro, Ala., when his canoe capsized on Friday evening. He was identified as Gregory Lawson, 51. A woman who was with him swam to shore. Authorities are investigating the incident. (click for more)

Latest Hamilton County Arrest Report

Here is the latest Hamilton County arrest report: ADAMS, AUSTIN TYLER 711 BELVISTA AVE CHATTANOOGA, 37411 Age at Arrest: 33 years old Arresting Agency: Chattanooga CRIMINAL TRESPASSING CRIMINAL IMPERSONATION DISORDERLY CONDUCT --- BAKER, LAKISHA RENEE 2409 EAST 13TH STREET CHATTANOOGA, 37404 Age at Arrest: 41 years old Arresting Agency: Chattanooga FINANCIAL ... (click for more)

Opinion

From One Mayor To Another: Walden Town Council Is Finally Fulfilling Its Vision

Dear Walden Board Members, As a former Town of Walden mayor and police commissioner, I have quietly watched as the new Town Center proposal has unfolded over the past several months. I have felt your pain as you carefully weighed all the pros and cons of such an important endeavor. I have understood, all too well the pressure each of you have been under to make the right decision, ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: It’s How Well We Mend

It’s not exactly something you want your banker or your mother to know, but in June a very smart and quite perceptive medical doctor spent almost two hours talking to me and told me some important things I’ve never heard before. He told me that I was a whole lot sicker than I thought I was. As a matter of fact, he also told me that it was his notion I had somewhere between 12 and ... (click for more)

Sports

John Gilpin, Jennifer Huwe Repeat As Pie Run Winners

It was almost like a couple’s day at the annual Signal Mountain Pie Run Saturday morning. John Gilpin was the men’s overall winner for the third straight year while his girlfriend Haley Moody was second among the ladies. Jennifer Huwe was also a repeat winner as she won the women’s division while her husband Kevin was second overall behind Gilpin. The weather was ideal ... (click for more)

Mocs Volleyball Falls On The Road At Woffard

Despite playing extremely short-handed due to injuries, the Chattanooga Mocs volleyball team put together a gutsy effort in a tough 3-2 (25-21,15-25, 25-27, 25-18, 15-9) loss on the road at Wofford on Friday night inside Jerry Richardson Indoor Stadium in Spartanburg, S.C. Chattanooga falls to 5-15 overall and 0-7 in SoCon play following the loss. Wofford improves to 11-11, ... (click for more)