Resident Of Wilder Street Suing City Because She Is Not Allowed To Operate Airbnb

Wednesday, October 9, 2019

A homeowner who says the city’s Airbnb ordinance is unconstitutional is challenging her prosecution to city court in a filing with City Court Judge Sherry Paty.

 

Mary Alice Crapo, 65, of 2512 N. Wilder St., filed the complaint.

 

Mrs.

Crapo says her council member, Russell Gilbert, and others have deprived thousands of homeowners like her for two years of their right “to earn at least a partial living by participating in the Gig City economy via the Internet.”

 

She said, “The STVR ordinance infringes on my rights of liberty and my property rights. If I am not free to use my property like everybody inside the overlay map, my rights have been infringed upon. I can no longer invite vacationers with the Internet to Chattanooga use my home, but others in Chattanooga are allowed to do so.  We live in the same city, but the City of Chattanooga has created two groups by drawing a line on a map. This is what makes this law vulnerable to being overturned. That is totally illegal and unconstitutional. 

 

In a brief citing Supreme Court cases and the Constitution, Mrs. Crapo said the law in favor of a free market in rental housing is longstanding.

 

“There are many cases to cite to prove that the overlay map violates all kinds of statutes. For example, Crass v. Tennessee Valley Authority, “The equal protection right is violated by selective enforcement only when the selection is based on ‘arbitrary classification.’ If we find the overlay map is an arbitrary classification, that makes it invalid.”

 

Mrs. Crapo cited an early 19th century case, Vanzant v. Waddell, 1829. “The right to life, liberty and property, of every individual, must stand or fall by the same rule or law that governs every other member of the body… under similar circumstances.”  

 

She said, "The political jockeying that created the map reflects political pressures on council members to have their districts inside — or outside — the 'map of permission.' The fluctuating opinions of each councilman formed the overlay map. So there is no special classification for an individual be chosen to live ‘inside the line on the overlay map.’ This means the selection is arbitrary and unconstitutional.”

 

“The first thing I told all the councilmen when I learned about the new ordinance,” Mrs. Crapo said, “‘This is the Jim Crow laws of 2019.’ I just became ‘black,’ one of the deprived ones, because I was outside of the overlay map.

 

“Rosa Parks in 1955 refused to get out of her seat on the bus for some white man because of the Jim Crow laws and the 14th Amendment came to Park’s rescue.  I will be citing a lot of cases that used the 14th Amendment as well to ensure this law is overturned.”

 

The City Council has set up certain areas where short-term vacation rentals are allowed. They are not allowed elsewhere.

 

 


Jerry Seinfeld Comes To The Tivoli May 28

Man Who Whipped Child Before Is Again Charged With Child Abuse

Rodney Dion Lough, 45, Arrested In Bradley County For Theft Of Travel Trailer


Jerry Seinfeld will perform at the Tivoli Theatre on Thursday, May 28, at 7 p.m. Doors will open at 6 p.m. Tickets are $160 and $85 and are available at Ticketmaster.com and the Tivoli Theatre ... (click for more)

A Chattanooga man is facing child abuse charges after police said he beat his child despite being forbidden by the courts to do so. In November, police were dispatched to investigate a ... (click for more)

Detectives from the Bradley County Sheriff’s Office Property Crimes Division have recovered a stolen 25-foot travel trailer and arrested Rodney Dion Lough, 45, for its theft. Lough has been ... (click for more)




Breaking News

Jerry Seinfeld Comes To The Tivoli May 28

Jerry Seinfeld will perform at the Tivoli Theatre on Thursday, May 28, at 7 p.m. Doors will open at 6 p.m. Tickets are $160 and $85 and are available at Ticketmaster.com and the Tivoli Theatre Box Office. Review for Jerry Seinfeld: Actor and comedian Jerry Seinfeld made his stand-up debut at an open mic night in 1976 and appeared on The Tonight Show in 1981. After starring ... (click for more)

Man Who Whipped Child Before Is Again Charged With Child Abuse

A Chattanooga man is facing child abuse charges after police said he beat his child despite being forbidden by the courts to do so. In November, police were dispatched to investigate a possible child abuse case. The mother said that her daughter had marks on her body due to a punishment from Malichi Moore, 27. The mother showed marks on the child’s leg where a there ... (click for more)

Opinion

Good Urban Design

Chattanooga is enjoying a robust movement to plan developments in a number of downtown neighborhoods, and there is good reason to believe that well designed development should be welcomed. The opposite is also true, that bad or poorly designed development should not be welcomed, especially if it seriously degrades the existing neighborhood. In the case of a sought after rezoning ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: AG Barr: What Has Happened To Us?

About 48 hours ago, William Barr, the Attorney General of the United States, delivered the keynote address at the 2020 National Religious Broadcasters Convention in Nashville at the Opryland complex. As many of you know, Barr has been the subject of heavy barrage in Washington and from The White House. In the last two weeks, over 2,000 Department of Justice types have, in a written ... (click for more)

Sports

Lady Vols Prevail Over Ole Miss, 77-66, On Senior Night

The Lady Vols prevailed over an upset-minded Ole Miss team on Thursday, taking a 77-66 win on Senior Night at Thompson-Boling Arena. Junior Rennia Davis was Tennessee's (19-9, 9-6 SEC) high scorer, recording her 28th career double-double with 19 points and 11 rebounds. Freshman Tamari Key and sophomore Rae Burrell were also in double figures, with Key scoring a career high ... (click for more)

CFC Signs Midfielder Carr And Defender Reynolds

Chattanooga Football Club is thrilled to announce the signing of midfielder Kyle Carr and defender Sean Reynolds for the historic 2020 campaign with NISA. Kyle comes to the Scenic City from USL One franchise Lansing Ignite, where he was viewed as a lynchpin at the base of the midfield and a steadfast, consistent player. “I’m very excited to play in Chattanooga for Chattanooga ... (click for more)