East Ridge Detective Says He Was Unaware Of Woman Who Became Star State Witness In Murder Case

  • Wednesday, February 13, 2019
Jason Sanford
Jason Sanford

The East Ridge detective who for years looked into a 2000 murder in which a woman was strangled and put in a garbage can said he never heard from a woman who is now a star witness for the prosecution.

J.C. Johnson, who retired last year, said when asked about Mary Ruth Boyd, "That name does not sound familiar."

Ms. Boyd testified Tuesday in the first-degree murder trial of Jason Sanford that she contacted East Ridge Police twice with her information and never heard back.

Detective Johnson also said years ago he felt he had enough proof to convict Sanford, but he said the district attorney at the time declined to prosecute.

Sanford, who had returned to his home state of Michigan shortly after the body of his girlfriend was found stuffed in a trash can in Spring Creek in mid-June 2000, is standing trial in the courtroom of Judge Tom Greenholtz.

The Cold Case Unit formed by District Attorney Neal Pinkston revived the case in 2016 and soon made the arrest of Sanford in the strangulation death of 21-year-old Sarah Davis Perry. DA Pinkston is one of the prosecutors at the trial.

Mary Ruth Boyd told the jury that she was cleaning out her car when an older model white truck drove by very slowly. She said at first she thought it was her brother because he had a similar truck.

She said there was a garbage can in the back of the truck with the lid partly off.

Ms. Boyd said she got a good look at the driver because she said he stared at her as he passed and went on to a dead end, then again as he drove back by slowly. 

She said, "Something didn't seem right."

The witness said after the truck passed she proceeded on to the grocery store and spotted the truck again. She said it was pulled off the side of the road where a bridge crosses Spring Creek. She said the garbage can was no longer in the truck, but she could see marks where it had been dragged under the bridge.

Ms. Boyd said when she heard there had been a murder in East Ridge she called East Ridge Police "and told them what I had seen. But no one ever contacted me." She said she was haunted by the incident and felt guilty not telling what she knew, so she called East Ridge Police again in 2004. She said once again no one called or came to interview her.

She said at the time "I wanted to know if they had ever caught the man."

Ms. Boyd said it was only within the past few months that someone contacted her about the case -investigator Kay Baker. She told her the story and was shown a photo of Sanford. She said she told the investigator, "You've got your man."

In the courtroom, Ms. Boyd said she could make a positive identification of Sanford as the man at the creek with the garbage can. She said, "It's the gentleman sitting right there."

She said, "I'm upset that he got by with it for 18 years. What did the kids get? What did the mother get?" Ms. Perry had children ages one and four.

Detective Johnson said marks were found in the creek that matched that of a two-wheeled garbage can being wheeled under the bridge. He said there was also a spot that had foot prints. He said a cast of the prints was made and sent to the FBI, but did not yield any usable information.

He said when he and another East Ridge officer went to Michigan to interview Sanford "he did not admit to any involvement, but he didn't adamantly deny it either."

Questioned by defense attorney Johnny Houston, he said the victim had earlier lived in Georgia with Sanford and his cousin. He said it may have been correct that the cousin disliked Ms. Perry because he wound up getting charged with drugs in Georgia.

It was also testified that Ms. Perry was at Valley Psychiatric Hospital until just a few days before her death. She left the facility over the advice of staff, the records showed. 

Prosecutor Crystle Carrion told the jury that a cousin of Sanford had given a statement that around the time of the murder that Sanford asked him for money and told him, "I've killed Sarah and I need to get out of town."

She said Sanford got on a Greyhound bus and left to return to Michigan on a Greyhound bus the night after he allegedly killed her.

Defense attorney Amanda Dunn said the cousin, who has since died, gave four different versions and they were all different. 

She said Sanford returned to Michigan, but detectives had no trouble finding him when he was interviewed in the wake of the murder and then by the Cold Case Unit.

Attorney Dunn also said there had been multiple suspects, not just Sanford.

The jury was told that Ms. Perry had some mental health and drug use issues.

Peggy Ferguson, who lived next door to Ms. Perry at the time, said she often heard the couple arguing.

She said on a night around the time of the murder she saw Sanford outside the house pacing back and forth nervously. 

Dusty Fine said the garbage can came from his family's nearby auto body shop. He said he worked late on a personal vehicle and forgot to bring the can in. He said it was gone the next morning. 

Justin Weathers said he was 12 at the time and was hunting crawdads, fishing and riding bikes at "The Whoops" with a friend when they found the body in the trash can. He said it was the friend who went up to the garbage can under the bridge at Springvale Road.

He said when the friend lifted the lid and saw the body of a woman who was naked from the waist up "he immediately started to holler. We took off running. Then I made him go back and get my bike." He said they raced back to the friend's grandmother's house and she called police.

Sarah Perry Davis
Sarah Perry Davis
Breaking News
Latest Hamilton County Arrest Report
  • 3/28/2024

Here is the latest Hamilton County arrest report: ADERHOLT, FELICIA DAWN 1110 ST CLAIR ST DUNLAP, 37327 Age at Arrest: 37 years old Arresting Agency: HC Sheriff Booked for Previous ... more

Signal Mountain Must Determine How To Use Remainder Of ARPA Funds
  • 3/27/2024

The town of Signal Mountain has $358,637 remaining from the American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) funds it received and there must be a plan in place by the end of the year for how the money will be ... more

Chattanooga Man Gets 21-Year Sentence For Fentanyl Death Of 19-Year-Old
Chattanooga Man Gets 21-Year Sentence For Fentanyl Death Of 19-Year-Old
  • 3/27/2024

A 25-year-old Chattanooga man, was sentenced to 21 years in federal prison for supplying drugs that led to the death of 19-year-old Charlotte Gallant. Jonathan Bash appeared before Judge Curtis ... more