Experts Disagree On Use Of Blood Alcohol Level Against Former EMT Whaley Charged In Wrong-Way Traffic Death

Monday, August 17, 2020 - by Joseph Dycus
Professor Kenneth Ferslew using whiteboard
Professor Kenneth Ferslew using whiteboard
- photo by Joseph Dycus

Two toxicology experts in Judge Barry Steelman’s courtroom expanded on the topic of retrograde extrapolation during Justin Whaley’s motion hearing on Monday. Whaley is facing vehicular homicide charges after his vehicle crashed into another car and claimed the lief of James Brumlow in 2018. Whaley was allegedly intoxicated during the incident; however, a blood draw was not taken until four hours after the crash.

The former EMT was arrested after the wrong-way crash on Highway 111 on July 3, 2018.

Because of this, the state had to extrapolate based upon the results, which led them to charge him with driving under the influence. Defense attorney Lee Davis has asked for the results of the blood draw to be suppressed, saying that level of extrapolation is unreliable and should not be admitted as proof. Prosecutor Christ Post brought in ETSU professor Kenneth Ferslew of the William L. Jenkins Forensic Center to discuss why the blood draw results should be admitted.

“If we believe the story, he was drinking from 9 p.m. to midnight or 1 a.m. in the morning, according to the evidence you’ve provided to me,” Professor Ferslew said. “So then he went to bed, then woke up and drove to the event. So the event is at  5:40 in the morning. I’ve got four additional hours in there after the drinking event. We’re in elimination by all studies I’ve ever seen, since we’re way past where maximum absorption has occurred.”

The witness said that the body begins breaking down and processing alcohol from the moment it enters the body, but that as a person drinks, the amount of alcohol being broken down is outpaced by the amount coming in. When people drink more, then that’s when their blood alcohol content goes up. But after alcohol is no longer consumed, then the blood alcohol level goes down in a linear fashion. The professor used a whiteboard and markers to illustrate his point.

However, after a certain level, the decline in alcohol is no longer linear. For the TBI, that level is 0.02 gram percent concentration. Professor Ferslew told Judge Steelman that if the police had waited even 15 minutes longer, then the results would have been unusable. As it stands, the results of the draw were right on the border of what is admissible.

“They are 99.73 percent confident by statistical analysis that blood has a 0.02 gram percent concentration in it,” the expert witness said. “The variation, or measurement uncertainty, is in the third decimal at 0.002, so if you want to take the uncertainty and calculate it in, that means 99.7 percent of 100 measurements go from a range of .0198 to .022. That’s why they report to that low number and now lower.”

By operating under the assumption that the level was at 0.02 percent at the time of the draw, the TBI used retrograde extrapolation to figure out that Whaley was intoxicated when the crash occurred.

“Your previous testimony was had the police taken this blood sample taken 15 minutes later, in your opinion this would have been reported as a negative,” attorney Davis said. “So we’re right on the very line of what is reportable.”

Attorney Davis then brought on his own toxicology expert, who disagreed with the prosecution’s decision to use the blood draw as evidence. Jimmie Valentine believes that once a person’s BAC levels were that low, then one could not draw results from it once information was extrapolated.

“What he’s talking about is when you get into this non-linear portion, if you’re at 0.02, you’re alright,” Mr. Valentine said. “I don’t agree with that. I think that when you get into these really low BAC levels, you’re in the non-linear portion of the curve. So what happens when you try to to any retroactive extrapolation, it’s just a wild guess at that point. You’ve either overestimated or you’ve underestimated, and you just don’t know.”

The defense also had issues with the state not knowing the precise amount of alcohol Whaley consumed that night. Witness testimony said the defendant had consumed six glasses of various kinds of bourbon. However, those glasses were anywhere from one to three ounces.

Mr. Valentine told the court that just having one sample taken at such a murky time was not “scientific.” He said that in other states, two or even three samples are taken over the course of several hours.

“If we give the benefit of the doubt, he’s below 0.02, so that puts us right in this non-linear portion of the curve,” Mr. Valentine said. “Using this retrograde extrapolation is just not very scientific at this juncture. It’s best used when you have multiple samples from different times, so you can be sure.”

The two experts argued with one another over this idea, but in the end the judge decided he would need time to review what was said before coming to a decision.

“It was very helpful testimony today from both sides, and it was very educational to the court,” Judge Steelman said. “It was a privilege, really, to hear such learned individuals in this field. We’ll try to decipher it and make a decision about what the jury will hear on Sept. 21.”

 

 


Latest Hamilton County Arrest Report

Nonstop United Service To Houston Begins, Daily Chicago Flights Resume In Chattanooga On Thursday

Grand Jury No Bills And True Bills


Here is the latest Hamilton County arrest report: ANDERSON, VINCENT CATRON 3304 PIONEER LANE CHATTANOOGA, 37419 Age at Arrest: 32 years old Arresting Agency: Hamilton County DRIVING ... (click for more)

On Thursday, The Chattanooga Airport will mark the beginning of nonstop United Express service, operated by SkyWest Airlines, to Houston and the return of daily United flights to Chicago. These ... (click for more)

Here are the No Bills and True Bills from the Hamilton County Grand Jury: No Bills: 1 DICKSON, DAVID JEREMY THEFT OF PROPERTY OVER $10,000 09/23/2020 2 DICKSON, DAVID JEREMY EVADING ... (click for more)



Breaking News

Latest Hamilton County Arrest Report

Here is the latest Hamilton County arrest report: ANDERSON, VINCENT CATRON 3304 PIONEER LANE CHATTANOOGA, 37419 Age at Arrest: 32 years old Arresting Agency: Hamilton County DRIVING ON REVOKED, SUSPENDED OR CANCELLED LICENSE --- BLOCKER, ANTHONY LAMICHEAL 3720 FOUNTAIN AVE CHATTANOOGA, 37412 Age at Arrest: 40 years old Arresting Agency: Hamilton County FAILURE ... (click for more)

Nonstop United Service To Houston Begins, Daily Chicago Flights Resume In Chattanooga On Thursday

On Thursday, The Chattanooga Airport will mark the beginning of nonstop United Express service, operated by SkyWest Airlines, to Houston and the return of daily United flights to Chicago. These flights mark a significant milestone in the resurgence of travel to and from the Chattanooga Airport. "This is an encouraging step forward as the air travel industry gradually recovers," ... (click for more)

Opinion

Selma Paty's Legacy

Much has been said of the accolades of Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg and rightfully so. I wanted to remind everyone that Chattanooga had its own lady attorney who made many in-roads for females in the legal field. Selma (Sunny) Paty actually began her legal career before Justice Ginsburg. She likewise was Jewish and being a female in the 1950's, when she started her practice, was ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: My October Garden

Well, in my monthly walk through my garden I broke the sad news to my annuals and biennials that Monday would be our last weather with temperatures in the 80s, and that Father front would soon come knocking. My perennials were saddened, of course, because we’ve had a happy year. So, as my man Cleo dished out a round of Miracle-Gro and Osmocote to those that wanted a nudge before ... (click for more)

Sports

Reds’ Stephenson Returns Home To Face Childhood Favorites In MLB Playoffs

The last time Tyler Stephenson attended an Atlanta Braves game, he was a high school prospect with dreams of one day making it to the major leagues. Like most aspiring baseball players who grew up in Atlanta over the past two decades, Stephenson wanted to become the next Chipper Jones. Living in the suburb of Kennesaw, Stephenson studied the Hall of Famer’s every move during ... (click for more)

Dalton State's Trevor Bassett Medals At Innisbrook

PALM HARBOR, Fla. – True freshman Trevor Bassett (215, +2) stole the show, methodically working his way around the difficult Copperhead Course to win Individual Medalist in the Invite at Innisbrook at Innisbrook Golf Club in Palm Harbor, Fla. on Tuesday. As a team, the Roadrunners dropped into a tie for 5 th after shooting 311 (+27). Wayland Baptist (Texas) (878, +26) took ... (click for more)