Jerry Summers: The Killing Of Sheriff Cate And Deputy Conway By The Taylor Brothers

Tuesday, September 22, 2020 - by Jerry Summers
Jerry Summers
Jerry Summers

In 1882 Sheriff William T. Cate had been elected to replace Sheriff Hiram "Jack" Springfield in Hamilton County.  Before being elected to the high office, Cate had served as the local mail agent and magistrate.  He was well-liked and respected throughout the county and easily won the race against his opponent, James E. Conner. 

During the prior administration of Sheriff Springfield, a ship carpenter, John Taylor, had killed a steamboat captain.  He was convicted of voluntary manslaughter and sentenced to 10 years imprisonment in the State penitentiary.  He won an appeal and the case was sent back to Chattanooga for re-trial.

Deputy John J. Conway, 30, was assisting Sheriff Cate in transporting three prisoners and Taylor to Knoxville, Tennessee aboard the Southern Railway System.  The lawmen sat in seats opposite their handcuffed prisoners in the passenger car.  Two men had boarded the train in Sweetwater, Tennessee and sat directly behind Deputy Conway. 

When the train reached Philadelphia, Sheriff Cate foolishly walked out on the platform to see if some of his relatives had come to visit him, leaving Conway alone with the prisoners and the two strangers at his back.

Bob Taylor, brother of John, shot Conway in the back of the head killing him instantly.  The shooter of Deputy Conway took the keys from the dead deputy’s pocket and unlocked his brother and the two other prisoners.  When Sheriff Cate heard the gunfire he rushed back into the car and the third Taylor brother, Andy, shot him without warning.

The two Taylor brothers approached the injured lawman lying on the floor of the train and shot him three more times.  As Cate lay dying the killers ordered the conductor to “pull the bell” in order that they could get off at the Lenoir City, Tennessee depot.  They then went into the engine car and ordered the motorman operating the train to get it moving.

The train went through three towns without stopping before the four suspects jumped from the train in Lenoir City and fled towards their home in Kingston.  Andy, the shooter, was later re-captured and finally executed on November 23, 1883.  John Taylor, who had been wounded by Sheriff Cate before he died, would later die from the injury. 

Sheriff Cate had only been in office 14 days when he was killed on September 14, 1882.

* * *

Jerry Summers

(If you have additional information about one of Mr. Summers' articles or have suggestions or ideas about a future Chattanooga area historical piece, please contact Mr. Summers at jsummers@summersfirm.com)

Murder of Sheriff Cate
Murder of Sheriff Cate

Entry Forms Available For Mainstreet Cleveland Christmas Parade Set For Dec. 5

Emergency Road Closure At S. Seminole Drive

Chattanooga Democratic Socialists, Concerned Citizens For Justice To Hold Brake Light Repair Clinic


Entries are now being accepted for the MainStreet Cleveland annual Christmas parade set for Saturday, Dec. 5 beginning at 6 p.m. "The annual Christmas parade is one of Cleveland’s longest running ... (click for more)

The Chattanooga Department of Transportation announces S. Seminole Drive will be closed between Crestview Circle and Rosemont Drive beginning Friday through Tuesday from 8:30 a.m.-3 p.m. for ... (click for more)

Volunteers from the Chattanooga chapter of Democratic Socialists of America (DSA) and Concerned Citizens for Justice (CCJ) will host a brake light repair clinic on Sunday from 11 a.m. to 3 p.m. ... (click for more)



Happenings

Entry Forms Available For Mainstreet Cleveland Christmas Parade Set For Dec. 5

Entries are now being accepted for the MainStreet Cleveland annual Christmas parade set for Saturday, Dec. 5 beginning at 6 p.m. "The annual Christmas parade is one of Cleveland’s longest running and most anticipated holiday traditions with many beautiful floats and thousands of twinkling lights," officials said. “Mainstreet Cleveland is happy to announce that the Christmas ... (click for more)

Emergency Road Closure At S. Seminole Drive

The Chattanooga Department of Transportation announces S. Seminole Drive will be closed between Crestview Circle and Rosemont Drive beginning Friday through Tuesday from 8:30 a.m.-3 p.m. for an emergency sewer repair. Detours will be posted. View CDOT's map of event and road closures for full details of these activities and other projects underway in our public space. (click for more)

Breaking News

Tennessee Has 3,606 New COVID Cases, 65 Deaths; Hamilton County Has 104 New Cases

Hamilton County had no new deaths from the coronavirus on Friday, as the toll remained at 106. There were 104 new cases, compared to 131 on Thursday, bringing the total to 11,732. There have been 10,675 people recover from the virus in the county, 91 percent, and there are 951active cases, up seven since Thursday. There are currently 80 people hospitalized in Hamilton County, ... (click for more)

Man Killed On I-75 After Vehicle Hits Deer, Then He Is Struck By Multiple Vehicles After Re-Entering Freeway; Several Others Hurt

A man was killed in the 1000 block of I-75 north after his car struck a deer, then he was hit by multiple vehicles after re-entering the freeway. Several others involved in the wreck were injured. The Chattanooga Police Traffic Division on Friday responded to the multiple-vehicle crash with injuries. Police said a Chevy Silverado was traveling north on I-75 near ... (click for more)

Opinion

The Courts' Role In Protecting Voting Rights

Nov. 3, Election Day, is right around the corner. Of course, voting is fundamental to elections. It is through voting we both give our consent to those we entrust to govern us and hold those governing us accountable. From our right to vote come many of our rights and freedoms. Every day seems to bring new stories about disputes over voting, many of which are pursued through lawsuits. ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: Faith, Family & Football

The most heralded player in any college football huddle is the one who got there via a “battlefield promotion.” These were always my personal favorites in the nearly 40 years I covered college football because, unlike a kid who head is swollen because some unknowing source decreed they were a “five star recruit” or a punk clown who changes his “commit” three times before his last ... (click for more)