ATM Leader Says Market Center, The Maclellan Should Give Up PILOT Tax Break Agreements

Tuesday, October 22, 2019

The head of the citizen watchdog group, Accountability for Taxpayer Money (ATM), says both the Market Center and the The Maclellan apartment building should give up their PILOT tax break agreements.

Helens Burns Sharp noted that both have changed their business models and now include short-term rentals.

Ms. Sharp sent an email to members of the board of the city's Health Educational and Housing Facility Board, which is due to discuss the two entities at a meeting on Wednesday.

She said:

Dear Board Members--

I see on your October 23rd agenda that you will be discussing the Market City Center and Maclellan PILOTs. I cannot be at the meeting to address the Board so I decided to put a few comments in writing. I would appreciate it if a printed copy of this email is entered into the record for the meeting.

I was delighted to see the letter from Mayors Berke and Coppinger dated August 23, 2019. It says that conversion of units to short term vacation rentals (STVR) within the Market City Center apartment complex is in violation of their payment-in-lieu-of-tax (PILOT) agreement and that these units will now be assessed for property taxes. 

I assume the response to the Maclellan "news"--they want to lease two units as travel units--will be viewed the same way. They have 90 total units, with a requirement that 20 percent (18) be rented to low and moderate-income tenants. 

Actually, I wish that both developers would acknowledge that their business model has changed and ask to terminate the PILOTs.

I founded Accountability for Taxpayer Money (ATM) several years ago. While ATM is not against all property tax incentives, we believe that the city and county always need to be strategic in awarding them, making sure they go to businesses that pass the "but for" test. (But for the incentive, we would not do the project. Occasionally a developer may have already decided to do a project that would pay property taxes if not for the PILOT.)

Also, we believe that clawback language in PILOT agreements could be made more clear. For example, language could be added to all new housing PILOTs to make crystal clear that conversion to STVR units voids the PILOT.

We believe that language in the agreement should make clear that it is not acceptable to just "set-aside" units for low and moderate-income. State law references housing units to be occupied by low and moderate-income citizens.

People ask me from time to time why I get my feathers ruffled over some PILOTs and tax increment financing (TIF) projects. Two reasons: tax equity and social justice.

Tax Equity. This gets at the fairness issue, aka "should government be picking winners and losers? Example: On housing PILOTs, the vast majority of apartment developers pay full property taxes on their units. When your board approves a housing PILOT, you are giving a very generous tax break that lasts from 14 to 18 years to a handful of developers. Under state law, the public purpose allowing you to approve a PILOT agreement requires the project to provide housing to be occupied by low and moderate-income citizens. (The policies adopted by City Council set the definition for low-mod at $38,000 per year and allow a rent of up $950 per unit.)

Social Justice. This gets at the issue of what these "forgiven" taxes could be used for if they were collected from PILOT and TIF beneficiaries. The long list includes equipment for firefighters, job training for East Chattanooga residents who want to work at the Paint company coming to the Tubman site, and all the streets in town that need to be improved. A conservative estimate of city and county property taxes that will not be collected due to housing PILOTs currently on the books is over $10 million.

Thanks for your service on the Board.

Respectfully--

~Helen Burns Sharp

New Traffic Pattern From West MLK Boulevard To U.S. 27 South Begins Monday

HCEA Leader Says Town Hall Meeting "Not Confrontational"; Tim Boyd Responds

Upcoming City Council Agenda


As U.S. 27 widening through downtown Chattanooga progresses, the contractor will implement a new traffic pattern that will affect access from West MLK Boulevard to U.S. 27 South. Beginning ... (click for more)

Jeanette Omarkhail, president of the Hamilton County Education Association, said Thursday that the planned town hall meeting on Sunday on teacher pay and other issues is not "confrontational." ... (click for more)

Here is the upcoming City Council agenda: I. Call to Order by Chairman Oglesby. II. Pledge of Allegiance/Invocation (Chairman Oglesby). III. Special Presentation. Order of Business ... (click for more)


Breaking News

New Traffic Pattern From West MLK Boulevard To U.S. 27 South Begins Monday

As U.S. 27 widening through downtown Chattanooga progresses, the contractor will implement a new traffic pattern that will affect access from West MLK Boulevard to U.S. 27 South. Beginning at 9 a.m. on Monday, the contractor will shift traffic and open a newly-constructed ramp from West MLK Boulevard to U.S. 27 South. After the ramp is opened, traffic wishing to access U.S. 27 ... (click for more)

HCEA Leader Says Town Hall Meeting "Not Confrontational"; Tim Boyd Responds

Jeanette Omarkhail, president of the Hamilton County Education Association, said Thursday that the planned town hall meeting on Sunday on teacher pay and other issues is not "confrontational." She said, “There was discussion at this week’s County Commission meeting that the town hall being held this weekend was confrontational in nature. Nothing could be further from the truth. ... (click for more)

Opinion

Tubman TIF - Not Yet Ready For Prime Time

A wise man once wrote that reading about tax increment financing is about as exciting as watching paint dry. Yes, it is boring, but it is important that the city use this tool wisely to create economic development opportunities and to build community trust. On Thursday, Nov. 14, at 11 a.m., the Industrial Development Board (IDB) will hold a public hearing regarding a proposed ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: The Whistleblower

For a guy that endured the evolution of personal computers, I’ve never forgotten one of the earliest truths: “GIGO -- Garbage In, Garbage out.” As a newspaper reporter who started with Royal portable typewriters, then went to “telecopiers,” and then “Telerams,” and then Radio Shack’s first really portable computer and on down the line, I still marvel at mankind’s genius. When I ... (click for more)

Sports

UTC Wrestlers Travel To Second Ranked Iowa

University of Tennessee at Chattanooga head wrestling coach Kyle Ruschell wants the Mocs to compete against the best in the country to get his team prepared for the postseason. UTC is definitely doing that this weekend with a trip to No. 2 Iowa on Sunday, Nov. 17. Match time is set for 3:00 p.m. (E.S.T.) in Carver-Hawkeye Arena in Iowa City, Iowa. “This is a great opportunity ... (click for more)

Lady Vols Go To 4-0 With 30-Point Win Over Tennessee State

The Lady Vols moved their record to 4-0 on Thursday night, defeating Tennessee State, 73-43, in front of a crowd of 7,213 at Thompson-Boling Arena. The win marked the third-straight year that UT has started out 4-0, and the Lady Vols improved to 6-0 all-time against the Lady Tigers (1-1). Eight players for the Big Orange scored during the first of six consecutive home ... (click for more)