Exit Employment Agreement For Red Bank City Manager Tim Thornbury Is Finally Approved

Wednesday, May 19, 2021 - by Gail Perry

At the fifth meeting about City Manager Tim Thornbury’s status in Red Bank, an amendment to the employment agreement between the city and Mr. Thornbury was approved. At the commission meeting Thursday night, despite repeated attempts by the mayor and vice mayor to alter the proposal, the vote was to accept it as written. The original contract between the city and Mr. Thornbury was entered into on Nov. 6, 2018 when the responsibilities of the city manager were added to his existing position as director of the public works department and building inspector.

 

Attorney Sam Elliott, representing Mr. Thornbury regarding his contract, told the commissioners that it is well known that city manager jobs do not last long. When there is an election, things could change, so he asked for a contract to give him an exit which led to this proposed amendment to the agreement.

 

In the agreement that was finally passed, Mr. Thornbury will cease the duties of city manager and public works director, and will perform all the duties for all commercial building inspections required by the city until another inspector is hired or is certified to conduct the inspections. This arrangement will end on March 31, 2022. He will also provide on-call services upon request from the interim city manager for assisting in preparation of the 2021-2022 city budget, assisting with the transportation improvement projects that are in process, assisting with the notice of noncompliance from the National Park Service regarding the conversion of the old Red Bank Middle School property on Dayton Boulevard, as well as assisting with other transition matters and projects within the city that he has experience and knowledge of.

 

Under this agreement, he will be paid his current level of compensation which is $110,000. He will also be eligible to get health insurance and retirement benefits, vacation, sick leave, and an automobile allowance through Oct. 31.

 

Attorney Mark Litchford was retained to represent the city after City Attorney Arnold Stulce recused himself because of the long-time relationship he has had with Mr. Thornbury. Mr. Litchford told the commissioners that an on-call employee would be subject to responding to the city manager at any time. If the commissioners suggest that he resign, according to his original contract, the city would have to pay for 12 months of work and get nothing in return.

 

Vice Mayor Stefanie Dalton questioned the provisions for Mr. Thornbury to receive benefits. She contended that according to the city’s personnel policy, benefits could only be paid to full-time employees working 40 hours a week, not those working on an as-call basis. She suggested that he should step back into the public works role he held in the past, but maintaining his current salary. Mayor Berry agreed.

 

Attorney Elliott replied that the vice mayor was being “overly technical” and that a contract is an obligation that can be changed and that obligations in it can be removed by the commissioners. Both attorneys Elliott and Litchford agreed that the board of commissioners has the power to adjust a change to a contract. Mr. Litchford added that after asking John Alexander, who was later approved to serve as interim city manager, he was told that Mr. Thornbury will be in the field or meeting with professional people every day. Mr. Litchford said that the designation of “full-time” is not in any job description in the city’s personnel policy. The responsibilities of each job are determined by the city manager. “I’m satisfied on-call complies with the city’s employment policy," said Mr. Litchford.

 

Commissioner Ruth Jeno said some of the projects that Mr. Thornbury has been working on have been ongoing for years and many are being funded by grants which he has been instrumental in getting and managing. The city would lose more that he would be paid for the next 12 months if those projects were lost. She added that he has also been working with the WWTA Board with regards to getting the sewer moratorium lifted in order to move forward with development of the old middle school property.

 

The vice mayor responded that she has concerns regarding any and all of the projects he has been working on that have not all been approved by the municipal planning commission as required before making changes to any public property. She said that all on-going projects need to sent back through the planning commission, which she said was required by state law.

 

She added that in the past year, he did 95 building inspections which, she said that she has read, takes around four hours each to perform, implying that would not require his attention full-time.

 

Mr. Thornbury responded that the first step in all municipal projects is for the city manager to receive approval from the commissioners to go forward in applying for funding or grants. He said that was done for each project. “My point is that I have to get your approval first,” he said. Three new projects were sent to the planning commission this week for review even though a recommendation to proceed is not needed for routine work such as simple resurfacing, he said. Widening the Lullwater Bridge was the project that did need approval because it altered the width, but repaving on Dayton Boulevard and updating ADA requirements did not need approval, but were sent due to the concern from the vice mayor.

 

Mayor Berry said if the agreement is reached that the city would still be looking for a new city manager, which she has been told takes around three months. So she suggested shortening the term of the on-call agreement for it to end on Nov. 6. When Mr. Elliott said that would not be acceptable, she withdrew her motion.

 

Then Vice Mayor Dalton said that the creation of the new position of commercial building inspector would set a dangerous precedent for future city managers and despite a legal opinion from Mr. Litchford representing the city, again suggested that he be assigned to the established position of public works director. “I don’t feel that creating a new position will help Red Bank going forward with future city managers,” she said.

 

“With my long experience with cities,” said attorney Elliott, “city managers talk. You have an agreement with Mr. Thornbury that is mutually beneficial. When you say it is jeopardizing Red Bank’s future, it is actually the opposite because Red Bank would not be honoring its agreements, so respectfully, you’ll have trouble in the future.”

 

“He still wants to do the job,” said Commissioner Pete Phillips. “He just doesn’t want to deal with us. Mr. Thornbury, his attorney and our attorney have all agreed to the contract. It will all fall apart if we try to renegotiate it now,” he added.

 

Mayor Berry then made a motion to amend the new agreement by adding that Mr. Thornbury be classified as the director of the public works department, based on comments from the vice mayor. Mr. Thornbury indicated that was unacceptable, after which the mayor again withdrew her motion.

 

Comments made at the meeting during the citizens participation include:

  • Some on the board want to make rules to benefit themselves.

  • In agreement with the vice mayor, the speaker said Mr. Thornbury should be asked to work for a daily rate.

  • With elections, things change and employees might leave. It was his decision to retire. He does not want to work for you.

  • You should consider changes that have occurred since the November election. Since then City Recorder Ruthie Rohen, a 33-year employee, Fire Chief Mark Matthews, a 45-year employee and City Manager Tim Thornbury, a 35-year employee have all left.

  • This process has been drawn out and has had a lot of theatrics, there needs to be a resolution and it should be done respectfully, and efficiently. You cannot bring in a new person and expect them to know what is going on. A new employee does not replace experience.

  • Thanks was given to Attorney Mark Litchford for his guidance and expertise during this procedure.

  • Why is an hourly wage not under discussion?

  • The amount of disrespect during the process has shown distain for all these people. Where is the compromise?

Commissioner Pete Phillips made the motion that was seconded by Commissioner Ed Lecompte, to accept the amended agreement approved by Thornbury, Litchford, and Elliott. The motion passed to accept the contract came from Commissioners Phillips, Jeno and Lecompte. Mayor Berry and Vice Mayor Dalton voted in opposition.

The search for a permanent city manager will be guided by MTAS, (Municipal Technical Advisory Services.)


Latest Hamilton County Arrest Report

Former TBI, Highway Patrol Director Larry Wallace Dies At 97; Helped Chattanooga And Cleveland Police

Police Blotter: Woman Is Afraid Of Man Trying To Burn Her With Acid; Woman Rents Apartment With Stolen Identity


Here is the latest Hamilton County arrest report: AUSTIN, GEORGE H 312 MCBRIEN RD CHATTANOOGA, 374114888 Age at Arrest: 21 years old Arresting Agency: Chattanooga PD DOMESTIC ASSAULT ... (click for more)

One of Tennessee’s most distinguished lawmen has died. Former TBI director Larry Wallace died at his Athens, Tn., home on Thursday after a short bout with cancer. The Athens native was ... (click for more)

Police were called to a disorder on Amin Drive and Shallowford Road where a woman was very afraid. She didn’t want to talk to police and make a report. The woman said a short, black male with ... (click for more)



Breaking News

Latest Hamilton County Arrest Report

Here is the latest Hamilton County arrest report: AUSTIN, GEORGE H 312 MCBRIEN RD CHATTANOOGA, 374114888 Age at Arrest: 21 years old Arresting Agency: Chattanooga PD DOMESTIC ASSAULT BALLEW, KRISTEN DIANE 3404 OLD TASSO RD CLEVELAND, 37311 Age at Arrest: 30 years old Arresting Agency: Collegedale Booked for Previous Charges or Other Reason(s) BENN, DEDRICK ... (click for more)

Former TBI, Highway Patrol Director Larry Wallace Dies At 97; Helped Chattanooga And Cleveland Police

One of Tennessee’s most distinguished lawmen has died. Former TBI director Larry Wallace died at his Athens, Tn., home on Thursday after a short bout with cancer. The Athens native was head of the TBI from 1992 to 2003. He also headed the Tennessee Highway Patrol and later provided help to the Chattanooga and Cleveland Police Departments. Former Cleveland Mayor Tom Rowland ... (click for more)

Opinion

Rest In Peace, Larry Wallace

Athens and Tennessee lost a great friend and a long-time public servant when Larry Wallace passed away Saturday afternoon. The 1962 McMinn County High School graduate started his lifetime law enforcement career with the Athens Police Department in 1964. He joined the Tennessee Highway Patrol in 1967 and was appointed as a special agent with the Tennessee Bureau of ... (click for more)

Election Day Observations - And Response

Congratulations to all the winners in Thursday's election. And also thanks to all who ran, it takes a lot of courage to enter the arena of politics. I didn't vote for Weston in the primary but I certainly did in the general election. I think he will do a wonderful job. Sabrena, I voted for you but I would imagine your career is over after one of the dumbest political stunts I ... (click for more)

Sports

Rain Did Not Dampen Red Wolves Resolve In Win

The rain delays did not lull the Red Wolves to sleep, as Chattanooga pounced all over the top-ranked Greenville Triumph in Saturday’s 5-1 blowout. Following a two-hour thunderstorm delay, the Red Wolves squared off against their long-time difficult foe in the Greenville Triumph. Every game between the two squads has been one by one goal—that was not the case for this muggy, physical ... (click for more)

Chattanooga FC Extends Unbeaten Streak With 3-0 Win Over Maryland

Chattanooga FC battled to a 3-0 victory over the Maryland Bobcats late Saturday night with an official attendance of 3,479. The only thing more electric than the delay-causing lightning was Chattanooga’s first half attack, with goals from Markus Naglestad, Greg Stratton, and Taylor Gray. Chattanooga FC had a two-week break in action prior to the match following a dramatic cup ... (click for more)