Urging A More Thorough Analysis Of The Stadium Relocation

Friday, August 5, 2022

The number of questions citizens are raising about relocating the Lookouts stadium keeps growing. Few are being answered. Based on the information available to the public on land use and economic impacts, a stadium is by no means the ideal anchor for South Broad redevelopment. Citizens, however, appear to be most concerned about the public sector economics. From that perspective, the economic impact analysis the City Council will consider Tuesday is missing very critical information, namely the opportunity costs.

The stadium proposal only relocates an existing public good. Whatever economic impacts the stadium spins off now move with it. Let that sink in. Most, if not all, of the economic impact is negated by that singular opportunity cost, and that does not even include whatever public costs will ultimately be needed to then redevelop the old stadium site. After accounting for that, the only new direct community benefit from the stadium proposal is the removal of blight in the path of development.

It is incumbent on local government to answer the most basic policy questions: Is the stadium proposal the most efficient use of taxpayer resources to accomplish the cleanup of US Pipe/Wheland Foundry brownfield sites? Is it more cost-effective than just investing in the cleanup and letting the market determine the use? Would an RFP offering comparable public incentives attract a better use with greater public benefits? What are the relative risks and means, such as claw back provisions, to minimize the risks?

Hamilton County economic development resources have largely focused on the same regional market areas for four decades while neglecting declining smaller-scale community market areas and other regional market areas. Public investments and incentives for redevelopment have changed little in that time. PILOT and TIF have remained the dominant incentive programs guided by the same metrics - the amount of private investment and the number of jobs created for PILOT with loosely defined blight removal criteria for TIF.

Local governments have realized diminishing returns from this model over time as public investments increasingly incur opportunity costs inherent in redeveloping already productive land or relocating productive uses like the stadium to at best expand a current focus area. Other opportunity costs have accumulated, including residential displacement in current focus areas, the perpetuation of poverty in neighborhoods served by neglected community market areas, the loss of community economies and cultures, related increases in demand for social services, and the cumulative effect on tax equity. Increasingly, allocations using this redevelopment policy model have made fewer better off while making more worse off.

Local governments and their economic development partners clearly need a broader framework for cost-benefit analyses of public investments and incentives for redevelopment. What are the public policy alternatives for the type of development incentivized, why it is incentivized, where it is incentivized, and how it is incentivized?

There is no reason to hurry the stadium proposal. Most of the Phase I environmental assessment have only just begun, and it will take another year or two at least to complete the Phase II assessments needed to estimate the cleanup costs accurately. It is only prudent for the city council and county commission to slow down and give the new county mayor time to conduct a more thorough analysis of the stadium relocation proposal. It is only fair to let him steer county government as he sees best.

Frank Wrinn


Those That Made Tyner High School Great

Faye Robinson Thanks The Voters

Joe Biden Or Joe Stalin? - And Response (6)


I would like to thank John Shearer for the article on Tyner High history. I want to list a few names of teachers that made it great. I know I will probably leave out a name and I am sorry. The ... (click for more)

I want to thank the voters for electing me to be the first Hamilton County School Board member for the newly created District 10. Thank you to my family, friends, neighbors and my campaign team. ... (click for more)

August 8, 2022, the United States became a Third World country thanks to AG Merrick Garland and FBI Director Chris Wray, sinister henchmen of Joe Biden. From reports, FBI agents executed an unprecedented ... (click for more)



Opinion

Those That Made Tyner High School Great

I would like to thank John Shearer for the article on Tyner High history. I want to list a few names of teachers that made it great. I know I will probably leave out a name and I am sorry. The names that follow made Tyner High School great. Kent Hampton, Andy Anderson, Bill Kennedy, Terry Parks, Diane Whittaker, Monte Howard, Eva Pennington, Raymond Adams, Marvin Cousins, Patsy ... (click for more)

Faye Robinson Thanks The Voters

I want to thank the voters for electing me to be the first Hamilton County School Board member for the newly created District 10. Thank you to my family, friends, neighbors and my campaign team. For the last six months, I have been on a listening tour. I asked a lot of questions. I wanted to see and hear from students, teachers, parents, support staff, administration and taxpayers, ... (click for more)

Breaking News

City Council Gives Final Approval For Stadium Deal; Council Adds Provisions For "Transparency" On $80 Million Project

The City Council on Tuesday unanimously approved the $80 million Southside Stadium project. The action puts in motion the ability for a new city/county Sports Authority to convene and issue $80 million in bonds for the "community" facility on nine acres at the U.S. Pipe/Wheland Foundry site. Councilman Chip Henderson added several provisions that he said would add "transparency" ... (click for more)

CHA Planning 1,783 Housing Units At Re-Envisioned Westside

Officials of the Chattanooga Housing Authority said the plan to re-envision the Westside includes building 1,783 new housing units. Betsy McCright, CHA executive director, said the College Hill Courts and the Gateway Tower will be taken down, but she said residents in those 629 have been promised a spot in some of the new housing. She said the demolition will be in stages ... (click for more)

Sports

Hash Leads UTC Soccer To Win Over MTSU

Chattanooga’s Shelby Hash battled through the Middle Tennessee defense Tuesday night twice to give the Mocs a 2-1 win over the Blue Raiders in preseason women’s soccer action. The two teams battled to a draw in the first of three 30-minute periods at the Dean A. Hayes Track and Soccer Stadium. In the 43 rd minute of the match, Hash fought off the defense, pushing the ball through ... (click for more)

Randy Smith: Rusty's Ready To Go

As the Chattanooga Mocs open their fourth season under head coach Rusty Wright, there is an air of excitement and high expectations. The Mocs are the pre-season favorites to win the Southern Conference Championship as well as being ranked 12th in the polls before the season gets underway. That's pretty good for a guy who has more than paid his dues since he graduated from UTC in ... (click for more)