Slime Journalism

Wednesday, January 12, 2005

Another mayoral race is approaching. Again, the voices of the same old circle of a rich and powerful few are readily heard, but not directly of course. Instead, they continue to sit on their high perch overlooking the surrogates who speak for them. All they need do is tend to their payrolls.

Last Thursday the Chattanooga Times-Free Press printed Allan McCallie's unsubstantiated allegation that another candidate via a "push poll" was maligning his candidate of choice, Ms. Ann Coulter. Of course, the Times-Free Press omitted the simple fact that Mr. McCallie is an attorney and trustee of the RiverCity Company.

In what was presented ostensibly as a straight news article, Mr. McCallie claimed a polling firm whose name he could not remember contacted him.
Questions seeking his reaction to generic candidate scenarios, in
particular, a candidate who is an atheist, a candidate who keeps her maiden name after marriage, and a candidate who profits from a non-profit agency supposedly offended McCallie. It was clear from Mr. McCallie's own statement, however, that he took offense only by surmising that those questions related to his candidate, Ms. Coulter, also paid (until recently) by the RiverCity Company.

For good measure the Times-Free Press then ran a Sunday editorial, "Slime Tactics in the Mayor's Race," complaining about "the noxious weeds and deadly blights of push polls and nasty rumor campaigns." The editorial condescends by defining to its presumably uneducated readers the term, "push poll," calling it "a sleazy new-age hybrid" between a "typical" public opinion poll and a rumor campaign. The piece was chock-full of incendiary language including "slanderous attacks," "insidious," "instigators who operate in the shadows to suggest lies," "parasites whose toxic work often remains undisputed," "sleazy innuendo, "planting false information," "specious assumptions," "nasty rumors," "underhanded," and "stealthy
political poison."

Such language meets the journalistic standards of Michael Savage, perhaps, but is hardly worthy of an editorial page still bearing the name of the formerly well-respected Chattanooga Times. Vicious characterizations are not the editorial's most troubling parts, however.

These are its really disturbing aspects:
The editorial restates as fact the claims of a biased source without even referencing the source, much less the financial conflicts of interests and biases of the source. In hypocritical fashion, the editor then repeatedly attempts through his own innuendo to link the alleged push poll to his real target, highly regarded City Councilman and mayoral candidate, Ron Littlefield. The editor disguises his own borderline slander with the c.y.a. phrases, "clearly seemed to seek a way to attack," "seemed to be the target of," "seemed designed to," and "surely may."

The editor fails to disclose that he owes his own job to a prominent Coulter financial backer, Ruth Holmberg. The editor misinforms its readers about what a push poll really is. (Push polls are conducted in the final days of a campaign. Push polls are not designed to survey a sample, but to reach many thousands of targeted voters. Push polls give the name of the candidate being subjected to the negative attack, no surmising required.)

During an election season there are any number of polls conducted for any variety of perfectly legitimate reasons. Some test issues. Some test opposition candidate strengths and weaknesses. Some test a candidate's own strengths and weaknesses. Some measure name recognition, positive and negative. Some track the horserace. Some serve more than one of those purposes in the same survey. Some are conducted by campaigns. Some are conducted independently, sometimes even using a current election to gather information for use in an altogether different election. Times-Free Press
statements as to who conducted a particular poll or why it was conducted are pure speculation at best and a blatant smear at worse.

By way of full disclosure, I know Ron Littlefield. Ron Littlefield is a
friend of twenty-five years.

I worked as a volunteer in Ron's first race (a city-wide campaign unseating an entrenched incumbent Public Works Commissioner in the previous form of government), but have not been involved in local politics for many years since, until now. When I read that Times-Free Press editorial, I decided that I could not sit idly by while representatives of the power structure shamelessly attempt to tar Ron, a good man, an honest man, an honorable man, with terms like "slime" and "sleaze."

First, I called the Times editorial page number to express my concerns. I quickly realized I was not speaking with a dispassionate editor who had simply expressed a strongly held political opinion. Instead, the editor made very clear to me that he had an agenda, and that his agenda was personal. I asked him, "If you're going to attack Ron, why don't you do it directly, instead using innuendo?" The Times editor responded, "Don't worry we will!" He was also condescending to me as well, explaining, "This is politics!" At least he didn't confuse "this" with journalism.

I have much more to say about the revolving door between the RiverCity Company and the office of mayor. I have many issues to address regarding the financial conflicts of interest through which a tangled web of privileged insiders gain at taxpayers', electric power ratepayers', rent payers', and private property owners' expense. I also intend to point out every instance in which the Times-Free Press fails to disclosed those conflicts in its reporting on the mayoral campaign. Furthermore, I promise to state facts, not innuendo.

For now, however, on the issue at hand I can say without hesitation, without reservation, and without equivocation that Ron Littlefield would never, not ever, authorize, sanction, or in any way approve of a push poll being conducted on his behalf. I can also say without using c.y.a. language that the Chattanooga Times-Free Press editorial was erroneous, malicious, and intentionally misleading to its readers.

Thanks to the Chattanoogan.com, the voices of people other than a rich and powerful few can be still heard. Thank God our community does not have to depend on a single publication, namely the Times-Free Press and the "slime" journalism of at least one editor there.

Frank Wrinn
fwrinn@hotmail.com


Congratulations, Democrats

Roy Exum: Liberty Above Mandates

Marie Mott Needs Our Prayers - And Response


“It’s wrong to hope he (Lindsey Graham) dies from COVID, right?”, Kate Coyne-McCoy, director of the Rhode Island Democrat Party, tweeted yesterday, advocating a premature end to his life. ... (click for more)

It is no secret I’ve been on the COVID vaccine bandwagon since the very get-go. Due to my compromised immune system and my age (72) I am one of those at-risk people and I got my first shot the ... (click for more)

Former City Council candidate and protest leader Marie Mott and I used to be friends. We had a public falling out over defunding the police and other political issues. I respect her and know ... (click for more)



Opinion

Congratulations, Democrats

“It’s wrong to hope he (Lindsey Graham) dies from COVID, right?”, Kate Coyne-McCoy, director of the Rhode Island Democrat Party, tweeted yesterday, advocating a premature end to his life. Congratulations, Democrats, after years of denigration of your political opponents you have finally found an appropriate leader for your party. I am surprised it took so long but I’m overjoyed ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: Liberty Above Mandates

It is no secret I’ve been on the COVID vaccine bandwagon since the very get-go. Due to my compromised immune system and my age (72) I am one of those at-risk people and I got my first shot the first minute I could; around Valentine’s Day. Since then, I’ve used my opinion pulpit to push the vaccine as hard as possible because I am totally convinced it saves lives. Therefore, this ... (click for more)

Breaking News

Man Charged In Pikeville Axe Murders Told Police He Can't Remember Grisly Killings, But "It Must Have Been Me"

A man charged with using an axe to hack a mother and her daughter to death told authorities he cannot remember any details of the grisly killings at Pikeville, but Robert Joe Whittenburg said he concluded "it had to be me." Whittenburg, 47, faces two counts of first-degree murder in the killing of 46-year-old Deanna Lawrence and her 24-year-old daughter (and his girlfriend) Dedra ... (click for more)

Red Bank Commissioners Vote On 1st Reading To Raise Taxes 11 Cents

Red Bank Commissioners voted unanimously on first reading on Tuesday night to raise the property tax by 11 cents. The new $1.10 per $100 of assessed valuation was 10 cents below what Interim City Manager John Alexander had recommended and had been supported by Mayor Hollie Berry and Vice Mayor Stefanie Dalton. Red Bank's tax rate previously was $1.39. However, under the certified ... (click for more)

Sports

Dan Fleser: Dodgeball, Kickball Part Of Vol Football Team Building

The football conversation on Tuesday at Tennessee’s Neyland-Thompson Sports Center was almost exclusively about football. The fare was typical for a media-day setting and timely, considering preseason practice begins on Wednesday and the season opens Sept. 2 against Bowling Green. There wasn’t a second spent on recounting any games of dodge ball or kick ball that took ... (click for more)

Lookouts Snap Losing Streak With Timely Hitting

The Chattanooga Lookouts didn’t exactly knock down the walls at AT&T Field with their bats Tuesday night, but they did manage to get enough clutch hits to snap a two-game losing streak with a come-from-behind 5-1 victory over the Rocket City Trash Pandas. The Lookouts improve to 17-17 at home and 40-36 overall while Rocket City falls to 37-39 overall. More importantly, ... (click for more)