Federal Judge Signs Order Allowing TVA To Access Farms On Way To Planned New Meigs County Power Center

Tuesday, December 4, 2018

Federal Judge Sandy Mattice has signed an order giving TVA access to several farms along the route to a planned new $300 million power center in Meigs County.

Meanwhile, the farm owners have hired prominent Chattanooga attorney Roger Dickson to try to fight TVA access to the farms for construction of a high-voltage line.

The order says  the farm lands "are deemed to be condemned and taken for the use of the United States" with compensation to be determined for the owners. 

One suit is against Greg Vital, a well-known businessman who has raised objections to the line going across his Meigs County farm. His farm includes an old stone barn that is on the National Register of Historic Places.

Another is against John and Bridget Vantiegham, who also own property in Meigs County along the route to the power control center. Another is against the owners of Cornerstone Farm in Hamilton County. 

The farm owners say they have only had a few months notice of the taking, but that TVA has been planning it for several years.

Magistrate Judge Susan K. Lee, who was also assigned to the case, has recused herself in a one-sentence order.

Here is the order signed by Judge Mattice:

Upon the filing of a Declaration of Taking and the deposit of the estimated compensation to which the landowner is entitled for the taking, the lands are deemed to be condemned and taken for the use of the United States and the right to just compensation vests in the person entitled. 40 U.S.C. § 3114(b). The United States of America, by and through its agents, is entitled to immediate possession of property condemned by power of eminent domain. United States v. Miller, 317 U.S. 369, 381 (1943). The statutory and constitutional authority of the Tennessee Valley Authority (“TVA”) under the TVA Act, 16 U.S.C. § 831, as an agent of the United States, to construct electric transmission lines and circuits and acquire rights-of-way therefore by condemnation has long been established. Ashwander v. Tennessee Valley Authority,297 U.S. 288 (1936); United States ex rel. TVA v. Russell, 87 F. Supp. 386 (E.D. Tenn. 1948); United States ex rel. TVA v. An Easement & Right-of-Way Over 1.8 Acres of Land, 682 F. Supp. 353 (M.D. Tenn. 1988). In this case, Plaintiff has filed a proper Declaration of Taking (Doc. 1-2) and has placed with the Court an estimate of the just and liberal compensation to be afforded to Defendants for the taking (Doc. 2).1 Accordingly, Plaintiff TVA shall have and be put into immediate possession of the real property specifically described in Plaintiff’s Declaration of Taking to the extent necessary to allow, enable, and permit TVA to conduct “surveys, core drilling, appraisals, title investigations, and related activities to determine what portion of said land or interest therein is necessary for the erection, operation, and maintenance of electric power transmission circuits.” (Doc. 1 at 1–2). “[T]he Plaintiff [will] remain liable for damage to annual crops and other actual property damage resulting directly from the operations of Plaintiff’s forces in the conduct of such activities upon said land.” (Id.). Accordingly, Defendants are ORDERED to immediately comply with this Order and to surrender possession of said real property to TVA pending further order of the Court. 


Michael Patrick Is Interim Chief At WWTA; EPA Meeting Delayed To March 6

City Report Says Ballard Had Pattern Of Sexual Harassment Over Female Trainees; Attorney Says He Looks Forward To Returning To Work

Chattanooga Under Flood Watch As New Round Of Storms Approaches


The Hamilton County WWTA Board of Commissioners has named chief engineer Michael Patrick as the organization’s interim executive director. He replaces former executive director Mark Harrison ... (click for more)

A city report says an instructor over police academies had a pattern of sexual harassment against female cadets. Two female trainees initially filed the complaint against instructor Ricky ... (click for more)

Chattanooga was under a Flood Watch until Saturday morning as a new round of heavy rain and thunderstorms was approaching from the west. The city has already been pounded by days of rain, ... (click for more)


Breaking News

Michael Patrick Is Interim Chief At WWTA; EPA Meeting Delayed To March 6

The Hamilton County WWTA Board of Commissioners has named chief engineer Michael Patrick as the organization’s interim executive director. He replaces former executive director Mark Harrison who resigned late last week. Prior to joining the WWTA as chief engineer, Mr. Patrick was the director of the city of Chattanooga’s Water Wastewater Resources Division. He was responsible ... (click for more)

City Report Says Ballard Had Pattern Of Sexual Harassment Over Female Trainees; Attorney Says He Looks Forward To Returning To Work

A city report says an instructor over police academies had a pattern of sexual harassment against female cadets. Two female trainees initially filed the complaint against instructor Ricky Ballard. Ballard was suspended earlier this month for 160 hours without pay over the sexual allegations. Four female cadets said they received unwanted hugs from Ballard. They said Ballard ... (click for more)

Opinion

Heavy Rains Are Coming In The Next Few Days

Please remember to check on folks that are vulnerable which includes the elderly and homebound. With expectations of up to 7 inches or more of rain, we may see flooding in areas that rival those of the past. As Chief Roddy told me this morning, be proactive, not reactive. Pack for an extended stay at work or someone's house. Be ready with extra food, water and blanket in your ... (click for more)

The $500,000 Tax Money Giveway - And Response

Mayor Berke, On September 5, 2017, you asked and were granted a 22-cent property tax increase for city government operations and a capital fund. At the meeting, the City Council approved your proposal for the property tax increase of 22 cents per $100 of property assessment. As a result, every business, home owner, and property owner had one-month notice that their local property ... (click for more)

Sports

Dan Fleser: Vols Still Atop SEC, But Vantage Point Still A Little Cloudy

The view from the highest points of the SEC men’s basketball standings isn’t exactly picturesque these days. By virtue of LSU’s 82-77 overtime loss to Florida Wednesday night, Tennessee again has the best vantage point. No matter, it’s still partly cloudy up there in first place by virtue of last Saturday’s rout at the hands of Kentucky. A workmanlike victory over Vanderbilt on ... (click for more)

Top-Ranked Goodpasture Edges Notre Dame

Some things are inevitable and apparently the Notre Dame basketball team finding its way on the tracks between Goodpasture and a trip to the Division II-A State Quarterfinals is one of them. For the second year in a row, the state’s top-ranked team from Madison found a way to get in a trip to Chattanooga for a 32-minute tussle with the Fighting Irish in the opening round of ... (click for more)