Federal Judge Signs Order Allowing TVA To Access Farms On Way To Planned New Meigs County Power Center

Tuesday, December 4, 2018

Federal Judge Sandy Mattice has signed an order giving TVA access to several farms along the route to a planned new $300 million power center in Meigs County.

Meanwhile, the farm owners have hired prominent Chattanooga attorney Roger Dickson to try to fight TVA access to the farms for construction of a high-voltage line.

The order says  the farm lands "are deemed to be condemned and taken for the use of the United States" with compensation to be determined for the owners. 

One suit is against Greg Vital, a well-known businessman who has raised objections to the line going across his Meigs County farm. His farm includes an old stone barn that is on the National Register of Historic Places.

Another is against John and Bridget Vantiegham, who also own property in Meigs County along the route to the power control center. Another is against the owners of Cornerstone Farm in Hamilton County. 

The farm owners say they have only had a few months notice of the taking, but that TVA has been planning it for several years.

Magistrate Judge Susan K. Lee, who was also assigned to the case, has recused herself in a one-sentence order.

Here is the order signed by Judge Mattice:

Upon the filing of a Declaration of Taking and the deposit of the estimated compensation to which the landowner is entitled for the taking, the lands are deemed to be condemned and taken for the use of the United States and the right to just compensation vests in the person entitled. 40 U.S.C. § 3114(b). The United States of America, by and through its agents, is entitled to immediate possession of property condemned by power of eminent domain. United States v. Miller, 317 U.S. 369, 381 (1943). The statutory and constitutional authority of the Tennessee Valley Authority (“TVA”) under the TVA Act, 16 U.S.C. § 831, as an agent of the United States, to construct electric transmission lines and circuits and acquire rights-of-way therefore by condemnation has long been established. Ashwander v. Tennessee Valley Authority,297 U.S. 288 (1936); United States ex rel. TVA v. Russell, 87 F. Supp. 386 (E.D. Tenn. 1948); United States ex rel. TVA v. An Easement & Right-of-Way Over 1.8 Acres of Land, 682 F. Supp. 353 (M.D. Tenn. 1988). In this case, Plaintiff has filed a proper Declaration of Taking (Doc. 1-2) and has placed with the Court an estimate of the just and liberal compensation to be afforded to Defendants for the taking (Doc. 2).1 Accordingly, Plaintiff TVA shall have and be put into immediate possession of the real property specifically described in Plaintiff’s Declaration of Taking to the extent necessary to allow, enable, and permit TVA to conduct “surveys, core drilling, appraisals, title investigations, and related activities to determine what portion of said land or interest therein is necessary for the erection, operation, and maintenance of electric power transmission circuits.” (Doc. 1 at 1–2). “[T]he Plaintiff [will] remain liable for damage to annual crops and other actual property damage resulting directly from the operations of Plaintiff’s forces in the conduct of such activities upon said land.” (Id.). Accordingly, Defendants are ORDERED to immediately comply with this Order and to surrender possession of said real property to TVA pending further order of the Court. 


Fort Negley Residents To Get Parking System Similar To Fort Wood

Petition Seeks To Keep Dollar General Out Of New Salem Community On Lookout Mountain As Dollar General Market, Ante-Bellum Event Venue Are Planned

Woman's Body Found In Walker County On Tuesday


The City Council passed an ordinance on Tuesday allowing restricted on-street parking at Fort Negley on the Southside. Council Chairman Erskine Oglesby said parking has become at a premium ... (click for more)

A petition is seeking to keep Dollar General out of the New Salem community on Lookout Mountain. It comes as Stan Carnahan said a new Dollar General store as well as an event venue in a replica ... (click for more)

An unidentified body was found on Tuesday, about 115 feet off the roadway, in the 2900 block of Old Mineral Springs Road, Lafayette, according to Walker County Sheriff Steve Wilson. Preliminary ... (click for more)


Breaking News

Fort Negley Residents To Get Parking System Similar To Fort Wood

The City Council passed an ordinance on Tuesday allowing restricted on-street parking at Fort Negley on the Southside. Council Chairman Erskine Oglesby said parking has become at a premium in the neighborhood just south of the resurgent Main Street. He said many customers of nearby businesses park in the neighborhood for lengthy periods. He said the new system will require ... (click for more)

Petition Seeks To Keep Dollar General Out Of New Salem Community On Lookout Mountain As Dollar General Market, Ante-Bellum Event Venue Are Planned

A petition is seeking to keep Dollar General out of the New Salem community on Lookout Mountain. It comes as Stan Carnahan said a new Dollar General store as well as an event venue in a replica of an ante-bellum home are planned there. Mr. Carnahan said the projects are to go on a 10-acre tract across from the Canyon Grill. It is at the intersection of Highway 136 that ... (click for more)

Opinion

Why I Support Funding The Proposed Budget - And Response

Dear Commissioners of Hamilton County, I attended the District 3 community meeting with Commissioner Greg Martin and School Board Chairman Joe Wingate, who was filling in for District 3 Rep. Joe Smith. Commissioner Martin stated he had not made up his mind on how to vote for the tax increase at that time. He requested thoughtful input on why the citizens of his district wanted ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: VW Needs Big Repairs

The banner headline on Monday morning read, “Gov. Lee, top Republicans celebrate failed UAW bid to unionize Volkswagen,” and that’s the second-worst thing that the headline could have said. The worst, of course, is if the UAW had won, and the Detroit-based union that lost 35,000 members last year would be revived -- breaking a hole into the tight wall of foreign-owned auto assembly ... (click for more)

Sports

Taliaferro Helps Fairyland Beat Country Club, 405-402

The Fairyland Flash swim team lost by a whopping 201 points to the Country Club Wavemakers last Monday at Country Club’s pool, but Fairyland was without the services of some 19 point-scoring swimmers that night. It was a totally different story atop Lookout Mountain Tuesday night as the Flash took over sole possession of first place in the Chattanooga Area Swim League’s Red division ... (click for more)

CFC Leaps To The Top Of The Standings With 2-0 Victory At Asheville

With the game still scoreless, Alun Webb chased after a pass with nothing but open space in front of the Chattanooga FC forward. He quickly caught up with the ball, and the closest Asheville defender was merely a slight bother to Webb as he curved the ball into the box for a shot that held up in a 2-0 CFC victory in the North Carolina mountains. The ball found the opportunistic ... (click for more)