Bigger Is Not Always Better

Friday, December 20, 2019

Bigger is not always better, especially when one considers the allowable size of tractor trailer rigs on our nation’s highways.  There is a current push by the transportation industry to increase the length and weights of 18-wheel trucks on America’s highways.  This is both ill-conceived and irresponsible considering our aging highway and bridge infrastructure, the personal safety of everyone using our highways, and the ever-increasing highway congestion we all endure.

Some companies in the transportation industry are lobbying Congress to increase the gross weight of tractor-trailer rigs by 14 percent from the current 80,000 pounds to 91,000 pounds. In addition, the industry wants to increase the allowable length of double tractor-trailer rigs to 91 feet, an increase of 10 feet. 

These requests have been made of our federal legislators before by the transportation industry.  In 2016 the U.S. Department of Transportation delivered a three-year Comprehensive Truck Size and Weight Limits Study Report requested by Congress.  This study concluded heavier trucks will create “…serious safety problems…” as it relates to the condition of our nation’s bridges, and in addition the report noted that the heavier tractor-trailer rigs will impose billions of dollars of additional wear and tear on our highways.  

I am quite confident a similar study conducted today would have similar conclusions knowing highway congestion has grown over the past three years and our bridges and highways haven’t gotten any younger.  According to the Federal Highway Administration there are 20,177 bridges in Tennessee and 10,955 (or 54 percent) are in fair-to-poor condition.  Need I ask the question whether-or-not heavier tractor-trailer rigs will further negatively impact these aging structures and unnecessarily risk the lives of all of us using them daily?

Six years of commuting to work on I-75 between Chattanooga and Cartersville, Ga., has given me some perspective on big rigs. I have seen a noticeable increase in accidents involving tractor-trailer rigs over the past two years, many of which are single vehicle accidents.  I can’t explain the increased number of accidents, but I am certain larger rigs will result in many more severe accidents.  During 2018 in Tennessee alone, there were 3,973 large-truck accidents resulting in 118 fatalities.  In the first half of 2019, reported highway accident numbers indicate Tennessee is on track to repeat similar numbers of large truck accidents with an even greater number of fatalities.  

How can anyone make a reasonable conclusion that increasing the size, weight, and length of tractor-trailer rigs makes sense?  

I strongly implore leaders in the House and Senate to vote “NO” to passing federal legislation increasing the allowable size and weight of tractor-trailer rigs on our highways.  We do not need the federal government telling us what is best for Tennessee.  This seems to be a reasonable request considering the road conditions and usage varies dramatically across our great United States.

Commissioner Tim Boyd
Hamilton County



Put Aside All Divisions

Things To Consider While On Lock Down

Fresh Air Is Good For You


Nearly 10 million Americans filed for unemployment in the last two weeks. The actual number of people unemployed is likely much higher with many of those being my friends and neighbors in Walker ... (click for more)

I would like to start by saying thank you to our medical professionals, you are in our prayers. Fighting this would not be possible without each one of you. May God comfort you and give you strength. ... (click for more)

I don't think the virus is being spread by a family walking along the sidewalk, on the Riverwalk or across the Walnut Street Bridge. More likely it is being spread by people loading into ... (click for more)




Opinion

Put Aside All Divisions

Nearly 10 million Americans filed for unemployment in the last two weeks. The actual number of people unemployed is likely much higher with many of those being my friends and neighbors in Walker County. We have uncertain and possibly fearful days ahead. Fear of getting sick not only for ourselves but for our friends and loved ones. Fear of unemployment, poverty and for some, ... (click for more)

Things To Consider While On Lock Down

I would like to start by saying thank you to our medical professionals, you are in our prayers. Fighting this would not be possible without each one of you. May God comfort you and give you strength. Some of the things to consider during our time at home now that we are going on a "total lock down". When we see and hear the horrible things that this virus is doing, it is almost ... (click for more)

Breaking News

Mayor Berke Directs Chattanoogans To "Shelter In Place"; Takes Questions On Facebook Live

Chattanooga Mayor Andy Berke signed Executive Order 2020-06 , directing Chattanoogans to shelter in place to try to prevent local hospitals from being overwhelmed with coronavirus victims. He said, “I know how disruptive and painful these actions will be for many, many Chattanoogans but the fact is that the coronavirus is still infecting far too many people in our city far too ... (click for more)

Hamilton County Has 12 More Coronavirus Cases To Bring Total To 63; An Additional Death Of Adult Over 70 Occurs

Hamilton County has 12 new coronavirus cases, including a death of an adult over 70, officials said Thursday. The count has now increased to 63. Becky Barnes, health department administrator, said recent patients cannot say where they picked up the virus - indicating it is "community spread." She and County Mayor Jim Coppinger continued to emphasize the need for people ... (click for more)

Sports

Noted Chattanooga Golfer, Operator Of Moccasin Bend Golf Course Wes Brown Dies At 91

Noted golfer and longtime operator of the Moccasin Bend Golf Course Wesley G. Brown Sr. has died at 91. Born in Chattanooga on September 11, 1929, to Mr. and Mrs. Edward E. Brown, Sr., he attended Normal Park Elementary and McCallie School, as a standout athlete and leader. At Washington Lee University, he was captain of the golf team and played defensive back on the football ... (click for more)

Cleveland-Native Rhyne Howard Selected As WBCA Honorable Mention

LEXINGTON, Ky. – After being named a top-four or top-five finalist for the Wooden Award, Citizen Naismith Trophy, Ann Meyers Drysdale Award and Cheryl Miller Award along with first-team All-America honors by the Associated Press, United States Basketball Writers Association and the Wooden Award, the Women’s Basketball Coaches Association has tabbed University of Kentucky sophomore ... (click for more)