State Supreme Court Rules On Parenting Plans Law

Monday, October 21, 2013

The Tennessee Supreme Court ruled Monday that a parent seeking to modify a residential parenting schedule after establishing a permanent parenting plan is not required to prove the parents did not anticipate a significant change in circumstances at the time of the initial parenting agreement.

The Court explained that a law enacted in 2004 made obsolete earlier court rulings that had been understood as requiring such proof.

In the case before the court, the couple divorced when their son was three years old and their daughter was not quite one year old. The residential parenting schedule gave the mother 280 days and the father 85 days each year with the children. In 2011, the father petitioned the court seeking more time with the children because, since the divorce: (1) he had relocated his residence and his dentistry practice; (2) he had remarried and his current wife had established a positive relationship with the children and his ex-wife; and (3) the children were two years older than they were at the time of the divorce.

The trial court granted the father’s request and gave the father 143 days and the mother 222 days annually with the children.

The mother appealed. The Court of Appeals reversed the trial court’s judgment, explaining that the father had failed to prove that the changes in circumstances could not have been reasonably anticipated when the initial residential parenting schedule was established. The father then appealed to the Supreme Court.

In the opinion filed Monday, the Supreme Court reversed the Court of Appeals’ decision and reinstated the trial court’s judgment, explaining the 2004 law makes modifying residential parenting schedules easier by eliminating the requirement that any significant change in circumstances could not have been reasonably anticipated at the time the original parenting plan was established.

The Court emphasized that the trial court properly applied the law and modified the residential parenting schedule consistently with other statutes instructing courts to structure residential parenting schedules so that both parents enjoy the maximum participation possible in the life of the child.

To read the Opinion in Andrew K. Armbrister v. Melissa H. Armbrister, authored by Justice Cornelia A. Clark, visit the Opinions section of TNCourts.gov.


Police Blotter: Doller General Shoplifter Returns; Landlord Visits Tenants At 2 A.M.

2 Fugitives Arrested Friday Afternoon On Shallowford Road

Latest Hamilton County Arrest Report


A shoplifting was reported at the Dollar General, 2303 E. 23rd St. Police spoke with the store manager, who said an unknown black female had run out of the store with a trash bag full of items ... (click for more)

Detectives with the Hamilton County Sheriff’s Office Fugitive Division went to 6220 Shallowford Road on Friday at 2:45 p.m. to attempt to locate and arrest fugitives Shawn Cranfield, 42, and ... (click for more)

Here is the latest Hamilton County arrest report: ARNOLD, TAMI MARIE 1526 DALLAS LAKE ROAD HIXSON, 37343 Age at Arrest: 53 years old Arresting Agency: Hamilton County Booked for Previous ... (click for more)



Breaking News

Police Blotter: Doller General Shoplifter Returns; Landlord Visits Tenants At 2 A.M.

A shoplifting was reported at the Dollar General, 2303 E. 23rd St. Police spoke with the store manager, who said an unknown black female had run out of the store with a trash bag full of items without paying. The woman then fled in a white four-door sedan with a drive out tag. The manager estimated the value of items taken around $200. While working on the report at a separate location, ... (click for more)

2 Fugitives Arrested Friday Afternoon On Shallowford Road

Detectives with the Hamilton County Sheriff’s Office Fugitive Division went to 6220 Shallowford Road on Friday at 2:45 p.m. to attempt to locate and arrest fugitives Shawn Cranfield, 42, and Erika Bell, 29. Cranfield had outstanding Hamilton County warrants on the following charges: possessing a firearm with intent to go armed; possession of drug paraphernalia (x2), possession ... (click for more)

Opinion

Why Is All The New Building Not Saving Us From A 40-Cent City Property Tax Increase? - And Response

With the number of homes, apartments and condos built downtown, why is a 40 percent property tax increase necessary? Are these new structures on the paying property tax role? I need to know what’s going on downtown and why isn’t that money benefiting the city? Georgia Vaughn * * * The answer is that tax exemptions for these projects have been given out freely and ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: The Degradation Of Nurses

Debbie Moore-Black, is a registered nurse whose blogs regularly appear on the medical news website, KevinMD.com. With the unearthly demands of COVID and historic lack of concern for the nursing populace, she wrote this week on the degradation and the devaluation of the nation’s nursing force. Perhaps we should all listen: * * * TIME WILL TELL IF LESSONS WILL BE LEARNED ... (click for more)

Sports

Game Notes: Tennessee At Florida

Tennessee hits the road for the first time this season with a showdown against SEC East rival Florida in primetime on Saturday night in Gainesville. The Vols are coming off a 56-0 shutout of Tennessee Tech last weekend and will look to carry that momentum into Saturday as they look to spring the upset against the 11th-ranked Gators. BROADCAST INFO Saturday's game will be ... (click for more)

Covenant Women, Men Win Maryville Invitational

The Covenant cross country teams dominated the course at the Maryville Invitational Friday afternoon. The women came in first of five with 22 points in their 6k race, while the men were also first of five in their 8k race with 26 points. The women had three runners in the top five. Claire Mackes continued her stellar performance, coming in first place overall with her ... (click for more)