City Council Votes 5-4 To Approve Tax Abatement For Lindsay Street Project; Boyd Questions, Graham Backs Project At County

Wednesday, February 11, 2015
Project at 5th and Lindsay
Project at 5th and Lindsay

The City Council on Tuesday night voted 5-4 to approve a tax abatement for an $8 million housing project near UTC.

Voting in favor were Chris Anderson, Jerry Mitchell, Russell Gilbert, Carol Berz and Moses Freeman.

Opposed were Yusuf Hakeem, Ken Smith, Larry Grohn and Chip Henderson.

UTC Five, LLC plans to construct two four-story buildings at 500 Lindsay St.

There will be 16 efficiencies, 24 one-bedroom, and 24 two-bedroom units. Officials said 13 of the efficiencies will be set aside as affordable housing. Those eligible must make less than 80 percent of the county median income of $31,000.

At the County Commission on Wednesday, Commissioner Tim Boyd sharply questioned the tax abatement, while Commissioner Joe Graham backed it. The county vote will be next Wednesday.

Commissioner Boyd computed that the governments would be giving up as much as $1 million in taxes. He said the developers could turn around and "flip it" in a few years. The county was told that the tax abatement can be transferred with the approval of the city's Health, Educational and Housing Facility Board.

Commissioner Boyd said it would be hard to verify if those qualifying for affordable housing truly qualify. He said, "I know bartenders driving around in BMWs who don't have $31,000 on their W2s."

Commissioner Graham said the county would not be losing any taxes and would stand to gain a significant amount for the schools.

Attorney Alfred Smith said, even if the county turns it down, the developer could opt to proceed using the city tax breaks but paying full county taxes.

Developer Roe Elam said the efficiency set asides will rent for $730 per month. He said the tax abatement allowed lowering the price by about $50 per unit.

He said, "If we don't get the PILOT (payment in lieu of taxes), we put a For Sale sign in the front yard. The PILOT makes a big difference."

Mr. Elam said this would not be typical dorm-style student housing, but would be aimed more at graduate students, professor, staff and young professionals.

Councilman Smith questioned whether a $50 difference "would keep a young professional from renting." He also asked, "Is it worth a 10-year abatement?"

The developer will pay no taxes on the improvements for 10 years. Afterward, there will be an annual step up from 20 percent to 40 percent to 60 percent to 80 percent and finally to 100 percent in 2030.

Councilman Freeman said the project is among those "bringing bodies" downtown, and he said they would help spur economic development.

Councilman Hakeem said the tax abatement benefits might help downtown, but would not brighten other areas, who he said would be without the $800,000 in forgiven taxes.

Kim White of the River City Company said such tax abatements are necessary to lure developers to include affordable housing. She said, "Our young people are moving back, but they have no place to live downtown."

She noted that the council earlier approved the framework of the residential abatement program. Councilman Smith said, "The fact that we approved the framework last Aug. 6 in no way restricts my right to review each individual project."

She said the property is hilly and difficult to develop. She said it has been vacant for six years.

Councilman Anderson noted that the developer would continue to pay the current taxes and the school taxes.

The Health, Educational and Housing Facility Board earlier approved the project.


 


Grand Jury No Bills And True Bills

HCSO Responds To Multiple Vehicle Break-Ins On Benwood Drive

Police Blotter: Man Steals Loud Truck With Transmission Problems And Abandons It Down The Road; Man Complains Over "Smallest Possible Stuff"


Here are the Grand Jury no bills and true bills: No Bills: 1 FINCH III, CLAUDE ABRAN STALKING 05/18/2022 1 SPENCE, IZIK DOMESTIC ASSAULT 05/18/2022 True Bills: 313534 1 BALLARD, ... (click for more)

Hamilton County Sheriff’s Office deputies responded e arly Wednesday morning to a residence near the 6920 block of Benwood Drive for the report of suspicious activity. A resident advised ... (click for more)

A woman on Boy Scout Road told police her Chevrolet C/K 1500 had just been stolen. She said the truck has a bad transmission and she could hear it on the train tracks. Officers continued down ... (click for more)



Breaking News

Grand Jury No Bills And True Bills

Here are the Grand Jury no bills and true bills: No Bills: 1 FINCH III, CLAUDE ABRAN STALKING 05/18/2022 1 SPENCE, IZIK DOMESTIC ASSAULT 05/18/2022 True Bills: 313534 1 BALLARD, RODNEY EDWARD ASSAULT 05/18/2022 313535 1 BIRT, TYRUS DEMETRAY CONTRABAND IN A PENAL INSTITUTION 05/18/2022 313536 1 BOYD, ROBERT LEON RECKLESS ENDANGERMENT 05/18/2022 313536 2 BOYD, ... (click for more)

HCSO Responds To Multiple Vehicle Break-Ins On Benwood Drive

Hamilton County Sheriff’s Office deputies responded e arly Wednesday morning to a residence near the 6920 block of Benwood Drive for the report of suspicious activity. A resident advised two men were observed acting suspicious and were believed to be burglarizing vehicles. When confronted by deputies, the suspects fled on foot One of the subjects, a juvenile, was caught by ... (click for more)

Opinion

We Owe A Great Debt Of Gratitude To Sheriff Jim Hammond

I nearly bit off my tongue trying to restrain myself with regard to the attacks on Sheriff Jim Hammond in recent weeks. For over 25 years I have known Jim. I know him to be a fine Christian gentleman, a patriotic American, a genuinely compassionate leader. For many years, at his church, he taught Sunday School. On behalf of the U.S. Department of Justice, he taught constitutional ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: Muffling The Mobs From Neighborhoods

On Monday Florida Governor Ron DeSantis signed a bill to combat bad behavior, which most laws do, but HB 1571 should have never been necessary. It bans angry mobs and profane picketers from going into neighborhoods to protest in front of somebody’s house. We’ve seen the upraised middle fingers and the insidious language spewed out of megaphones in recent weeks in front of some Supreme ... (click for more)

Sports

"We have nothing to lose" - UTC Softball On the Road to Tuscaloosa

A crowd of enthusiastic supporters sent UTC’s softball team off to Tuscaloosa in style on Wednesday afternoon. The crowd cheered the SoCon champions on as they boarded the bus bound for Alabama, where the team will play against Alabama, Stanford or Murray State. The Mocs sat at 25-25 entering the SoCon tournament, where they went on a dreamlike run to clinch their first conference ... (click for more)

"A strong ability to come back" - Chattanooga State Softball Ready for NJCAA Tournament

Chattanooga State’s Tigers scrimmaged against one another on a sunny and muggy Wednesday afternoon. The conditions weren’t the most pleasant, but it was downright paradisal compared to the conditions the team will be competing in less than a week. The Tigers softball team will travel to Yuma, Ariz. For the NJCAA tournament. After bowing out in last season’s tournament, this ... (click for more)