Man Talks Himself Into Being His Own Lawyer For Federal Court Trial

Monday, January 13, 2020 - by Joseph Dycus

A felon who already confessed to having a gun will represent himself at a trial after his guilty plea was rejected by Federal Judge Sandy Mattice on Monday.

Judge Mattice came to this conclusion after an arduous process in which it eventually became clear that Raphael Ar-Rahmaan, 30, was less than thrilled with his attorney's representation. Ar-Rahmaan even attempted to get new counsel, a motion denied by the court.

The defendant is a convicted felon and was found with a gun by police after he was wanted for a burglary. According to Ar-Rahmaan, it was originally believed that a warrant was never issued for his apprehension. Because of this, attorney Ripper filed a motion for suppression, as they believed the federal government could not prosecute Ar-Rahmaan for things that happened during an incident they did not have a warrant for.

However, according to court documents, the federal government produced evidence they had a warrant for Ar-Rahmaan. Because of this, attorney Ripper dismissed his motion or a suppression hearing, since the factual basis for the suppression hearing no longer existed.

However, Ar-Rahmaan believed his suppression hearing was withdrawn without his consent, a belief he vocalized to Judge Mattice.

“I feel like I’ve denied my rights because of the suppression case (being dismissed),” said Ar-Rahmaan, “I was really looking forward to exoneration.”

When Judge Mattice told the defendant he had the option of representing himself at a trial, Ar-Rahmaan shot down that suggestion by saying, “I don’t know the language you speak” and asked for a new attorney. Judge Mattice eliminated that idea, pointing out how expensive federal attorneys are.

“What have you done to make it fair for taxpayers to pay for two or three attorneys,” asked the judge after Ar-Rahmaan said he had the right to have two or three shots at having an attorney who could represent him well.

Ar-Rahmaan even admitted to needing to plead guilty if the interaction with the police was not suppressed, as he freely said the gun was found on him. However, during the plea session, the defendant continued to make comments about how he believed he was being forced into pleading guilty.

He told Judge Mattice that he felt entrapped, and that agents were “using a female” to get him in a situation to be arrested. And yet when Judge Mattice asked him if he still wanted to plead guilty, Ar-Rahmaan begrudgingly continued.

But as the guilty plea continued, and Ar-Rahmaan persisted in grumbling about how his representation was poor and he believed he was denied justice, Judge Mattice began to ask if he truly wanted to plead guilty after each question. An exasperated judge finally stopped the guilty plea midway through.

He said, “I’m going to refuse your guilty plea, and you’re going to represent yourself at your own trial,” as a shocked courtroom looked on. The trial date will be set at a later time.

 

 


Latest Hamilton County Arrest Report

Stormwater Fees Increasing In Collegedale

All Tax Evasion Charges Dismissed Against Soddy Daisy Funeral Home Director After All Money Owed Is Repaid


Here is the latest Hamilton County arrest report: ATWOOD, SARAH NICOLE 102 DAISY AVE SODDY DAISY, 37379 Age at Arrest: 30 years old Arresting Agency: Hamilton County NONSUPPORT AND ... (click for more)

Fees for stormwater regulation and control, including land disturbances, will be increasing in the city of Collegedale. When property is disturbed, it requires time and attention from the city ... (click for more)

All tax evasion charges against a Soddy Daisy funeral home director have been dismissed after he fully paid off the debt. Cade Coulter Williamson had faced 14 felony counts. The charges ... (click for more)



Breaking News

Latest Hamilton County Arrest Report

Here is the latest Hamilton County arrest report: ATWOOD, SARAH NICOLE 102 DAISY AVE SODDY DAISY, 37379 Age at Arrest: 30 years old Arresting Agency: Hamilton County NONSUPPORT AND FLAGRANT NONSUPPORT BEARD, ANGELA JOYCE 477 BRADMEYER DRIVE DAYTON, 37321 Age at Arrest: 58 years old Arresting Agency: Hamilton County FAILURE TO APPEAR CRIBBS, CHARLES JEROME ... (click for more)

Stormwater Fees Increasing In Collegedale

Fees for stormwater regulation and control, including land disturbances, will be increasing in the city of Collegedale. When property is disturbed, it requires time and attention from the city to issue permits. The current fee structure does not allow Collegedale to recover a reasonable fee to reimburse the actual costs, officials said. At the commission meeting Monday night, ... (click for more)

Opinion

Mark Kimsey Was The Real Deal And Larger Than Life

Rest In Peace to one of the most honorable, intelligent and entertaining human beings I have ever met in my entire life. Mark Kimsey, you were an eloquent and extremely talented writer and the epitome of what an American Law Enforcement Officer should be - courageous, scholarly, empathetic, proficient and selfless. Words can not begin to express how much you are respected ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: Laughing With Jim Murray

When I was in high school, I would love it when the “Newspapers in Education” would roll around once a week. The Chattanooga Times was a real Godsend because it offered me something interesting to read during class and, man, I would pounce on the paper. I would immediately find the syndicated columnist, Jim Murray, and revel in his every word. He was - and this I believe to this ... (click for more)

Sports

Topgolf Opens Second Open-Air Concept In Chattanooga

Topgolf Entertainment Group, a global sports and entertainment company, announced its newest venue located in Chattanooga will open its doors to the public on Friday. The new venue is the second community-focused, completely open-air concept from Topgolf, featuring a technology-driven, single-level design. Topgolf Chattanooga features 36 climate-controlled hitting bays outfitted ... (click for more)

Chattanooga Red Wolves Win 1-0 In Chi Memorial Stadium Opener

The Chattanooga Red Wolves played their first home match in newly finished CHI Memorial Stadium Saturday night. The Covid-19 reduced sold out crowd was rewarded with a 1-0 win as the Red Wolves beat FC Tuscon on a Greg Hurst goal in the second half. Hurst scored in the 53th minute to give the Red Wolves a 1-0 lead. Red Wolves keeper Alex Mangels saved a FC Tuscon PK in the second ... (click for more)