Attacks On Signal Founder C.E. James Unfair, Unfounded, Great-Grandson Declares

“Are We Really Going To Write Him Out Of History Because Of A Few Clauses In Some 100-Year-Old Deeds?” Chattanooga Attorney Stuart James Asks

Saturday, August 1, 2020 - by Judy Frank
C.E. James, Signal Mountain founder
C.E. James, Signal Mountain founder
Current efforts to remove a monument honoring Signal Mountain founder/developer C.E. James “don’t pass the smell test,” according to James’ great-grandson.

Chattanooga attorney Stuart James, a former longtime Signal Mountain resident, said Friday that his family is distraught over recent charges that his great grandfather – who, as a developer, literally and figuratively left marks all over Hamilton County– was actually a closet racist. 

That charge came from Signal Town Manager Boyd Veal during a July 27 town council meeting highlighted by Mr. Veal’s request that a monument honoring C.E. James be removed from a small park named after the town’s founder/developer. 

Mr. Veal told council members that his request grew out of his discovery of several 100-year-old deeds recording the sale of properties on Walden’s Ridge by the Mountain Land Co., operated by James and several family members. Those deeds, he noted, prohibited the “sale, lease or other transfer of property to any negro, mulatto or other person of color.” 

The attack on his grandfather probably could have been anticipated, the Chattanooga attorney said, given the current national climate and widespread efforts to do away with numerous historic monuments and symbols. 

But what it doesn’t take into consideration, he added, is the fact that C.E. James is a Hamilton County icon who made numerous contributions to local towns and cities. 

“He wasn’t in the KKK,” declared the attorney, who has fired off outraged protests on Facebook and elsewhere about the treatment of his great-grandfather. “He wasn’t a Confederate general.” 

Instead, his grandson reminded anybody who would listen, C.E. James “built the James Building (Chattanooga’s first skyscraper) . . . He owned a lot of land on Walden’s Ridge . . . (and) built the road up Signal Mountain. He was the town’s first mayor. His son (W.T. James) was the second mayor . . . He built the hotel (which is now owned and occupied by Alexian Brothers). He gave away the land where the (Signal Mountain Golf and Country Club) is now located. 

“Are we really going to write him out of history because of a few clauses in some 100-year-old deeds?” he demanded Friday. 

The Chattanooga attorney is not alone in his dismay over the treatment of historic monuments such as the one honoring the founder of Signal Mountain. 

“We are suffering from ‘monumental’ confusion about historical statues, place names and symbols,” Washington Post columnist Max Boot wrote in a July 23 column. 

“We need to draw some fine distinctions here. Study the specifics of each individual to decide whether he or she is still worth honoring,” the columnist argued. “The rule of thumb should be that those who contributed a great deal to the development of our country deserve to be recognized, however flawed they were as human beings.” 

For example, Mr. Boot wrote, “(Ulysses S.) Grant fought to defeat the Confederacy as a Union general and then, as president, he fought against the Ku Klux Klan. That far outweighs the fact that he briefly owned one slave whom he freed before the Civil War.” 

On Signal Mountain, Mr. Veal’s recommendation that the town remove the monument honoring its founder triggered vigorous debate. 

“Why do we need to talk about and discuss this today?”Carolyn Longphre wrote on League of Signal Mountain Voters, a Facebook site maintained by former Signal Mayor Paul Hendricks. 

“Mr. James lived when things were different,” she pointed out. “Discussing those times won’t change them. This is ridiculous!” 

Van Bunch disagreed. 

“Yes, deed restrictions were commonplace,” he wrote. “As were lynchings. It was against the law to integrate at any level in TN from around 1905 until Brown v. Board (of  Education) in 1954. I am sure the restrictive covenants for Carriage Hill contain those provisions. White fragility.” 

“(M)ore reasons to step back and condemn the practice and not the individuals,” former mayor Hendricks responded. 

“(T)imes change,” Jeff Duncan added. “Norms and ideals change, and thankfully so. My deed in Walden contains restrictions against running a brothel, gambling or distilling. Dang it! Should’ve read the fine print before I signed.” 

Friday, attorney James said he has not spoken to Mr. Veal or any other current Signal official about the current situation. 

Former Mayor Hendricks is a longtime friend, he noted, so he wants to discuss the issue with him before taking any further action. 

The deeds “discovered” by Mr. Veal come as no surprise, he noted. 

He first saw them 20 to 30 years ago, he said, when he and other family members interested in genealogy were researching their famous developer ancestor. 

What’s ironic about the current controversy, he noted, is that his great-grandfather – who relied on attorneys and real estate associates to handle property transfers – probably didn’t even draw up those deeds. 

Such clauses were common at the time Signal Mountain was being developed, he noted; any search would reveal hundreds of similar legal documents detailing historic property transfers throughout Hamilton County and the surrounding area. 

The full text of Stuart James’ facebook post about his great grandfather reads as follows: 

 

I have been making several posts about my great grandfather C.E. James. Unfortunately, I have not done him justice nor have I appropriately condemned what some on Signal Mountain are trying to do.

My brother is in tears, my sister indignant, my family broken hearted. The thought of Boyd Veal saying C.E. James is racist tears at our family’s heart. Mr. Veal reads a few deeds, draws conclusions and rushes to condemn. Mr. Veal has no idea who C.E. James was or what he did.

As a third generation resident of Signal Mountain Mr. Veal appears woefully ignorant about a man whose genius “conceived the great dam of the Tennessee River . . . . "

Unfortunately, I had forgotten what Mr. James did for Signal Mountain,Chattanooga, Hamilton County, and the great State of Tennessee. I did not do him justice in my previous posts. I forgot about how this community admired C.E.James until my sister sent me his eulogy. 

The following are the words written about C.E. James upon his death. As you will see, C.E. James was a pillar of integrity and gave back to his community, investing over one million dollars into the public good on Signal Mountain and undertaking public endeavors expending more than 36 million dollars. He was a man of integrity and vision.

We need more people like him today. Here is a description of who C.E. James really was…

“He erected the first skyscraper here, he bound the great commonwealths of Georgia and Alabama to the volunteer state with rails of steel and spikes of iron when he was yet a young man; he ran the bear from the jungle and the catamount from his hiding place on Walden’s Ridge and founded there a city, peopled and lighted it, expending over one million dollars for the public good, a blessing to this state and to this city forever. 

“Finally his genius conceived the great dam of the Tennessee River, and he took the dirt and the rock, and the sand and the cement, and made it into a concrete thing, and picked it up and blew into it the breath of life and caused it to reach out its arms of fire and power and energy and send its force and light into every nook and corner of this great commonwealth, carrying the message of progress and civilization. He did all this because God had given him a great heart, a great mind and a great soul; and in all these splendid public endeavors, in the expenditure of more than thirty-six million dollars. No man or woman has ever charged that, by mistake or design, a dollar of money has ever wrongfully gone into the pockets of Charles E. James. 

“No other man, from Bristol to Memphis, in private life or in public life, had done one tenth for Tennessee that has been done by this man of vision and of unparalleled business foresight. He stands singly and alone among the builders of the south,  “The Greatest Roman of Them All.” His manhood undefiled, his integrity unquestioned, his mind a dynamo of nerve and thought and action, his heart as red as the crimson flush of a summer sunset.” 

This was the man that was my great grandfather and I am proud to be his great grandson.


Signal Mountain Closes Pool After Lifeguard Tests Positive For COVID

62% Of UTC Courses To Be Completely Online; Chattanooga State To Have Only 1 Entrance And Students Must Fill Out Questionnaire

Hamilton County Has Another Death From The Virus And 84 More Cases; Tennessee Has 42 More Deaths


Signal Mountain has closed its pool after a lifeguard tested positive for COVID-19. Officials said, "We do not believe it was contracted at the pool facility. The guard’s most recent shifts ... (click for more)

Local educators informed the Rotary Club about their experiences in navigating a COVID-19 world during Thursday’s Zoom conference. Hamilton County superintendent Dr. Bryan Johnson, Chattanooga ... (click for more)

Hamilton County had another 84 new coronavirus cases on Thursday, as well as another death bringing the toll to 50. The number of COVID patients in Intensive Care is now at 39 after Wednesday's ... (click for more)



Breaking News

Signal Mountain Closes Pool After Lifeguard Tests Positive For COVID

Signal Mountain has closed its pool after a lifeguard tested positive for COVID-19. Officials said, "We do not believe it was contracted at the pool facility. The guard’s most recent shifts were this past Wednesday and Saturday during the morning sessions. "Given the protocols in place, risk of exposure for patrons was extremely low. However, we feel it appropriate to provide ... (click for more)

62% Of UTC Courses To Be Completely Online; Chattanooga State To Have Only 1 Entrance And Students Must Fill Out Questionnaire

Local educators informed the Rotary Club about their experiences in navigating a COVID-19 world during Thursday’s Zoom conference. Hamilton County superintendent Dr. Bryan Johnson, Chattanooga State president Dr. Rebecca Ashford, and UT-Chattanooga’s Chancellor Dr. Steven Angle shared the virtual stage. Dr. Johnson gave a brief explanation about Hamilton County’s plan to deal ... (click for more)

Opinion

Busloads Of COVID-19 Headed This Way - And Response

Peaceful protests are a constitutional right of all Americans under normal conditions. These are not normal conditions. Atlanta is a major "hot spot" of new cases and total cases of the virus. So forgive me for saying this, but Atlantans, STAY HOME! Busloads with an estimated total of 500 protestors are probably bringing coronavirus to Miller Plaza Friday night at 6:30 in ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: We’re Out Of ‘Touch’

I’ve been a “people person” for all of my life and not until this past weekend did I become aware I have been suffering badly due to “lack of touch.” A lifelong friend passed along a Daily Devotional where a gifted pastor in Massachusetts mourned the fact that – get this – she had been touched by another human being only four times in the last four months. As I paused to dwell on ... (click for more)

Sports

Chattanooga FC Defender Raymond Lee Moves To USL Championship Pittsburgh Riverhounds

Chattanooga Football Club is announcing that the club has finalized a deal with Pittsburgh Riverhounds in the USL Championship that will send defender Raymond Lee to the Keystone state, pending league and federation approval. “From a club standpoint, it is always difficult to see a good player and better person leave” said Peter Fuller, Head Coach, Chattanooga FC. “But I think ... (click for more)

UTC's Sept. 3 Football Game With Western Kentucky Is Delayed

The UTC football game set at Western Kentucky on Sept. 3 will be delayed. Western Kentucky Director of Athletics Todd Stewart said, “We have had continuing discussions with Chattanooga regarding the date of our 2020 football game. Given the recent changes among many programs regarding their start date for the upcoming football season, WKU and Chattanooga have mutually agreed ... (click for more)