Woman Charged In Fatal Ooltewah Stabbing Found Guilty Of Reckless Aggravated Assault

  • Thursday, March 23, 2023

A woman charged in a fatal stabbing in Ooltewah was found guilty of reckless aggravated assault on Thursday.

Kimberly Smart, who was 32 at the time of the July 17, 2021, incident, was charged with criminal homicide in the death of 34-year-old Kristal Michelle Reno. She was tried on a lesser charge of voluntary manslaughter in the courtroom of Judge Boyd Patterson.

Felony aggravated assault in Tennessee carries 3-15 years.

 An attorney told the jury on Tuesday that the fatal stabbing occurred when Ms. Smart became upset that Ms. Reno had taken some roach motels (traps) out of her car.

Alex Shoaf of the public defender's office said Ms. Reno "liked to fight." He said the two women argued over the roach motel issue, then Ms. Smart stabbed her with a kitchen knife that Ms. Reno threw at her.

He said when Ms. Reno began bleeding profusely, Ms. Smart "tried her very best to save her."

Prosecutor Kevin Loper said the knife wound severed two major arteries in the victim's neck. He said the victim "had no chance."

He said Ms. Smart then "fled out the back door."

The jury saw body cam footage of paramedics trying to clean large amounts of blood off Ms. Reno.

Another body cam video showed Ms. Smart being located by a deputy near the house at 9311 Bill Reed Road in Ooltewah where the incident happened.

She said, "I didn't mean to do it. It was an accident. She threw the knife and all I did was defend myself. I did everything I could to help her."

A man at the house said Ms. Smart appeared to have tripped over a trash can while holding the knife.

The victim was transported by Hamilton County EMS to a local hospital where she succumbed to her injuries.

There were eight people living in the "modest" house, it was stated.

Breaking News
Frye Mansion At Wildwood Destroyed By Fire
Frye Mansion At Wildwood Destroyed By Fire
  • 5/10/2025

A Wildwood, Ga., mansion that was built in 1896 has been destroyed by fire. A number of fire units responed to 1860 Pope Creek Road, but the historic house was completely engulfed by flames. ... more

Man In Critical Condition After Being Pulled From Duplex Fire In East Chattanooga
Man In Critical Condition After Being Pulled From Duplex Fire In East Chattanooga
  • 5/10/2025

A man was in critical condition after being pulled from a burning duplex in East Chattanooga on Saturday morning. Firefighters had to knock flames down as they made their way through the home ... more

Misty Carelli Dies From Car Crash Injuries That Earlier Claimed Her Husband
  • 5/10/2025

Misty Carelli, 52, of Hixson has died from injuries suffered in a car crash in Mount Nebo, West Va., last Monday. Her husband, Ronald Carelli, died earlier after their vehicle ran into the ... more